What are some fantasy changes/request for Survival Hunter that you believe would improve its gameplay during end game content, or overall flair/definition?
I don’t mind how it is now compared to when I last played it in Dragonflight, but I feel like there’s something missing to it…
Probably unpopular opinion. Getting rid of boomstick and not returning fote. No channeled abilities altogether. I just don’t like channeled abilities on melee.
And a slight increase in bombs cd. My personal opinion is that rarer, but bigger booms are cooler than more common smaller booms
Now ofc that would put in gaps in rotation.
So to compensate:
For aoe:
Return of wildfire cluster. Big boom into smaller booms was cool.
Return of legion butchery. (Uncapped aoe that did more dmg the more enemies it hit.)
For ST: Flanking strike (without the jump in). Big ST hit that maybe grants tip stacks.
In general:
Return of serpent sting. Caused by raptor swipes.
Return of kill shot by utilizing hatchet toss. Maybe in the style of warrior sudden death proc.
Strap in for another 1,000 reply post of people bickering.
If we’re going for the ranger, jack-of-all-trades “make it work” archetype, why are we using a random grab-bag of abilities? I’d like to think we could focus in and design around the concept of someone deriving abilities from nature, like venoms/poisons, burns, and bleeds, coming from traps, melee or ranged devices, + a pet. So you’re still scrappy, and figuring things out, but your kit is cohesive.
I think of a lone mountain man, or forest-y kinda dude that has only a relationship with their pet, maybe shuns civilization a bit, and can survive in the wilderness comfortably. They create poisons from plants or critters they harvest, as well as salves or tinctures to heal themselves and their pet. Traps lean less explosion, and more bleed/poison/burn (think acid).
This concept could be applied to the whole of the class, with each spec choosing a path that fits under that umbrella. The Marksman relies more heavily on their weapon, the Beast Master more heavily on their relationship with their pet(s), and Survival on their grit and creativity to create an arsenal from what the forest provides.
Here’s another one.
This one is more of a visual overhaul.
When I hear “adaptive ranger”, I imagine a guy with both sword and a bow.
So.
Weapons: a single one handed weapon + a ranged weapon. Both visible at the same time in combat and out of combat.
All current abilities that can be used from range, get an animation of being shot from your ranged weapon. Bomb, boomstick whatever.
But when those ranged abilities are used in melee range, they get a melee animations (keeping the effects the same), boomstick uses your ranged weapon appearance regardless of range.
During aspect of the eagle melee attacks become full on shots, getting cast feom your ranged weapon. Swipe to multishot, steike to shot you get the idea and during that time ranged weapon also gets auto shots.
Kill command. Gets a hit animation from player too. If cast in melee range, instead offlailing arms around like a chicken, you will also do a melee attack if cast from melee or a shot if cast from range.
I’ve mentioned before my favorite god from Smite, Ullr. His kit is DW hand axes and a bow that you toggle between. When you’re at range you have more attack power, and when you’re in melee you have a TON of leech. When I played, I had a skin where he looked Rambo-esque. The name of the skin is “Survivor.” I like very much like the concept of that archetype.
Sounds cool, but I don’t think wow is ready for a spec that can swap between range and melee at will. Would be too op for mechanica. But it does sound cool. Like gw2 ranger.
To be fair, we could kiiiiiinda do that pre-Legion. Not ever really fully effective in melee, though.
I agree it would be a long-shot to expect that in WoW. I’d love 1h ranged weapons, but also never going to happen. I played condi Ranger in GW2 → Shortbow [swap] Axe/Torch. Great fun, but all ranged. Wasn’t Longbow/Greatsword a thing?
Dial the venom theme up to an eleven. 12.1 has proven that the GFX team has done a stellar job on these effects. We’re sorely missing this from a class archetype.
Also, make wilfirebomb poisonous, rather than wildfire. Palette swap it to green if you have to. I don’t care what it’s called. I want to be leaving poisonous clouds and patches. Consistent area denial.
I don’t care what anyone says, Wildfire bomb is stupid. Oh, and get rid of that god damn stupid Dumbstick.
I don’t think that’s particularly unpopular at all. And agreed. At the least, it should be optional. If I wanted a channel forced front and center, I’d have gone with WW.
Agreed, in favor of more potency per throw, especially as the baseline.
Can stay that way, even, as long as we have other melee actions to shake things up; if we want to interweave it into the rotation more via interesting effects (such as per an improved-upon real Wildfire Infusions [as opposed to just 1–2s CDR per KC]), we can attach CDR to it at that time.
This is basically just +% damage but with the tiniest bit of extra visual flair, so better than Improved Wildfire Bomb, but can’t really muster any care either way.
If it’s caused directly by Raptor Swipes, then it may as well be caused by our other bladed actions as well (e.g., Throwing Hatchet). Even then, it wouldn’t be any extra gameplay, but merely an effectively-passive minute buff to split target cleave.
I’d rather not randomly make using a worse weapon (dinky throwing hatchet) stronger than our spear just because we surprise ourselves with a proc.
I feel like it’s already mostly doing that, just too shallowly (rather than too broadly) to feel as “resourceful” as it should.
Fair, though given how the gunpowder-making historically in isolated mountain villages, I don’t see explosives, incendiaries, etc., as antithetical to that, especially given the amount of Azerothian beasts naturally using the same.
Same. Would love this.
Yup. Or give a quick-swap action if you want it to be a bit more palpable, either way. Maybe even give a choice node between faster-swaps and/or some small uptime-compensator vs. being able to swap automatically.
Naturally.
Aye, and can do the same with a natural Aspect of the Hawk / Aspect of the Wolf/Beast passive… but the same time… it’s only really the melee that needs any buff. Ranged is already advantaged in itself.
I mean, given that ranged and melee specs can exist competitively on the same class, I don’t see why not. The only thing is that you need the melee compensation to scale with melee uptime or output, or at least with having the melee weapon out, rather than being a compensatory spec passive.
Hero Specs feel like they should have been kiss/curse overlying options that’d swap out some of our spec and class talents while forcing and buffing certain picks at cost to general %AP or the like.
And while some hero specs handle things better, forcing MM for instance to pick just between night elf (super-Spotter’s Mark) and dead elf (KS-but-magic-and-half-DoT-now), or even SV to pick between NE and actual-Rexxar is just… ugh.
I mean, this would just be WFI if they had turned Flamefang Pitch into a Flame Patch from each WFB.
Wildfire → Fire Patch
Shrapnel → basically Caltrops
Volatile → combustible gas cloud
Pheromone → natural biochemical gas cloud
We only have one poison spec in the game. It would be cool to see more, though I’d rather have it as ranged were they to go that route. SS, Poison Fang pet attack, Arrow that exploded like WFB but does poison splash, maybe some kinda bleed or two, SNAKE TRAP!!. Ugh it could be so good…
The biggest I would suggest for Survival is to pivot from Fire/Bleed damage to Poison.
What I believe Survival is supposed to represent the ingenuity of the Hunter class. So instead of Wildfire Bomb being a conventional explosive it should feel more improvised. I believe if it was poison based it would cover that feeling while incorporating a knowledge of nature that should also be a part of the Hunter Class.
Coating are weapons in poison instead of igniting them (if anyone actually uses that talent), using poisonous made from surrounding flora to make explosive/projectiles (if Hatchet Toss did poison damage along with talents buffing poison, it might actually be a move!), along with the suit of traps Hunters get would make it feel like you’re actually using the environment around you while in combat. As a Hunter that should be you’re expertise, utilizing the natural world around you to win a fight.
Also, a small change to Boomstick I want. Make it 2 shots, I actually want it to be two charges, one shot per charge and the cooldown doesn’t start to reset until the 2nd charge is spent. It’s supposed to be a double barrel shotgun, it’ll be so easy for it to feel like one.