Sure thing. So in pvp you don’t really have the luxury of always picking your eclipse. If I did have the option to free cast with literally no pressure, I’d go into solar eclipse just because wrath is quicker to spam and does more ST dps. If I’m being pressured or otherwise taking damage, I prioritize lunar so that when umbral embrace procs I can get instants off easily from owlkin adept.
I don’t use waning twilight or smolder for pvp.
I have multiple builds but for arena, my primary focus, I won’t really press starfall at all.
I don’t use twilight because I don’t know what to give up for it and it requires a third dot which is the real problem. Stellar flare in arena is not ideal, smolder isn’t very high damage at all and only benefits from adding a dot which only matters for twilight. Just too many points to allocate. Mushrooms can apply a dot too but I only take that for my starfall build. Ultimately I just don’t want to give up the other stuff.