- When you have only 51 talent points to play with, you’re limited in what can be tweaked.
- There’s no mystery in this day and age of the internet. And what rewards? If nothing is better than naxx, it’s not much of a reward. Better ilevel DOES mean better gear, or at least it should. Otherwise, what’s the point of ilevel?
- Turning BC content into a lukewarm elite area with a few random rewards, no repeatability isn’t good. BC gave us an entire new content, over a doezen new dungeons that were repeatable with heroics. Your suggestion is a massive downgrade.
- If my hunter turns into a demon hunter, then suddenly my giantstalker set, my rhok’delar, all the stuff I geared towards a hunter is suddenly worthless. This IS getting rid of the toon. And how is making a class rare a good thing? Hint: it’s not.
- itemization isn’t the whole problem. You’re missing abilities that were added in BC.
- Oh, so you want more raids. I’m pretty sure BC did this.
- They find it out by looking it up on wowhead or wowwiki. Mystery in this game doesn’t stay mystery for longer than a day because INTERNET.
Again, everything you’re asking for is basically “Give me BC but don’t give me BC”. There seems to be this massive misconception among the classic + fan club that raising the level cap was a bad thing.
It wasn’t. It made the game complete
The golden age of the game was BC and Wrath, where almost all of the classes and specs were viable at level 70-80. Trying to replace this with some imagined “Classic but more” that was never even an option in the first place isn’t a good idea.