Bards as a Profession

I would love to see Bards in WoW Forever, but I’m not convinced there is enough there to justify an entire class. Instead, I think Bard could work extremely well as a profession.

Making Bard a profession would allow every class to participate in it while giving the profession its own identity, progression, and specializations. Rather than crafting traditional items, Bards would learn songs and instruments that provide temporary benefits to themselves and their group.

Bard Specializations

The profession could eventually specialize around different instruments, with each instrument focusing on a different type of support.

Drums
Focused on physical power and could provide a Strength-based buff.

Lute
Focused on magical power and could provide an Intellect-based buff.

Lyre
Focused on restoration and could improve Spirit, health regeneration, or mana regeneration.

Flute
Focused on defense and could increase Armor or provide a small amount of damage reduction.

Violin
Focused on speed and precision and could provide an Agility-based buff.

The exact numbers obviously wouldn’t need to be enormous. The idea would be to give each specialization a meaningful niche without making Bard mandatory for every raid.

Pre-Encounter Songs

I picture the profession working somewhat like Alchemy.

An Alchemist creates potions and elixirs that players use before or during an encounter. A Bard could instead perform songs before an encounter that temporarily buff nearby party or raid members.

The important distinction is that these aren’t permanent auras following the Bard around. The Bard performs the song, the group receives the buff for a set duration, and then everyone goes about their business.

That also means the person playing the Bard profession doesn’t have to spend the entire raid standing in the corner playing Wonderwall while everyone else gets to fight.

Short-Duration Songs

Bards could also have weaker, short-duration versions of their songs.

For example, instead of the longer pre-encounter Strength song, a Bard specializing in Drums might have access to a much smaller 15-second physical damage or Strength buff.

These could have meaningful cooldowns so that choosing when to use them matters.

That would give the profession some actual gameplay instead of reducing it to another checklist of buffs you apply before pulling a boss.

Song of Rest

I’d also love something similar in concept to Song of Rest from Baldur’s Gate.

A Bard could perform a powerful out-of-combat song that dramatically increases health and mana regeneration for nearby party members.

Make it genuinely powerful, but put it on something extreme like a six-hour cooldown.

It wouldn’t replace healers, food, or normal regeneration. It would be a rare utility ability that feels appropriately powerful when someone actually uses it.

Camping

The new camping system seems like an especially good opportunity for this profession.

Bards could learn songs specifically intended to be performed around camps, potentially improving resting, regeneration, crafting, or other camp-related systems.

More importantly, it would add another social activity to camps.

One player is cooking. Someone else is crafting. The Bard pulls out a lute and starts playing while everyone prepares for whatever they’re doing next.

That feels very Warcraft.

Why a Profession Instead of a Class?

The biggest advantage is that Bard wouldn’t need to support three complete combat specializations, dozens of abilities, class-specific gear, PvP balancing, and an entire leveling kit just to justify its existence.

Instead, Bard becomes something every class can interact with.

You could have a Warrior beating war drums, a Priest playing a lyre, a Rogue carrying a violin, or a Mage playing a lute.

It adds another layer to your character without replacing the character you’ve already chosen to play.

And with WoW Forever already experimenting with professions, camping, and more ways for players to define their characters outside of their class, I think Bard fits that philosophy much better as a profession than as another full class.

Obviously, this would need some additional thought to really flesh out a full profession but do think this is more interesting that just adding another class.

3 Likes

I think it makes more sense as a full class, which it has been since D&D1e :shrug:

1 Like

I feel the opposite. It doesn’t make sense as a profession, but makes perfect sense as a support/healer class.

1 Like

A huge amount of video games and TTRPGS would disagree with you.

2 Likes

the issue with what you’ve suggested is that they will be even more in demand than any other profession for giving those buffs

it’ll be a world of bardic engineercraft

1 Like

Bards in LOTRO were the dumbest thing ever. Strumming their guitar at the bad guy. Would definitely need an add-on to mute them. They would still look ridiculous but I wouldn’t have to listen the them.

1 Like

Those are all fair points; I would point out that the iteration of Bards in a lot of TTRPGS and other video games are typically built around them using abilities from other classes. If that is the case then are you going to have a Bard running around casting priest spells, mage spells are using abilities from melee class kits?

This is where I think the idea of them being a sub profession makes the most sense as they’ve always just been treated as a hybrid of other classes anyways.

I think Bards should only be able to buff others in rested areas. It should also be a secondary profession like Cooking.

I actually thought about that and I think that is where tunning makes the most sense. Maybe only allowing x amount of bard buffs to be on a player at a time so there isn’t any weird stacking. It would for sure need to be implemented thoughtfully to not minimize what other professions are needed in the game. However, the counter is if they implement based on what the survey suggested Bard would have a dedicated spot in raids anyways for the same exact reason.

which is less of an issue, because we wouldn’t all feel the need to become bards

if it’s a sub profession, it’s still gonna be like “well I need to level my bard in case my dungeon groups or pugs don’t have it leveled”

As a profession it would push a new meta.

Find a spec that doesn’t really bring much, make it a bard, and you spend your whole time being a bard.

They’d just be the new pally buffbots.

You’re basically no longer your class/spec you’re a bard the whole time anyways, but lose a profession slot.

I don’t think as much as you’d think, Engineering is still going to dominate the PvP scene, Alchemy seems like it’s shaping up to be the BIS for raiders. gathering professions now offering baseline increases like 5% stamina for Mining, Magical resistance for Herbalism and 2% crit bonus for skinning. Plus, you’ll have BiS restricted items for the professions the create items. This would just give players another avenue to theory craft and build around without introducing a dedicated spec that will be mandatory for hardcore raiding guilds.

this is not a DnD its World of WARCRAFT you wanna play bard go play DnD

1 Like

HEY! :angry:
There is absolutely NOTHING wrong with standing in the corner playing Wonderwall!
:guitar: :musical_notes: :musical_note:
“Cause mayyybeee, you’re gonna be the one that saves meee…”

Or maybe “Brave Sir Robin”

2 Likes

That is true lol, I think my point is more so, that if implemented correctly as a profession you wouldn’t be just a buff bot. Restricting them down to using stuff out of combat doesn’t remove class identity and what you bring to a raid as the class you want to play, it just gives players an additional avenue to bring utility.

Again, I love the bard class in other games, but they typically are built around using the mechanics and abilities of other classes. That’s my whole point with them maybe not making sense to be used as a class and filling out 3 totally different specs and builds for them. In the respects of how WoW works it makes more sense to have them be an add on profession then an individual full class.

It’s also worth pointing out that Bards are not confirmed but were part of a survey as a potential new class. I just wanted to point out that they could introduce a new dedicated class while still giving people that love Bards an avenue to play out that character.

1 Like

Bard could totally work as a hybrid ranged dps. Give them a bow and a lyre, let them play songs to buff the party or debug the enemy, weave ranged attacks between songs, etc.

I personally wouldn’t play it but I think it would add something positive to the game.

Could also be a 4th spec added to Rogue if they ever decide to do something like that.

WoW Forever is the perfect place to make this a class, especially because there’s no focus on rated PVP or overly competitive gameplay. There’s a lot more freedom with classes than in retail or classic progression.

If you can’t wrap your head around Bard as a fully-fledged class just look at FF14 for a prime example

1 Like

The only class polled that in reality is just a profession is tinker. Worst one out of the bunch and it doesn’t even come close.