This is where you’re objectively wrong. Boomstick is not baked into the spec, it is a talent point. Talents are supposed to be optional boosters to abilities baked into the spec, or additional flavor abilities that, again, are supposed to be opt-in.
Again, your argument is weak.
Fury Warriors a Melee. Raging Blow is talent node meant to be an ability, but supports the class nonetheless. Your argument falls apart.
Protection Paladin’s Shield of Righteousness is baked into the spec, not added as a Talent Node. Your argument falls apart again.
Blizzard, and you, cannot seem to decide what theme Survival Hunter is: is it melee-midrange hybrid, or is it melee and ranged?
Beside that tangent, my argument remains the same: give us players an optional talent node between Boomstick and Fury of the Eagle.
And since you seem to constantly be referencing other class, I will use Arms/Fury Warrior as reference here:
This would be the exact same as having Avatar be a mandatory talent node in the first tier, as Boomstick is for Survival Hunters.
Looks like the elves can use guns just fine here based on the quest text. They seem happy to use Sniper Rifles
Can you avoid Boomstick? No?
Could you avoid Explosive Trap in Legion? No?
Did Legion have the talent tree design that we have in Midnight? No?
Do you think there’s a reason every spec has a bunch of baseline abilities forced into the talent tree? They needed to stretch these out between level 10-90, which is why every spec has rotational abilities on the spec tree. I am happy to go through spec by spec with you to show you this, but I have a feeling you have an excuse ready.
It looks like Raging Blow is a talent that Fury Warriors can’t avoid. That sounds a lot like Boomstick. Is Raging Blow not a talent?
I meant Avenger’s Shield, my apologies. Can you check to see if Avenger’s Shield is a talent or is it baked into the spec?
Well, since the spec theme has been the same since 2016 and the gameplay theme has been the same since 2018, it sure seems like they have made the decision. You just don’t like it.
Did you know many melee DPS have rotational ranged abilities? This isn’t a real problem for people who actually play the game.
You know what, you’re right. The spec theme has been the same since 2016: a mess of archetypes shoehorned into one another. I don’t like it, and wish Blizzard would do better.
You are free to not like it, I just don’t think they’re ever going to change the guerilla adaptive spec to be a one-note zugzug hunter. Sorry. Maybe after the healer spec they’ll add a 5th spec that’s a melee BM
Hunter as a class does not need a 5th spec for melee Beast Mastery. We already have Survival. The issue is not the existence of these fantasies, it is where Blizzard has chosen to place them.
Right now there are 4 core abilities in the 1st Tier Talent Row… when really there should be only one: Raptor Strike. This conveys the baseline gameplay identity of Survival: a hunter who fights primarily through melee combat.
If Wildfire Bomb, Kill Command, and Boomstick were rearranged to sit in the 2nd/3rd Tier Talent Row:
Explosives (Wildfire Bomb) to the bottom left.
Beast synergy (Kill Command + Takedown) to the bottom center.
Firearms (Boomstick) to the bottom right.
… Then players will have agency and freedom to pick their expression of a Survival Hunter. Talent Points are, after all, Player Investment into the Specialization of their Class.
As the talent placements currently sit, players are forced to invest into all 3 fantasy archetypes in the 1st talent row. Naturally this leads to friction. Some players do not want to invest in the firearm toting fantasy. Others do not want to utilize bombs. Many will enjoy both of those archetypes, and there is nothing wrong with that.
What is wrong however is expecting players who prefer one expression of Survival to accept all three archetypes as mandatory.
I think it’d be much, much easier to make barbed shot a barbed slash ability than cram this on SV, melee BM feels a lot more easier and a lot better fit for your idealized version of hunter
I have a feeling it wouldn’t be as easy as you suggest. Survival already has all the abilities it needs to be melee oriented or melee-midrange with all the fantasies currently presented. Changing a single ability does not suddenly make Beast Mastery the ideal Melee Hunter spec. It would need a major overhaul, similar to how Survival was reworked in the Legion Expansion.
The problem with this argument is:
Rexxar is presented as the face of Survival in-game through the Specialization Artwork, even though his lore identity is undoubtedly a Beast Master.
Unfortunately that is not the argument I am making.
My argument: given that Survival already exists as a melee hunter, can the talent tree better support opt-in agency of the different expressions presented, rather than forcing the player to accept all three?
Do you genuinely think making Barbed Shot function at melee is harder than completely making two different specs on the SV tree with choice nodes and different branches? Come on.
Well, yes, if you want melee hunter to be brad new spec that’s primitive and ignores technology, melee Beast Master is your ideal.
No, because that’s not how the game has ever worked, nor will it ever work, because it would be an insane amount of work to make 40 specs in the game have two to three different variations of “opt in”
And the description of survival in game is presented as being an adaptive ranger, not a naturalistic woodsman, which eclipses spec art you see for 2 second a day if you swap your talents around. And the spec icon is a yellow elf hiding in some leaves.
Does that supersede Rexxar?
Rexxar is a terrible example of what to aim a spec design for, since all he does is auto attack and use Warrior abilities.
Which doesn’t mean they meant for people to fall over themselves thinking a spec into which they moved all the explosives, made them the highest priority skills therein, made them the spec-unique interact animation, and initially made them the only skill unique to their spec followers… must be a tech-less primalist.
They did, but you overstate the extent of those NPC inspirations and how much exactly those kinds of overstatements are what caused so much of that that Frankensteining.
Again, Rexxar had zero hunter-unique effects in his WoW iterations before Legion. He hah had (and still has) no Survival skills outside of Wildfire Bomb in any other game iterations outside of WoW.
Huln did not exist before Legion, and arrived with solely a Trample skill (shared with VDH, with a close cousin in Warrior’s Dragon Charge), a semi-circular channel of flailing slashes never added to found on Survival, a to-target charge, and a self-heal CD. His questline involved no tracking, no hunting, just windshield-wiping spear from side to side. For every situation, his approach was just to charge in, be mad, and swing incessantly. That’s… far more akin to a Fury Warrior with a single polearm than it is any sort of Hunter.
Meanwhile, the only skill Survival actually added in common with Huln… was Harpoon, but even that was acquired independently long before we’d ever met the guy. Even Fury of the Eagle… wasn’t a skill used by Huln. He had nothing that functioned that way.
Meanwhile, we got Mongoose Bite, Raptor Strike, Flanking Strike, Carve, Butchery, Hatchet Toss (none of which were used by Huln, and only the filler strikes among which were ever used by Rexxar as mere renames to his earlier Cleave, Throw, and Strike)… and 11 unique pieces of tech.
Adding a second tree wasn’t a problem in itself. It allows for, say, an MM Hunter to decide on both what kinds of the basic Hunter parts they want to theme themselves towards and to what extent they may want to add bits of SV or BM into their kit while still having a manageable tree for their core stuff.
On this I’ll agree. Hero Trees were a step in a bit too weird and unnecessary a direction.
It being forced isn’t really a problem unless you consider, say…
BM being forced to take Bestial Wrath,
MM being forced to take Trueshot,
Fury being forced to take Rampage,
Arms being forced to take Colossus Smash,
Protection being forced to take Shield Wall,
Arcane being forced to take Touch of the Magi,
etc.
…as likewise inherently problematic. The problem are just ones from the skill itself, not it’s being forced, namely that…
Despite shortening virtually all other channels to 2 seconds or less if not usable from 25+ yards, Boomstick is 3 seconds;
Boomstick’s value is wholly linear (both through CDR/MF-stacks and its own damage) despite of course incurring the same CD regardless of how many shots you get off, so it naturally punishes being ended early; and
It uses an animation component we would normally expect to be customizable, but in this case isn’t (compared that to when Devourer briefly still had a green Eye Beam and how quickly that was corrected);
…and from our obligatory Primal Surge’s proximity to Lethal Calibration making the latter talent virtually obligatory, too, so we couldn’t opt out of its faster AoE-CDs in AoE.
Apart from that, though, it’s just a buffed FotE (our former left-wing capstone formerly buried below basic WFB upgrades), with 80% more range than in DF, more reliable damage, and a better CDR loop available to it. And given given the removal of Butchery / Flanking Strike for being “redundant” with either WFB (especially with Shrapnel Bomb) or Takedown itself, respectively, that’s not something we should be shocked to have seen move up the tree.
Which was a mistake that should be corrected.
His skills, from Huffer (Summon Boar) to Misha (Summon Bear) to Leokk (not part of his former Hero unit, as he just used Storm Hammer and Stampede instead, but absolutely part of his lore), are right there on Pack Leader. That’s where his picture would have made sense. The Hero Spec was made specifically to imitate him, while not a single Survival skill was made off of Rexxar. His sole connection is the arbitrary namesake for Legion SV’s most hated passive.
Putting his picture on Survival, though? No. That makes no sense. He’s sometimes been a melee fighter (well, in WC3, if you ignore the times he can auto from range; in HotS and the comics, he’s ranged) with pets, yes, but he has never expressed a single SV mechanic, nor anything distinguishable from a Warrior with a companion outside of animal summons — skills much more obviously related to BM, especially since Legion.
Within the norms of modern oversimplified low-choice talent trees? Probably not. You’d just be able to emphasize or deemphasize certain aspects, just as on most other talent trees.
Ideally, though? Sure.
At least unlike… say… Rogue, our mid-tier ability hasn’t been baselined, so there is the small possibility of a choice node for Boomstick if it wouldn’t be too invasive, while some other trees do have choice nodes in places similar to that of Wildfire Bomb, so even it could perhaps see an alternative, too. Doubtful, as just upgrading it to Shrapnel Bomb or the like later still makes clear that it remains part of Wildfire Bomb on tooltips, but maybe if WFB and its alternative both shared a prefix by which to refer to them.
I think you overestimate the amount of work this would require as surely as Rare is overestimating how hard it would be to situate a melee-BM option, though.
That said…
If your goal is to prune technology entirely back to the level 1–10 base, though, there’s no reason for that goal to be met within the tree that has always specifically been the one to offer way more tech than the others.
It would make far more sense instead for melee variants of basic ranged skills to be baselined with a faint advantage (which MM would immediately make up for and therefore safely ignore) that would allow BM the option of going melee for almost no advantage in practice, but some situational ones in M+ for if one has plenty of immediate range and ease of positioning from having enough ranged but falls a little short on availability of interrupts easily in reach anyways, hardiness, or direct mobility.
I honestly think the OG melee redesign for survival was more of iron horde theme. Something along the lines of modern iron horde (grenades, turret that later got turned into spitting cobra) and the Thunderlord clan from WoD. Especially the mobs from Iron Docks. Disengage, Caltrops they even had something similar to carve.
why would they make a brand new class to move everything cool hunters does to the new class? wouldnt it make more sense to make a brand new class thats the nature hippie you want?
yeah fair they’re not gonna change the last 10 years of SV identity and fantasy because loudmouths on the forums complain that it doesn’t match their headcanon
Yes, because your proposal overestimates the amount of work it will take to revamp Beast Mastery from Ranged to Melee; it is never as simple as changing one ability. Besides…
You’re conflating Specialization with Spec Identity Expression; the themes within the Spec itself. Blizzard has already made 4 competing Expressions within Survival:
Beast-synergy (Kill Command, the very first node)
Raptor Strike (Melee)
Wildfire Bomb (Explosives)
And Boomstick (Firearms)
The issue I have, and I feel this is the same issue many players have, is Blizzard forcing all 4 Expressions to be mandatory when we really want them as opt-in. We do not want Raptor Strike, Wildfire Bomb, and Boomstick all to be sitting in the 1st Talent Tier and would rather have them in the 2nd or 3rd Talent Tier. This way:
All 4 Identity Expressions still co-exist.
Players can choose their flavor of Survival Hunter.
We’re not talking about my ideal fantasy spec. We are talking about what already exists. Think of it like a face-down trident… the Talent Tree I mean:
Left side of the fork: Explosives (I will avoid this side).
Center of the fork: Melee and Beast Synergy; primitive and ignores technology (My Rexxar identity).
Right side of the fork: Firearms (I will avoid this side too).
Again, the issue is: Blizzard introduces all three identity expressions as mandatory investments before the player has the opportunity to pick for themselves. This naturally creates friction between players who all share the Survival Spec, but want to express its identity differently. So, when we ask for talent identities to be moved for better player agency over the themes Blizzard themselves have presented, and you reply with:
You’re side-stepping my argument.
We are not talking about 40 Specs, just one: Survival.
Blizzard has rearranged and swapped talent nodes and clusters in the past; Primal Surge is a good example, as it is being moved from 3rd Tier Talents to I think 2nd Tier Talents with the upcoming Season 2 of Midnight.
I don’t understand why you’re refusing to acknowledge the Rexxar fantasy when elements of it already exist within Survival.
Either way, I have said my piece. I think rearranging a room (Survival spec) is easier than refurnishing a room (Beast Mastery spec) to match the other.
i mean, bm is at a unique area where it absolutely can be melee. because all its rotation is best based. you only have ss and bs as your only character abilities.
thats really up to blizzard isnt it. your talking from a perspective of someone who has no intention of doing content beyond world content. anyone else would just copy wowhead for whatever build regardless of theme or fantasy. your basically askinbg blizzard to revamp the whole talent system to fit you and the 5 people who also want this. ill tell you the same thing ive told the person who wanted a “no wake of ashes build” for ret paladin.
blizzard will probably not cater to you and your small minority.
this isnt a survival only thing tho, this is something that happens for every spec. this level of customization is just unrealistic and i feel like you only hurt yourself fighting for it so adamantly. throwing yourself into conversations where people dont worry about that at all.
even then you open up a new can of worms that we see in mm and bm.. pointless trap talents. despite people saying they would take a damage loss if they get a single pet as bm, you now have people complaining about how their choice does less damage then the norm.
heck you rather have choice nodes or seperation instead of asking for a glyph that wouldnt result in a damage loss. so theres nothing anyone can really discuss with you
and the replacement they added is something thats still mandatory to get. like we said would happen…
it only exists as a hero tree now and that hero tree is shared with BM. it seems intentional