If only crafting was actually useful…
If they actually thought out the classes more cohesively shaman would be a moderately good class overall.
Its simply the truth. Content is so stupid easy that I believe a Priest or Hunter could tank a lot of it.
I disagree.
Content itself presents hurdles that limit a class to fulfill a roll.
Both Ariel and Tigole were from LoS in Everquest.
Both Sk’s and Paladins, in EQ, could tank groups and trash in raids just fine. However neither could tank bosses unless an overlooked, highly abused mechanic existed that was an exeption…think Paladins and Quarm.
Also keep in mind that Paladins are revamped just before launch and Shaman weren’t exactly fleshed out to begin with, especially in terms of itemization.
With that being said Paladins and Shaman can tank 5 man and trash in raids, assuming they farm consumables and pursue tank related gear.