Yeah, the Stoneskin totem bug is a thing. A lot of what I’m seeing is Alliance player comparisons so it can’t even apply.
Here’s one of the threads I’m looking at:
https://www.reddit.com/r/classicwow/comments/br86ov/elite_damage_is_way_off_evidence/?sort=new
The OP actually edited it now and crossed out a bunch of stuff and admitted he was wrong about it. Already got 1900+ upvotes as people are just wanting the numbers to be wrong.