Cannot disable PvP mode

Ever since I tried to do the bugged Battle for Undercity quest two days ago, my character has been flagged for PvP (on a PvE realm). When I try to disable it, I get the usual message that “You will be unflagged for PvP combat after five minutes of non-PvP action in friendly territory,” but I never actually leave PvP, even if I spend 5+ minutes idling in Stormwind/Dalaran.

I used my hearthstone to leave the bugged Battle for Undercity quest because it was incompletable.

EDIT: Apparently if you hold any of the Venture Bay quests from Grizzly Hills, they will keep you in PvP mode permanently. I had “Element 115” which wasn’t flagged as (PvP) in the quest log; abandoning the quest allowed me to disable PvP mode.

1 Like