Grading WoW expansions

Community General Discussion
1

Based on the expansions of WoW you played so far, grade them from A+ (the highest score) to F (the lowest score)

Vanilla: N/A
TBC: N/A
WotLK: C
Cata: C-
MoP: B+
WoD: D-
Legion: A
BfA: D+ (currently)

2 Likes
2

Wod = F
Everything else is passable.

1 Like
3

TBC: B?
WotLK: A
Cata: B
MoP: A+
WoD: C+
Legion: A
BfA: B

7 Likes
4

TBC: A+
WotLK: A
Cata: B
MoP: B-
WoD: D
Legion: B-
BFA: D

4 Likes
5

TBC: A (probably because I started there)
Wrath: B (the pug life was good for the raids my guild no longer did)
Cata: C+(age of the alts)
MoP: B- (didn’t play alot here though)
WoD: D (exapsion of 10,000 alts)
Legion: A (I had fun every day I logged in would play again)
BFA; Currently D but 8.2 looks like its gonna raise that so we will see

1 Like
6

TBC: A+
WotLK: A
Cata: C
MoP: B
WoD: D
Legion: B-
BFA: D

2 Likes
7

Classic C
Tbc A
Wrath A
Cata C
Mop F
Wod F
Legion A
Bfa B

8

Vanilla: C. Objectively I think it’s the worst expansion but it’s the base on which the other expansions are built, and what was learned made future expansions better. That said, it’s still… not great. Not bad but not great.

BC: C+. Vanilla 2 electric boogaloo. A variety of endgame dungeons was a big impovement but everything else is kinda samey

Wrath: B+. They hit their stride here and just about everything is one step better than bc.

Cataclysm: B. Good. Not the best but good. It was just kind of… more wrath.

Pandaria: A+. The best the game has ever been in any metric and I will die on that hill.

WoD: C-. …yeeeaaahhh

Legion: A-. Great, not perfect, but up there.

BFA: Not fair to judge the whole expansion yet

5 Likes
9

Can you explain why you thought MOP was an F without mentioning Pandas?

I ask because I’ve never gotten an answer that wasn’t some permutation of “I didn’t like the pandas”

2 Likes
10

Vanilla: B
TCB: B+
WLK: A-
Cata: B
MoP: A
WoD: D+
Legion: A
BfA: B-

Yeah that’s right. I said it.

2 Likes
11

Vanilla: f
TCB: C
WLK: C
Cata: f
MoP: B
WoD: F
Legion: c
BfA: A+

1 Like
12

they all were better then bfa.

2 Likes
13

Vanilla: N/A
TBC: A+
WotLK: A+
Cata: C
MoP: A
WoD: D-
Legion: B
BfA: D+ so far

14

Sure! I actually like pandas, and to be honest my assessment of mop may be unfair, as I was already unhappy with the game from cata.

I remember being extremely disappointed in pvp from the beginning, with stampede being broken, and whatever the warrior stack and one shot thing was. It was the first expansion I felt like all that mattered was the comp you played, and some of them were quite over the top.

I didn’t like the zones, Jade Forest and Kunlai Summit were nice, but the others either felt bland, or I simply didn’t like (dread wastes). I also personally felt like they had the most annoying dungeons of any expansion. I hated them all except temple of the jade serpent, and I mean both aesthetically and mechanics wise.

Wasn’t a fan of the reputation grinds associated with the expansion (not the fact that they were, but the way they were)

Positives would be the classes were interesting with plenty of abilities, and the raids were fun. Timeless Isle as well. Overall just wasn’t my expansion.

1 Like
15

Vanilla: N/A
TBC: B
WotLK: A
Cata: C
MoP: A
WoD: F
Legion: C
BfA: D

2 Likes
16

All A’s in my book even if I missed a bunch of it I dont care. I wouldnt be wasting my time on a game I dont like.

1 Like
17

Classic = B a few more quests would have been an A
TBC = B+
Wotlk = A+
Cata = C+
Mop = D I hate pandas and monks
WOD= D
Legion = A
BFA = F dumpster fire crap

1 Like
18

trolling us bro?

6 Likes
19

Mop was the worst expansion because of the pandaren, who even plays that race!?
:wink::+1:

1 Like
20

Legion A+
BFA F-
Going from Legion to BFA was going from Ferrari to driving a dumpster on fire with flat tyres.

5 Likes