MG Alliance is a vacuum. Eventually it will sponge up more and more players. I personally know a lot of people who have race changed from Horde to Alliance on MG because they got tired of being alone out in the world in Horde zones, or lack of any casual/walk-up RP. I know a lot of people on both factions who have left WrA to reroll on MG Alliance too.
Sadly, many people are not cognizant that they simply go where the most people are, it is herd mentality. Even if they don’t want to, they do it and ignore their individual wants (IE preferring playing Horde vs Alliance).
I play Horde on MG and it does get lonely, I haven’t RPed in a long time there. It is really hard to do cross faction RP when you play bloodthirsty orcs and the story has the factions in peace time. Finding casual/walk-up/world RP is nearly never going to happen on MG unless you have a guild. Structured and planned RP is great, don’t get me wrong, but a lot of us want that random spur of the moment stuff too. MG Horde isn’t the place to satisfy that itch so most people cave-in and go Alliance because it is so easy.
I’ve recently made this rogue on WrA, though. I plan on RPing, so reading this thread makes me sad to see that people are claiming WrA is on a decline, but it is really no surprise. RP in general feels like it has been on the decline since WoD for me personally.
The story has mostly been bad or below average for at least 7 out of the last 9-10 years. My characters had no reason to go to the Shadowlands, then the time skip happened, and now Dragonflight and the Emerald Dream is the same thing all over again, not any reason ICly to be there really… it is really hard to get the creative juices going when the attraction to the Horde for most players was living in constant conflict, fighting for your lives, being the villain/monsters in the story and so on.
The war is pretty much gone from Warcraft and I think a lot of Horde players find that hard to RP, I know I do. It is such a major swerve for faction loyalists, military RPers, and us few savages. I think it is easier to RP Alliance characters during this time because they have more peaceful races overall so it comes more naturally.
I don’t speak for anybody but myself, but that’s how I feel about it all.