Housing: not good, but not terrible

Tried it on the PTR and I’m definitely underwhelmed. Starting off with the good is the dector placement system for the interior. Being able to rotate and scale items is nice to be sure, but that’s where the positives end.

The glaring issues of course are that the interior is instanced, secluded from the outside, and you can’t customize your house.
I’m not referring to picking presets and adding fake windows to the exterior of course. Compare this to a game that has far more creative freedom for housing like minecraft, where house interiors aren’t instanced from the land they sit on, allowing you to see people outside…from the inside. You can have balconies, real windows, underground areas, you can manipulate the terrain, and so forth. A system that is undeniably garrisons but with decorations and more presets isn’t actually housing. Especially if one of the features are “neighborhoods” where you can’t even interact with others outside your house.

20 Likes

TBH this is the thing I kinda want the most, right now it looks far too same-y with everyone having the default house. The tower thing is very basic, with only a few choices.

It’s a feature that needs a lot more work put into it to really be worthwhile, imho.

9 Likes

Definitely the case. If the locations stay in what can certainly be described as a sub-optimal zone, with bad, even ugly land divisions and extremely limited choices, with very lackluster customization over your house, there is a 0% chance that many people are going to use the feature. Some people I’ve seen like the implementation, and the freedom the instanced nature enables, as the only thing they care about is the interior. But many others I’m quite positive like would like housing, and not just garrisons but with rotatable decor, and no landscape. I’m having trouble seeing housing as it is right now being popular.

I can log into minecraft right now and make a far better blood elf tower/villa hybrid that actually works, with custom landscaping such as trees and streams.

3 Likes

I certainly hope the addon replacements they’re cooking turn out to be fantastic. Wasting time on housing and not having sufficient replacements for all of the addons they are killing will be a bitter pill to swallow.

7 Likes

I never used many addons to begin with, save some weakaura knowledge point trackers and the Lemix helper one. To be honest I’m surprised they didn’t have an auto-scrapper for gear. Certainly rough clearing out all your bags without it I can imagine.

But yeah, It’s looking like housing might have been a waste.

2 Likes

Delusional expectations there, OP.

22 Likes

Oh sorry, I suppose expecting to be able to customize your house in the housing system is delusional, true.
:dracthyr_a1:

11 Likes

I thought that was the whole point?

As someone who has done a few games with building, interior design is surprisingly robust. It’s going to be fun adding everything I want over time.

I think a lot of people will get enjoyment out of what’s there already. I wouldn’t it expect it to be on par with free form building e.g. valheim as far as that exterior disconnect, but ymmv.

5 Likes

If you’re comparing WoW to Minecraft, a game where the whole world is only giant blocks, I don’t know what to tell you. That’s not even Apples to Oranges, that’s Apples to Rubik’s cubes.

Separating interior from exterior was the best way to have the most freedom in both. The neighborhood zones are fantastic. AND the system will be added to and enhanced from here on.

Housing will be a huge hit. People will come back to WoW for this feature alone.

48 Likes

I am not a big proponent of housing but it is kind of pathetic that these do resemble something like garrisons a lot more than any of the myriad of other games with base building out there.

Like even generic copycat early access games have exponentially more depth to their building mechanics.

4 Likes

I honestly can’t tell if some of these people are joking or if they seriously somehow thought an MMO would having base building like limited multiplayer/single player games. Of course there would be no terraforming or free form structures… Do you know ANY MMO that has such?

This isn’t a survival/crafting game, lmfao.

34 Likes

PTR =/= final release.
Now I will say that people must temper their expectations, or they will be disappointed.

2 Likes

Why is OP comparing it to minecraft… a game thats base activity is building things.

I’m just going to say that Pac-Man was very shallow compared to WoW and pat myself on the back for having a brilliant observation.

29 Likes

Also, rub two brain cells together for a minute and realize that the PTR is stress testing the neighborhoods. That’s it. Larger house sizes aren’t in, different exterior themes aren’t in, and they start you with a bare minimum of decorations unlocked.

This isn’t how it will launch, and it isn’t intended to showcase everything possible right now.

People come into a limited testing environment and cast judgement on a system they’ve seen a small fraction of… :disappointed:

22 Likes

Expecting to change the exterior of your house in a Housing feature isn’t that “deep” bro.
We had such to a minor extent in WoD with Garrisons when we upgraded them.

Blizzard are perfectly capable of presenting such.
Maybe not to the extent of Minecraft, lol – but more-so than what’s currently held.

No need to get so toxic to others so quickly …
Especially on what is a relatively trivial discussion. lol

5 Likes

The way to get great systems is to think about how the status quo could be improved. Otherwise you are settling for mediocrity, or have a failure of imagination.

Blizzard had an opportunity to implement terraforming. It’s not a literally impossible task. They compromised.

We could have had working windows, basements, neighborhoods existing in the world, zero loading screens.

So I agree with the OP that the housing system is just decent, and not necessarily the best it could have been.

2 Likes

As long as it requires being in shared neighborhoods, and has no utility, I don’t think it’s worth the time sink involved with it, messing with new mats and crafting, etc.

2 Likes

Im not sure what is and isnt intended on the PTR.
I mean you cant even move your house to another plot on there like you’re meant to. Thats bugged. So why not other stuff as well.

I think it will be fine. It’s not going to have every feature right out of the gate. I’m really excited to see what the community comes up with. That’s where it will really shine.

7 Likes