I think it’s time Blizzard restored the Black Proto-Drake and Plagued Proto-Drake to their original achievements:
Glory of the Raider (10 Player) — Plagued Proto-Drake
Glory of the Raider (25 Player) — Black Proto-Drake
These were the original Glory raid mounts. Blizzard removed them with Patch 3.1 in 2009 because, with Ulduar arriving and players becoming more powerful, completing the Naxxramas achievements would become increasingly trivial.
Fair enough — except Blizzard immediately stopped doing that.
The Rusted and Ironbound Proto-Drakes from Ulduar remained available. So did the Icecrown Glory mounts. And the Glory mounts from essentially every raid tier that followed.
Today we can go back and massively outlevel old raids, complete their Glory achievements, and collect their mounts. That’s been the established system for well over a decade.
Black and Plagued aren’t following some continuing Blizzard policy of preserving Glory mounts as limited-time prestige rewards. They’re leftovers from a policy Blizzard tried once at the beginning of Wrath and then abandoned.
And since then, Blizzard has actually gone in the opposite direction.
Patch 10.1.5 specifically revisited this era of the game. Blizzard created the Old Scholomance/Naxxramas secrets, restored access to old appearances and recipes, made Tier 3 obtainable again, added the Eastern Plaguelands entrance to Naxxramas, and even gave us a way to obtain Valiance as a mount.
So why are the original Naxxramas Glory rewards still the exception?
I’m not suggesting putting them on the Trading Post or making them vendor mounts. I’m not asking for a new acquisition method at all.
Just put them back where they originally belonged:
Glory of the Raider (10 Player) → Plagued Proto-Drake
Glory of the Raider (25 Player) → Black Proto-Drake
The achievements are still there. The rewards should be too.
And yes, people who earned them while Naxx was current accomplished something that someone steamrolling Naxx today obviously isn’t accomplishing. But that’s equally true of someone who earned an Ironbound Proto-Drake during current Ulduar versus someone earning one today. We don’t need to permanently remove the reward to recognize that difference.
The Plagued Proto-Drake has even been obtainable again through the Black Market Auction House, while the Black Proto-Drake remains unobtainable. At this point the original removal doesn’t even consistently preserve the exclusivity of the two rewards.
The achievements never went away. Their rewards shouldn’t have either.
It’s been 17 years. Blizzard has long since established how legacy Glory achievements work.
Put the Black and Plagued Proto-Drakes back on Glory of the Raider.