Guild Bank Missing Items Bug -- Aug/Sept 2024

https://massivelyop.com/2024/09/26/massively-overthinking-do-you-expect-compensation-for-mmorpg-trainwrecks/

Found it, so linking it here.

Agreed this is a good read and talks about studios that have given compensation to their affected fans for much, much less than data loss. Really puts into perspective how ridiculous people sound that claim compensation is asking for too much.

If my funny little monster hunter mobile game has better customer care with bug compensation freebies, wow needs to step up and do better than incomplete restorations.

15 Likes

Thank you for this. Like was said, what is ā€œjust pixelsā€ to some people holds a different value for others. I donā€™t really raid or mythic+ or pvp anymore, but I do collect. I spent most of Dragonflight just exploring and doing world stuff, and stored all the mats and items I didnā€™t use or sell in my gbank, as Iā€™ve done every xpac since their inception, because even though I donā€™t need the mat currently, I may need it in the future for something. And it felt rewarding opening my gbank and seeing how flush it was with items Iā€™ve gathered over many years.

But even though I can move on from this and just refarm maybe 70% of the items in my gbank, the overarching issue is the consent we would be giving blizz and microsoft in just allowing our time to be disregarded so flagrantly. And all the players should be united in standing up for the quality and integrity of the game we enjoy in the face of these corporate entities.

10 Likes

No, itā€™s well put, and been pondering these things as well and thank you for asking.

Iā€™ve been looking around to see who might be best to take over if I do decide to leave. I took over after our previous guild leader (who is also a friend I met in game) took an especially long break. Heā€™s come back now and then, but I believe due to health reasons, he hasnā€™t played since BfA. Heā€™s got two sons that Iā€™ve become really good friends, and they have toons in my guild (though theyā€™ve always had toons in some of the top guilds on the server as well). Wondered if they would be good successors. Iā€™ve tried to keep a certain spirit alive in our guild - that of making the place feel comfortable, homey, not creating a lot of obligations (except when I was nagging them to go fishing during Cata so we could get the Seafood Magnifique recipe for our guild. :smiley: ) And itā€™s not that I donā€™t trust them to run it, nor do I think I do anything all that special. BUT I do try do stuff like keeping up traditions like every toon that hits max level for that expansion gets a Delicious Chocolate Cake (been doing that since I was just an officer back in TBC when I first got that recipe). Or as a tailor/enchanter, using my professions to give free enchants and bags and such to the guild. And the issue also is, a lot of these Guildies DO take long breaks or play in a way where they focus on their progression, and so while they would try and mean well, due to their playstyles, not sure how much attention theyā€™d give the guild.

And Iā€™ve thought of what I would do as well. If I were to leave, I donā€™t see myself playing another MMO (but then, I didnā€™t see myself playing WoW either. Or playing with other people. Or joining a guild. The last bit, my guildies make fun of me occasionally). I have games on Steam, though mostly of the Comfy types. Backlog of streaming shows. Books that look interesting that I havenā€™t read. But whenever Iā€™d hear a piece of WoW music on Pandora (and yes, I use Pandora) or see one of my WoW T-shirts (and especially one that one of my officers had gotten custom made for me for my birthday or something - with our guild tabard design on it :smiley:) or see something else reminds me, I know a part of my heart will hurt. (Iā€™m a damn sap is what I am. :face_with_diagonal_mouth: )

9 Likes

There needs to be SOME form of compensation. They need to 1) ADMIT they screwed up. And this admission needs to come from someone high up in the company, not just passed on to a blue to ā€œrelay the messageā€. They need to say that this is wrong, and say they have taken steps/changed processes/whatever to make sure something like this never happens again. And then they need to 2) Provide SOME sort of compensation to those affected. Iā€™m not sure what form this compensation would take. I know that without logs items cannot just be restored based on ā€œtrust me, broā€, but they SHOULD be able to verify the fact that X guild lost items. Perhaps the compensation could be ā€œproportionalā€ to the approximate number of things that were lost. As I said, it would take a lot more thought to determine exactly what form compensation should take. But there needs to be SOMETHING.

Back in the day I wouldā€™ve expected a statement from Mike Morhaime over this. Obviously heā€™s long gone now. But we need a statement from, if not Johanna, at least Holly or someone high up in the WOW team.

And Iā€™m saying this as someone that was barely affectedā€¦I mean I think I lost a stack of spirits of harmony, and some miscellaneous essences from Cataclysm and like maybe 3-4 from Dragonflight. No sentimental, valuable, or hard to replace items. Iā€™ll even say that I donā€™t even require compensation for myself, for me the statement from someone high up admitting ā€œwe screwed upā€ would be enough.

If they canā€™t provide even this simple, basic level of customer service, I donā€™t know how much longer Iā€™m going to stay. Right now Iā€™m paid up until mid-January. I havenā€™t decided what Iā€™m going to do going forward yet.

14 Likes

No, youā€™re sincere. (Well, maybe a sap in a good way.)

I know how important community is because I donā€™t have one and never really have, and a sizeable part of my heart hurts when I see people struggling with the very same things that so many of us are trying to settle out right now.

It sounds like you know where youā€™d like to go with this, and who youā€™d like to have pick things up in your place. (Just make sure they have the cake recipe first, ya know.) :wink:

6 Likes

This is the partā€¦ the being human partā€¦ that the haters, and the trolls, and the ā€œitā€™s just pixelsā€ folk donā€™t understand or wonā€™t acknowledge. This is also the part that shows there are rays of light in the darkness of what some refer to as the Toxic community. This is the part that shows youā€™re someone that weā€™d want to play a game with, whether itā€™s WoW or something else. I can be just as much a ā€œsapā€ if you want :slight_smile: , but i donā€™t want to loose the point of this reply.

10 Likes

Since you didnā€™t answer, Iā€™ll answer for youā€¦

Your statement has as much in relation to the price of potatoes as your statement about people squirrelling away things since vanilla ā€“ not a thing.

Why people want to keep things, what they keep, how long they keep it or where they keep it is none of your business nor your concern.

All of your responses are nothing but troll posts and filler unconstructive responses ā€“ but you already know thisā€¦ It is exactly why you post to stir the pot and get attention that your HPD craves.

11 Likes

Yeah itā€™s really a no brainer. I donā€™t expect them to have everything figured out on how to resolve this, but I also expect to hear more than what weā€™ve gotten after an entire month of not knowing what was going on with the banks.

I know there are people being caustic about this, but I donā€™t feel like their reaction is strong enough reasoning for why we havenā€™t gotten more answers yet. Whatā€™s there to be cautious about telling us if the restored items are still being sent out or not.

9 Likes

Thatā€™s actually very interesting and good to see that the issue is gaining some traction ā€œout thereā€ ā€¦

8 Likes

Still no reply from Blizzards Nigerian prince mokele-mbembe as to why he emptied my bank account and has put nothing back.

7 Likes

As more time goes on, the more Iā€™m coming to terms with the fact my stuff is gone for good. But on the other hand, the more time goes on the angrier I am at Blizzardā€™s ineptitude, and the more I think we should continue to express our displeasure at this whole response.

Letā€™s say youā€™re having an important celebration at a restaurant. You buy a fancy custom made cake for the occasion.

Scenario 1: As the server walks out with the cake, someone opens a door too quickly and hits the servers arms and the cake falls onto the floor.

Scenario 2: The server walks out of the kitchen backwards with the cake balanced in one hand, while talking on the phone with the other, trips over a chair and the cake falls onto the floor.

Both scenarios end with our cake ruined, but one scenario was an honest mistake and the other scenario was a careless mistake that could easily have been avoided.

While I know none of us are privy to exactly what happened it certainly seems to me like this whole fiasco was a ā€œscenario 2.ā€

Then thereā€™s the aftermath.

Scenario 1: The server and managers apologize profusely, offer to buy you a different dessert as well as giving a substantial discount on the bill.

Scenario 2: All the staff disappear for an hour, then someone comes out and scrapes a tiny bit of smashed cake off the floor onto a plate and places it in front of you.

Again, in both scenarios we lose our cake, but in scenario 1 at least the staff try to make amends.

We deserve better than this.

22 Likes

OMG that is the PERFECT analogy! I love it.

7 Likes

Definitely, for someone with a guild called ā€œFear the Famineā€ :rofl:

5 Likes

Clearly, Customer Support still want us posting on the forums more. The pointed question I posed within my re-opened ticket [from following the Known Issue article being taken down from the TWW Prepatch] was seeking confirmation as to if there was going to be no additional effort based on the information Linxy had shared. Very much still reeks of trying to string us along,

Your ticket has received the following response:

Greetings NameThatNoOneIsConcernedAbout!
Iā€™m Game Master NotRelevantToThread from Blizzard Customer Support and Iā€™m here to follow up on your request.

Your patience is appreciated while awaiting for a reply, due to a recent surge in contacts, reply wait times might take a while but weā€™re doing our best to reach to every player as soon as possible!

We understand how the lack of communication can affect players such as you and entire guilds in widespread situations such as this. Keep in mind that situations such as this take their time to be properly investigated before a communication can be made, among some of the issues on-going.

At this time the only information available is that the Team is still in the process of proceeding with the recovery of the items for the affected guilds.

In regards to your opinion regarding the communication or lack thereof, weā€™d suggest posting this in the forums, as our Teams take a lot of time to go through suggestions that could improve the game and community overall: https:// support-blizzard-com /article/000021518

Thank you for your comprehension, I understand that this is not the answer which you seek, however, it is the only one that Blizzard Customer Support can provide for cases such as the one you so kindly described to us.

Should you have any more questions, feel free to reach out to us anytime.
Until next time.

  • Game Master NotRelevantToThread
    Customer Service, Blizzard Entertainment
    http:// blizzard-com /support
7 Likes

I donā€™t think they can get any more clear with the ā€œWe are still working on thisā€ without giving any estimates as to timeline. They may have no idea how long it may/might/could/will take.

Fortunately, it looks like your ticket was addressed by A Real Humanā„¢ and was topically relevant.

5 Likes

I hope this really means they are still recovering items.

Probably not, but my Wishful Thinking side really wants my stuff back.

6 Likes

I donā€™t think they can get any more clear with the ā€œWe are still working on thisā€ without giving any estimates as to timeline. They may have no idea how long it may/might/could/will take.

Fortunately, it looks like your ticket was addressed by A Real Humanā„¢ and was topically relevant.

Iā€™d be more open to believing that there are folks within Blizzard that are still working on it (eg. not Customer Service, likely not the teams trying to finish the 20th anniversary fixes, or the next expansion or two, maybe some of the goblins that are trying to earn rep with the gnomes may have time waiting for respawnsā€¦), if the Bug Reportā€™s thread (that was locked after 2.6k replies) had not been trending towards the ā€œif you did not get in-game mails on Friday Sept-20th, you are likely SoLā€ conclusion, following Linxyā€™s official post.

At least the estimated response time of 2.5 days was spot on, from the middle of the night re-opening of the ticket after the Tuesday reset, with a Friday near start of business (Pacific).

3 Likes

My guild bank has been basically wiped out. I would like my items restored or monies restored. I agree that this is not a good way to do business with your customers. I have been playing this game since original beta and have never seen this happen and then to be told there could be no restitution. Please remember that we are paying customers and businesses losing data and responding with woops, we donā€™t know how to fix this and will not be restoring your data or offering restitution is bad business.

8 Likes

And five minutes later, while youā€™re still in shock over your celebration being ruined a guest comes up to you and screams ā€œitā€™s just cake, get over itā€.

15 Likes

It could be total coincidence, but I just got an email with a rather lengthy survey from Blizzard.

Makes me wonder if thereā€™s been a big drop in subs after all?

I canā€™t think of a specific example off the top of my head, but Iā€™m sure Blizzard wouldnā€™t be the first company to magically change their tune after some backlash.

Keep the pressure on, fam :muscle:t3:

8 Likes