Hunter Hero Talents Rework: From NPCs to Hunter Archetypes

This is something that’s bugged me for a while, and from what I’ve seen around here, I’m definitely not the only one: a lot of Hunters feel the same way. Hero Talents are way too tied to a specific character, race, or lore theme. In practice we’re forced to play as Rexxar, Sylvanas, or a Kaldorei no matter what our Character actually is.

I think Hero Talents should expand on the fantasies that already belong to the Hunter class itself, instead of borrowing an NPC’s identity. So I want to pitch three new Hero Talents built around the classic Hunter archetypes: Beastmaster, Eagle-Eye, and Trapper.

Beastmaster — Mastering beasts is one of the most iconic parts of being a Hunter, and that fantasy could stick around without revolving around Rexxar. His three signature beasts are his companions, not the Hunter’s. It’d make more sense for the talent to tie into your own stable, letting you call on the beasts you’ve actually tamed.

Eagle-Eye — The Hunter who sees the hunt before it even starts. A talent built around awareness, target acquisition, and capitalizing on openings, rewarding you for spotting weaknesses and nailing the right moment to strike.

Trapper — The Hunter who sets the stage before the hunt. This could expand the trap toolkit: new traps, stronger versions of existing ones, area control, that kind of thing.

Here’s how I’d split them up:

  • Beast Mastery: Beastmaster + Eagle-Eye
  • Marksmanship: Eagle-Eye + Trapper
  • Survival: Beastmaster + Trapper

At the end of the day, these three archetypes cover different parts of what makes a Hunter a Hunter, while each spec still gets its own unique combo of identities.

Hero Talents should expand on the class fantasy, not shove players into the identity of one specific NPC, race, or lore theme.

What do you all think? Do you think would be cool for Hero Talents to move in this direction?

4 Likes

people really don’t like playing with traps as they’ve been presented before. it can be annoying to try and aim and hope the right target gets hit by the trap, even assuming traps can hit it. there have been bosses and normal enemies that traps don’t hit since they float above the ground.

that said, i 100% agree with your premise. our hero trees as they are now are far too niche and tied to hyper specific fantasies.

1 Like

I think the big main issue of moving the current talents away from what they are now is just how highly requested the fantasies are. An expansion of the system with more racially neutral but archetypically expressive hero talents alongside them is where I’d rather they take it. Not that expanding it doesn’t have its own issues, but an issue like complexity is a boon to another.

1 Like

idk why they decided to make hero talents so ridged in terms of fantasy. i dont like it when my orc is either rexxar lite or nightelf based or undead elf based.

i cant imagine being a race like vulpera, where all 3 hero trees dont fit the race at all

4 Likes

For me, it’s just like… why do we need each spec to just be a nexus of two half-specs instead of each having its wholly own stuff?

Look at what was already traditionally available across TWW/DF:

  • BM: Pet Amps, Bestial Self-Buffs, Beast Summons, each amped by capstone CD(s)
  • MM: Sniping, Rapid Fire, Stronger Fillers, each amped by capstone CD in equal measure
  • SV: 3+ types of synergetic debuffs, coordinated attacks, consistent access to branching decisions (MF creating its own nuke window whenever opposite setup), each amped by the capstone CD(s)

I guess I just really wish Hero Specs would vanish and leave us more control over the core aspects, or at least come with as much penalty as they do benefit and be entirely opt-in, as not to detract from our other talents. /sigh

That said, apart from might not being too keen on Trapper and thinking Eagle Eye would probably a bit undercooked, yeah this would actually be fine.

2 Likes

Personally, I think the Hero Talents (and Class Talents) should be merged into Specialization Talents. The thematic archetypes can then be their own branching pathway into said archetype and players can pick and choose which ones they want to fulfill their desired (Spec) Hunter fantasy. :dracthyr_heart:

2 Likes

i mean its clear that the more popular nodes of hero trees will probably be baked into the specs after the next expansion tbh.

Gods I wish! It would be nice to have that sweet Chakram baked into Survival Spec! :dracthyr_heart:

So long as the fantasy exists somewhere I’m happy, but part of the purpose of hero talents was shared identity between specs, different from the class trees themselves. Of course that could be accomplished just by putting them in both. There is a use of having it be an expandable fantasy package that isn’t having it clutter either of the main trees themselves, but even having more distinct packages will reach an untenable point, though I think that will happen slower than it would just putting them in the spec trees. The 3 distinct packets of class>spec>hero make it less intimidating than an entire Path of Exile or FFX sphere grid sized tree.

1 Like

I just used the current hero talent division to ilustrate how the options i proposed could fit the current structure, but i agree with the overall opinion that hero talents are kinda meh in a general sense, 11 nodes to add or change 1 skill at max is kinda overkill

Been playing around with some mockups, but it’s been surprisingly awkward without the dual layers of depth vs. breadth, let alone without using some 120+ talent nodes.

On principle, though, it still sounds lucrative, and I imagine there’s probably some way to pull it off.

Maybe via the “entry”/“mid”/“capstone” distinction instead allowing you to augment the initial layer of talents instead with like a second stack and eventually third stack atop what would otherwise each be one-point talents (building up in any of varied ways instead of only building outward /downward) to make the space less crowded. Idk yet; I’ll keep working on it.

Any mock-ups of what you’re thinking for it?

That’s fair. I guess I was thinking of it more in terms of like the bled-over components already being situated into some other portion (e.g., SV Kill Command into coordinated attacks) within the spec trees, while the class trees could have handled any other flavor, especially if we were willing to bring back more than just utility and banal %throughput nodes in said class trees.

1 Like

Not yet. Between a foot injury, BlizzCon, a sudden cold, doc appointments, and cooking RP events, I’ve been deflated worse than Squidward. :dracthyr_cry:

I’ll try to put a bit of effort into a mock-up of what my vision would look like. I am rather curious about it myself now. :thinking:

Hopefully Blizzcon itself wasn’t an affliction, but on all other count, ouch. Hope you feel better soon. :pensive_face: :saluting_face:

I look forward to it!

TTM hasn’t been able to salvage much for me, mock-up wise, due to only having multiples of 45 degrees which makes any 3-tree talent ‘spheres’ like those I wanted to test out hard to use (while 4-trees setups mean each spec has to have an opposite it shares nothing with, which doesn’t work given the likes for at least one of any set like Snake Trap, Cobra Shot, and Flanking Strike), so I might have to switch over to just using Krita or whatnot, ugh.

2 Likes

really think ttm is only useful for mop-sl mockups or df-tlt mockups :confused:

Directly, yeah, ofc. I mean, it’s literally the DF-TLT infrastructure. But it can still be a handy way to simply drag and drop text-insertable art assets.

1 Like

This could be a hot take but I don’t quite get the point of having to choose when it comes to talents, especially when most players just go somewhere and find thee ‘build’, and copy&paste. The ‘illusion’ of choice doesn’t mean much in terms of gameplay.

I always think hero talents should have just been spell skins. I’d rather Blizzard spend their time and effort to hone down the hunter identity and play style. Hunters, imo, is probably the weakest in terms of class visuals and feels. Spell skins lets players play the Hero Class they always wanted without diversifying the already weak hunter class play style.

For example, I main BM. So DR would put the spell visual focus on the hunter and pet aura-esque aesthetic. For PL, the visuals would focus on the pet, etc. I think I even floated the idea of designing an expansion-based legendary pet for hunters to tame/keep to remember the past expansions.

Having a pet doesn’t really mean you are hunter and having a ranged weapon doesn’t make you a ranger. The spell visuals for hunters is almost non-existent and the button does not feel good to press. DR sort solve this problem but PL? Jesus, what a snooze fest.

I think talents should be their way of making ability shine. Take the choice away and make modifier exciting and class appropriate. Especially with hunters, why is it always a choice of either AOE or ST? Why is it a problem of any class having both AOE and ST?

I don’t know. I have mained BM since forever and it’s just now I’m thinking hard on whether or not I should continue.

3 Likes

I agree with this. Hero talents normally add a bunch of nodes, that in general:

  • Don’t add changes or depth to your spec, specially recently after they pruning all the specs
  • Dont provide barely any choices, you are always forced to pick all nodes
  • In worst scenarios (like the hunter) it forces NPC fantasies that you don’t want into your character

So basically, the hero talents could simply be resumed to 1 or 2 new or adapted nodes to the main class tree, AND for the thematic part that forces thematics, it should be simply customizations like glyphs.

No need for a whole new tree that don’t add anything new, instead give no choice over stuff and force me play things or themes i don’t want because im obligated to choose it

2 Likes

I was watching videos on pro raiders and their opinion on the current raid and they mentioned the dreaded ‘seed’ mechanic and I thought, if the devs can come up with that, they can definitely do something better than BW every 30secs for bm hunters.

At this point, I just want something that has thought and maybe an ounce of effort in designing something unique and fun for my class, or any class.

Their refusal to learn: from other companies games, or even their past successful class designs; really annoys me. Stop inventing new systems over and over again. Take what works and people love, and then just improve that.

1 Like

Tbf, most talent points aren’t meant to provide choice. It’s not even feasible for them all to provide choice, because they’d you’d pretty necessarily be comparing codependent bundles of some 31 talents against each other instead of just the choice of talent A against talent B (or at most, this little capstone wing against that one).

We could get a fair bit more choice out of it, certainly, but the slight majority is still going to be mostly a choice not for endgame but simply for leveling — which former baseline perk/unlock we want slightly sooner (consequently getting something else slightly later).

Yeahhh… these kinds of “choices” only really seem to make any sense at maybe the Mythic raid, “The Great Push”, or RBG level.

Below that, the “choice” is almost always way too obvious and just forces loadout-swaps rather than any real customization. You get slightly janker gameplay just to get, what, “menu-play”?

1 Like

Yeah, that sucks. The problem with Blizzard is that they don’t like taking risks. Once they see that something works reasonably well, they tend to stick with it, which makes some of WoW’s current design choices feel merely acceptable rather than exceptional.

Combine that with how much they’ve been simplifying things recently, and you get a really boring combination.