Damage Meters are theorycrafting tools

literally everyone here is talking about randos in 5man pugs, not minmaxing your raid setups.

My point being though that they were dismissed for the most part. Now, damage meters are dictating to some degree how people play as a “meta”.

Why? Not everyone cares enough. The people that do care already do it.

1 Like

Except they really weren’t dismissed for the most part
 They were very popular in dungeons and especially in raids. If you want to progress, you need people to pull their weight and push their boundaries. They were used to cull/call out the weak back then. Now mix that with 15 years of people being used to doing that and they simply don’t have the time or patience to carry someone though a game that’s been out for a decade and a half


If people people can’t figure out their two button rotations and basic stat priorities, with simple google searches, then it tells a lot about them.

Now if someone is completely new to the game, that’s a whole nother story. However, that’s a fairly uncommon thing. I’d say maybe 1:10,000 players, in classic, are new players that have never touched WoW.

I’m an old vanilla player that returned to WoW only for Classic, never played anything beyond 1.10. When I started I invited two people that have never played any WoW at all and they both play. A lot of people play re-releases of games because they missed them the first time around and want to know why those games were popular. I’m sure there are a lot of people playing Link’s Awakening for the first time on Switch right now who had never played it on gameboy.

edit: and this isn’t exactly an indie game. Classic made WoW top the Twitch charts; BfA didn’t do that. There’s a lot of people that will just play whatever is topping the Twitch charts because they want to be a part of the zeitgeist.

I agree. Good to see what everyone is doing and if someone needs help because they are doing something wrong.

Bad things that happen from dmg meter. You all suck look at my epeen.
I need to keep up with wars deeps so i will yell at tank to make sure i have full mana before pull.

I was glad when i turned it on but some do abuse it.

Just because you didn’t, doesn’t mean others didn’t. The community didn’t and doesn’t go on hold just because you aren’t playing. The community continued to evolve into what it is today.

That just shows that there were a lot of retail players, that might not have had the chance to play vanilla, that were trying to see what all the fuss was about. People talk all this mad hype that vanilla was so hard, so that makes others want to see if it’s true and well it’s not, but that’s a topic for another thread.

1 Like

Not really. Maybe in dungeons, you’d see it all the time.

There’s was little room to “cull” in Vanilla in a progression guild. If you were in Naxx, you weren’t going to spend the time gearing someone else up.

It wasn’t a private server where you could “hey let’s run MC just for thunderfury while we do Naxx”

At the end of the day, all we really used it for was to tell who was afk half the time. Granted, it was usually on stuff we had on farm, but it was good to tell who was trying all the time and who wasn’t. We used loot council.

Nobody cares that you topped the damage meter in ZF.
Nobody but you.

1 Like

I had a warrior doing literally 15 dps in Sunken Temple, and the healer was complaining about us damn dps pulling agroo. So finally i linked it, turns out the warrior was using the dungeon to level up his maces. Damage meters can be very very useful, even in dungeons.

3 Likes

You really are the king of trashposting, and can only imagine how toxic you are in game and hope you’re on a number of black lists.

1 Like

Are you being ironically toxic or just regular toxic?

it is not even bfa thing, back in classic people want best dps so healers don’t go oom, that is why combat rogues, frost mages and marksman hunter are only dps in raids, nothing else unless you want to give more shadow damage to locks from shadow priest, even that is rare back then

The point I was making was that “1 in 10,000 players in classic are new players” seems like a bogus claim, not that the world stopped when I stopped playing.

1 Like

That’s why I said cull or call out. You cull a bad dps from an UBRS run, you call out a bad dps in a BWL fight.

I’ve never played on pirate servers, nor will I, so I don’t know how it goes in those cesspools.

Not at all. During vanilla, I probably ran hundreds of dungeons and hundreds of raids. They were used extensively from what I remember. Just because you didn’t use them like that doesn’t mean that everyone didn’t use them like that. This is a serious bias that goes around on these forums for some reason lol


I actually had this happen in a run recently as well!

Oh I’m sorry, do I post things that challenge your little bubble of nostalgia and foggy memory? And I do just fine in the game, I’m back with a bunch of old Naxx guildies from back in vanilla. We have a power guild going comprised of Naxx raiders from a few guilds from Medivh.

what I love about video games and the internet is that everyone can find their community; even people that are complete buttwipes.

Anyone that knows me, in game or in real life, knows that I’m actually a pretty decent person. In WoW, I’ve helped a lot of people get better at the game. By a lot, I mean probably in the hundreds range over the past 15 years. If I see someone doing crap dps for their gear level, I try to coach them on how to get better and you’d be surprised at how quickly people can progress. Granted, in classic that’s a pretty easy thing to accomplish with two button rotations.

everyone knows that anyone that has to explain that “actually I’m not a buttwipe” is a buttwipe.

so? Everyone that plays WoW helps other people that play WoW. “Using teamwork to overcome obstacles that you couldn’t overcome on your own” is basically the entire design thesis of the game.

I get that you think that you’re like this uniquely benevolent force of good in Azeroth but the reality is that most players don’t want to be “coached” when they’re not asking for help, they want to figure it out on their own. Most people, when they’re going through a video game and not playing perfectly just want to keep playing and get better on their own and don’t want a random person to roll up and explain things at them. Sometimes people enjoy dying.

think about how ridiculous of a statement that would be if you had actually said it.

1 Like

Hes totally the guy that starts kicking and blacklisting people after the 1st wipe.

honestly one of the most satisfying thing in this game is encountering an obstacle, failing to overcome it, coming up with a theory for a new strategy on your own, and then overcoming that obstacle by enacting a strategy that you devised on your own. A lot of times, “coaching” someone is effectively just saying spoilers at them.

edit: obviously this does not apply if someone is asking for help.