Queued for Shattered halls dungeon via Chromie Time on my level 42 hunter (because I wanted the bow, for transmog reasons mostly). We had another hunter, two paladins, and a warrior in our group. On the second boss (warbringer om’rogg), our ret paladin got an intellect dagger, and the holy paladin got the bow. The loot on the other bosses was fine, just the loot from that boss was broken big time.
This has been broken for years. I recall several times as a druid tank trading bows to a hunter that I should not have received.