But… the artifact weapons weren’t what raised the Horsemen.
You’re given the power to raise the Four Horsemen by the Lich King himself. As the quest text says:
The Four Horsemen were no ordinary death knights, they were born of pure, unholy power gifted from the Lich King to Kel’thuzad
This unholy power to raise the dead has now been passed to you, Deathlord. I am sure you will wield it with great conviction.
Kel’Thuzad raised the original four horsemen and he didn’t have no fancy artifact weapons when he did so. He was granted that power by the Lich King, and he used it. You’re simply doing what Kel’thuzad did when he raised the original group into undeath.
True enough, we didn’t raise them on our own. We had the Lich King giving us that power.
Since the Lich King is effectively no more (as there is no longer a Helm of Domination to put on Bolvar’s head and make him the Lich King), it’s unclear if we’ll ever be able to raise more death knights as powerful as the Horsemen. Even Kel’thuzad needed the Lich King’s power to raise the first group.
… Death Knights are created through necromancy, the raising of the dead. The Deathlord and Ebon Blade necromancers only being capable of raising Death Knights is headcanon.
Chris Metzen can be heard explaining this in the 2010 lore panel of Blizzcon aswell, if you’re interested.
It was a smart move from a business perspective. Advertising works and they were getting so much negative advertising about Shadowlands from a vocal minority of players and super subscription YouTube CCs that the smart business thing was to pull the plug on SL.
So a season got cut which no doubt was the Arthas / healm season.
Now the SL haters are blaming the devs for a problem which they caused and the developers had to solve.
If you start a Death Knight (one of the original races though, so you get the Wrath starting experience) and look around the space where you talk to Instructor Razuvious and get your runeblade, you can see Cult of the Damned necromancers raising potential Death Knights from a pile of Argent Dawn corpses. The Death Knights in question are then judged by Razuvious. If they’re worthy, they get sent to get their runeblade and armor. If they’re not worthy, ghouls are summoned to kill the death knight and devour the remains.
The Knights of the Ebon Blade have developed a work-around for that issue. They’ve created the Ball Cap of Really Effective Persuasion which has … mostly the same effect. The only drawback is that about half of the new recruits are only interested in monster truck rallies.
This is not true. The Lich King is not involved in the raising of Death Knights in Acherus (he’s just standing over at the balcony looking out over the soon to be destroyed Scarlet Crusade villages). It’s just Cult of the Damned necromancers doing the work, that’s it.
And post-Lich King death, there are quests in Cataclysm which make it clear that powerful Scourge can perform rituals to turn Paladins into Death Knights, which is almost what happens to Gidwin Goldbraids in the Eastern Plaguelands. You save him at the end of the main storyline for the zone, but he could have been turned into a Death Knight had we not shown up when we did.
You’re not reading what’s being typed. The Lich King doesn’t have to literally preside over every Death Knight, but his presence–his death magic–is needed to create more Death Knights.
The Cult of the Damned are a proxy. The Death Knights are a proxy. They are conduits for the Lich King to work THROUGH.
Death Knights are more complicated than simple necromancy. They require Death Magic. Only the Lich King possess the Death Magic to make new Death Knights.
The Helm of Domination only forces compliance, which was destroyed by the Primus, so the Lich King cannot compel Death Knights to do his bidding.
Since Pelagos is the Arbiter of the Shadowlands, I highly doubt he’s going to allow Bolvar to simply raise more Death Knights without some pretty heavy strings attached.