I could for about two months, then the real forum screaming begins.
Classic “plateaus/ends.” A lot of fans don’t realize this. They are having fun now, at low level. They see a different community now, at low level. For most of the people playing it, things are not serious business yet.
Having to eventually raid will ruin it for most players. Even ones from Vanilla, who were in ideal raiding guilds where things worked out, might not have that perfect situation again; People don’t know how rare that was. They don’t realize how many people had to be in a guild, for it to field 40 people at a raid. They don’t realize how you had to make EVERY SINGLE RAID, three or more nights a week, for five hours a night, to get DKP to then be able to bid on something that the kids who always showed up would otherwise get. It was like a full time job, so the people without those had the advantage (or the ones who had a set work schedule, during the day.)
I know exactly what Classic is/Vanilla was. The one thing I won’t be doing is raiding. So for gear acquisition, I’ll be doing battlegrounds for the rare/epic set at some point (on a hunter.) I did that in BC, when the season one set was from regular battleground honor; It was actually pretty fun! It is the one thing I never did in Classic, while it is on my time and the only auto-queue content in Classic (since no LFR LFG.)
I liked Legion. I thought it was the best expansion yet (even better than Vanilla, way better in fact.) But would I play Legion forever, if that was all this character had? Well, no. I’d plateau, as I did before Legion ended, since I don’t raid. So near the end I had all the legendarys, and had some really great pieces from greater invasion bosses. Eventually, I would have got as good as I could get, with my playstyle. At that point, as fun as Legion was I’d still be “done.” I’d probably get bored at it and not feel like playing it for a year more, or forever.
That is the main problem with Classic. People will plateau, then stagnate. There wasn’t that much to the game. It wasn’t mount/pet/mog collection central. Some people won’t raid at all, some will plateau with MC, some with BWL, etc. Sure, they’ll have fun walking around with the complete BWL set, but then what? “Retirement”, in an MMORPG, is just not something that most people want to play. Nor will everyone just want to play Classic for years, making alt after alt.
Even for the only thing I did not do in Classic, it is limited. I’ll do battlegrounds, getting the rare BG set; That was not really “hard”, just took time. I’ll try to get the epic set, possibly not being able to. So I’ll reach a point where I won’t be able to complete the Epic set, or where I can. In either case, since I don’t want to raid again, Classic will then “end.”
The same world, with many more complex additions, is also in BFA.
You also had chores to do in Classic, only they were the same chores with 40 people and banging your head against a brick wall.