I’m on the cusp of Millenial and Gen X depending on your source of truth for all that stuff. My interest in RP hasn’t changed but it also has been pretty low-key since forever. I think it’s been better these past few weeks than it has been on WoW for me in years though!
I dug tabletop stuff when it was at an actual table. RP gaming is great in that environment. It’s more of an outlet for acting than writing if you’re a player – where the DM is the storyteller, and we help that be a good story by truly being IC in terms of making choices as our character (their traits and flaws and all that).
I don’t believe WoW, or any MMO, is well equipped to suit RP. On the player level, it’s mostly about how/why characters are created and the in-game tools/support we have for RP (basically none without addons). On the game level, it’s the story and, again, the in-game tools/support we have for RP.
RP, as an outlet for storytelling, is often missing critical components of a good story. Bashing together plot points with tabletop elements in a digital environment falls short, in no small part due to these missing pieces. Good stories are driven by the character(s) as they transform from a personification of an anti-theme to a theme. If you’re missing theme, you’re missing the soul of story… so if it feels hollow, that’s because it is.
What doesn’t help is that WoW’s story is also missing these important pieces.
So the type of RP I’m finding to be great is walkup stuff, which returns me to it being a bit of character acting – but also writing because it’s text! The big picture, in this case, exists in my mind. The encounters are essentially vignettes (and boy have they been entertaining lately).
I think you hit plateaus with any hobby or skill. Moving away from stuff is often based on temperament, free time, other interests popping up etc.
For me, RP has always taken a backseat to gaming itself and was never my outlet for writing – probably makes it easy to maintain that level of interest. Stuff like music has become more of a lifestyle than a hobby, so I guess some things stay light or fade away while others just intensify.