They should keep going with Classic servers, IMO. Every era has its fans. Every one has benefits and downsides. I’d love to see Cata/MOP servers when the time comes.
And we’re going to be waiting a while on either of those considering TBC hasn’t started yet.
TBH WoW 2 or not, As long as I can keep my characters and bring them over I’d be alright with it.
But they’ve also spent a ton of money and time investing into upgrading the systems of this game and have been doing so. I feel like if we were going to get a WoW 2 ever, they wouldn’t be wasting their time and money on that. There’s no way the overhead would let them.
They let entire games go to the wayside. WoW would be as well if we were getting a WoW 2 remotely any time soon.
One good aspect of WoW’s more cartoonish art style is that it’s able to remain timeless and rather unique in a sea of boring MMOs that either tried to rip off its style or did their own generic thing. I’ve certainly seen people compare it to ‘Fortnite’ before like it’s a bad thing. Fortnite has a strong aesthetic that has remained consistent for its life-span. That’s a good thing. Being a bit cartoony certainly isn’t bad.
FFXIV looks nice but that’s because it’s done by people with the time, money, and effort to care, same as this game. Elder Scrolls has always had its own unique look too.
It’s not much of a surprise why these three are the top three at the moment (Runescape might be ahead of ESO, not sure, but it is certainly another unique game). Beyond the legacy of the IPs, these games do carry something in them where other games have failed.
SWTOR was a hit for a bit but it died off. Star Wars wasn’t enough to keep it going strong forever. Many other franchises tried and never even got off the ground with their MMO projects.
Like it or not there’s more to this game that keeps people here beyond even friendships. Warcraft has a strong aesthetic that is backed up by some of the best gameplay in the business. Even if it’s frustratingly wrapped up in some absurd systems that do make people quit. They really ought to realize by now this is bad for them, but I guess internally numbers do fine enough.
Even Classic has come along and proven that although the game has radically changed the core elements that were there still stand true and interest people. Classic is active, more active than many MMOs on the market that’s trying to compete with WoW.