tbf I think tbc is for a completely different audience than the people who are attracted to wow arena currently. apart from people who actually liked wow back then, and played through it, I can understand why people who haven’t played it, or graduated and moved on from playing it, don’t want to go back.
It definitely had it’s flaws. There’s some ignorant critiques in here, but there’s also some ignorant praise. TBC was by no means perfect, but it’s not as black and white as TBC bad future expansions good.
Tbc offers a really unique style to wow pvp. Especially with all the overlapping DR schools, and unique way combat evolved out of vanilla before wotlk started to streamline class design with efficiency.
If you don’t like rng, you’re not going to enjoy tbc. Even this awkward video highlights one of TBC’s most frustrating features to people who haven’t played from back then / coming back to those times. Resist. Resisting your interrupt. Resisting stuns. resist resist resist.
The good thing about tbc rng is that a lot of the time there’s room to recover, and your life isn’t over because x or y didn’t happen.
The bad thing about tbc is that if you don’t know the script, or the correct strategy for your comp to secure it’s goals / windows, you’re going to get stomped 10-0 while feeling like everything’s entirely hopeless, while on hindsight you realize your priest wasn’t purging abolish poison, doing damage to the warrior, and your focus macro wasn’t working. (to be awkwardly specific.)
Tbc’s also a time where gladiator could come from 2v2. And people taking 2v2 seriously is something i’d wager the majority of people in modern wow aren’t interested in.
From what I’ve heard classic was a huge success and is still very much active? Idk i don’t play classic.
If I could say something in TBC’s defense, I’d say push aside your preconceived notions of what WoW is, or what wow should be based on your experiences with the current game, and approach TBC as a blank slate and experience it for yourself if you haven’t before.
It’s the foundation of everything we do, the origin of arena, and where all of the passion and love for this game we get to share to this day initially came from. It’s quirky, it’s awkward. It’s completely different. But it’s lots of fun.
I’d also recommend looking at R1 gameplay in tbc, either modern or historical, and use that as your reference if you can find one that isn’t 360p lol.