I saw you guys were thinking about adding new classes to WoW forever, and that one of the considerations was a necromancer. I have been thinking about how I’d put necromancer in the game for 10+ years and I would greatly appreciate if you could consider my thoughts on how to implement them in a way that makes them distinct from a warlock or death knight.
Necromancers are not just casters and summoners, they’re reagent gathering self empowering scheming conniving villains. I think the core fantasy of necromancers isn’t just raising the dead, it’s manipulating the dead. Empowering themselves with the dead. Preparation, gathering ingredients from corpses, finding ideal specimens, and creating monsters. As such, I think there should be 3 specializations. A summoner, a caster, and a melee DPS.
First I want to talk about summoner. I don’t think you should just spawn a skeleton out of thin air or have a permanent pet like a warlock. Instead you should have several types of summons with distinct uses and methods of summoning relative to their power.
-
Raising corpses as a much weaker version of the enemy you killed to create that corpse. These would be your “filler” summon. A shoddily made servant that will deal a little damage and take a few hits but ultimately crumble away. 20-30 second duration, the limit on how many you can summon is how many corpses you have + how many times you can cast the spell in 20-30 seconds. Can’t be controlled, follows you around with “aggro” pet setting on.
-
Constructs. This is fulfilling the fantasy of patches and the duskwood hermit. Necromancers would have a bag slot similar to a quiver or soul shard bag. You would gather reagents from corpses with a dedicated button, like pick pocket but for corpses, and these reagents have various uses. One use is creating a construct.
Around level 10 you’d learn how to gather ingredients for a basic construct. Constructs last longer (5-10 minutes) but gathering the ingredients for a basic construct would take closer to 15-20 minutes. You should not always have a construct active. As you level you’ll learn new types of constructs which require rarer higher quality ingredients. An abomination for example would need the rarest and highest quality ingredients, but it’s closer in power to something like a doomguard, capable of eating lesser enemies like a wc3 kodo.
All necromancers would have these abilities, but summoners would have things like stronger/more/higher duration raised corpses. They’d also have more versatile constructs. I envision their end of talent tree being a bone obelisk that periodically creates a steady supply of minions until destroyed or expiring. Up to a limit + any nearby corpses which it auto-casts the raise dead on (up to a reasonable limit. Gathering 30 corpses for a 30 second army is cool, but 20 is probably more sensible)
Necromancers would also be able to store 1-3 corpses via an urn for later use. And this again leans into the fantasy of preparation and finding “the perfect specimen”.
Aside from constructs, the ingredients you gather from corpses would also be used to cast certain long cooldown powerful spells. Things like bone armour, bone spear, bone wall. But also creating ritual circles/runes for trapping enemies or empowering yourself/allies. You’d also naturally have a corpse explosion ability, and ingredients would be a great way to make a corpse on demand.
The caster specialization would lean into this particular mechanic of casting spells with ingredients, and they’d also be better at finding rare ingredients. Though the core fantasy of a necromancer caster in my opinion should be aspiring to become a lich. I don’t think you should have some extravagant lich form where you look like kel’thuzad or anything, but I think you should have things like a phylactery (similar to reincarnation, but it puts you at the location you created the phylactery. It’d be usable in combat, but can be destroyed by enemies and the cast can be interrupted) If you were questing, you’d probably put the phylactery at the town hub for example. A nercomancer shouldn’t just be casting a powerful spell, but orchestrating the perfect situation to cast it in. There should be set up and payoff. And that’s where I think runes would come into play.
I don’t think a nercromancer should have “fear” or “horrify” or any warlock type crowd control. I think they should physically obstruct enemies. Things like a bone wall, or arms grasping at legs, or drawing an enemy into a rune they’d placed on the ground. (think a somewhat stronger hunter trap that would be much more difficult to place in the middle of combat). There could also be various combat runes that manipulate the battle field, similar to totems. Unlike totems you can’t just place a new one every time you start a fight, or every time a mob of enemies moves. Instead this would be you using opportunities like when the rogue is off to sap an important enemy to use ingredients gathered from earlier mobs to create a rune that makes allies or even just yourself have faster cast speed while in general proximity and last 2 minutes or so.
And this is my favourite part of the necromancer fantasy that you almost never see anyone explore. Melee necromancer. Not a death knight, a melee necromancer. Low blow opportunistic fighting that’s a mix between warrior, rogue, and warlock. Empowering weapons with poison and curses, empowering yourself with alchemical concoctions, hiding in the shadows. Anything to get the upper hand. They should function as a battle mage that revolves around buffs, consumables, and positioning.
Their attacks, similar to a rogue, would require positioning where you have to be in front of or behind or to the side of an enemy and use your knowledge of anatomy to put holes in all the right places. You’d use ingredients to create potions that let you fleetingly mimic the potential of a real fighter but at the cost of some drawback like increasing your damage done and taken, or raising attack speed but lowering movement speed, or turning invisible but taking damage over time or increasing spell damage for ludicrously higher mana costs.
You should be using the dead not as soldiers, but as your literal sword and shield. Whether it’s bone armour that literally encases your body,
A melee necromancer should be an envious wretch trying desperately to prove itself as stronger and more powerful than everyone else by cheating and being something it isn’t. Borrowed power.
You might think “this sounds like a class that has very bloated action bars and a lot of buttons that would go un-used a lot of the time”. Yes, and that’s EXACTLY how all vanilla classes were. A melee necromancer might not get a lot of value out of raising a lesser corpse, and a caster necromancer might not get much value out of empowering their melee weapon with lifesteal. But having that utility adds so much flavour to the class.
And I know that gathering ingredients sounds like it’d be an annoying chore but I PROMISE YOU this would be such an insanely satisfying class to play.