Calling all Hunters: It’s time to fix the "Brokentooth" Problem and Pet Diversity

Hunters, we need to talk, and we need to make our voices heard. (And if you play another class, stick around for 30 seconds because you know how frustrating it is when game mechanics ruin your character’s visual identity).

Whether you play a Warrior, Mage, Priest, or Hunter, there is one thing we all love about World of Warcraft: character identity and customization. You spend hours farming that specific tier set, mount, or weapon appearance just so your character looks the way you envisioned.

Now, imagine if Blizzard told you that to be viable in raids or PvP, you had to wear a single, low-resolution pair of boots. If you switched to the ones you actually liked, you’d lose massive throughput and core class procs.

That is the exact reality Hunters are facing right now with Pet Attack Speeds.

The Problem: Illusion of Choice

In Classic/Forever (and the upcoming iterations), Beast Mastery and general Hunter performance heavily rely on fast pet attack speeds like 1.0 or 1.2 to keep Frenzy uptime high, maximize spell pushback in PvP, and scale properly.

Because of this, the whole class fantasy of “taming any beast in the wild and bonding with your companion” goes completely out the window. If you want to play optimally, you aren’t allowed to use that rare spirit-like owl, that cool purple bear you spent hours tracking, or a sleek raptor. You are mathematically forced into using Brokentooth, a ZG bat, or a handful of specific cats forever.

Seeing 50 Hunters in Orgrimmar or Stormwind with the exact same cat kills class fantasy, RPG immersion, and player agency.

Two Simple, Lore-Friendly Solutions

We don’t need game-breaking buffs or pets hitting at 0.5 speed. We just want the freedom to use the beasts we love without handicapping our performance. Blizzard could easily fix this without breaking balance:

  1. Trainable Attack Speeds (Class Quest / Stable Master): Just like Hunters already tame specific beasts to learn higher ranks of Bite, Claw, or Dash to teach them to other pets, let us learn “Swift Strikes” (1.0 / 1.2 Attack Speed) from fast beasts and train our favorite companions! You still have to put in the effort to camp and tame Brokentooth first, which preserves the prestige and RPG element while unlocking true pet variety afterward.

  2. A “Pet Transmog” / Appearance Glyph System: Keep the exact stats, family abilities, and attack speed of our active combat pet, but let the Stable Master project the appearance of another tamed beast from our stables onto it. You get the 1.0 attack speed mechanics, and you get to look at the pet you actually love.

Why This Matters for Everyone

WoW thrives when players feel connected to their characters. Giving Hunters the ability to bring their favorite beasts into raids and battlegrounds doesn’t make the class overpowered. It just makes the game more fun, visually diverse, and faithful to the RPG roots we all love.

Fellow Hunters and the WoW Forever community, drop a comment and bump this thread so the devs see it!

12 Likes

I’m not convinced pet attack speed isn’t normalized by family in forever. My tiger has .98 attack speed and has since level 10.

I mean, I understand the issue, but I’m still going to use the pet I like rather than the one that’s 1-5% better. People need to stop minmaxing the fun out of everything.

4 Likes

Do you mean like bis list ? That’s exactly what pets are part of. In addition damage was normalized in Forever so you only look at attack speed for pvp spell pushback.

Inform yourself before posting tears.

1 Like

My turtle agrees with you.

2 Likes

Actually, WoW: Forever uses a hybrid system! Every pet family has a 2.0s baseline, but specific beasts come with an innate hidden passive (Faster Attack I through VII, or Slower Attack) that restores their Classic speeds (like 1.3s on a Durotar Tiger, 1.2s on Swamp Jaguars, or 1.0s on Broken Tooth). That’s why your tiger hits at 0.98 with talents/buffs active, while a standard 2.0s pet never gets close to that!

Even though Blizzard normalized sheet DPS so slower pets hit harder per swing, those innate Faster Attack passives still give specific beasts a massive edge in PvP spell pushback, Frenzy/proc consistency, and way less DPS loss from misses/dodges in short fights.

That’s actually why a trainable Faster Attack passive (or Pet Transmog) fits Forever so well—the passive system is literally already in the game!

3 Likes

You wont be using a cat in raids. Youll have to use a wolf.

Two things here:

  1. BiS gear vs. Pets: Even when you wear a BiS list, you can transmog your gear (or at least gear isn’t your core class identity). For Hunters, taming a unique beast in the wild is literally the entire point of the class. You don’t camp a rare spawn for 12 hours just to leave it rotting in the stable forever.

  2. Attack speed isn’t just for PvP pushback: Yes, base sheet DPS was normalized, but faster attack speeds still give way more melee swings per minute. That means significantly faster and more reliable Frenzy ramp-up and uptime, more frequent on-crit procs, and far less penalty when a pet gets dodged or parried on a pull.

Nobody is “posting tears” here. Asking for a trainable speed passive or Pet Transmog doesn’t hurt your gameplay at all, it just lets Hunters actually use the beasts they tame.

There a few 1.0 AS pets and a ton of 1.2AS pets. This is a complete nothing burger and any change blizz makes will end up be worse for hunters.

AND DO NOT SAY WHY IT MATTERS TO EVERYONE. Many folks like it as is.

Petopia is your friend to see what is what for pets.

Attack Speed 1.0 :
Bloodseeker Bat (Bat, 60, Zul’Gurub (Raid))
Broken Tooth (Cat, 37, Badlands)
Frenzied Bloodseeker Bat (Bat, 60, Zul’Gurub (Raid))

Attack Speed 1.2 :
Deathmaw (Wolf, 53, Burning Steppes)
Feral Mountain Lion (Cat, 27-28, Hillsbrad Foothills)
Needles Cougar (Cat, 27-28, Thousand Needles)
Slavering Worg (Wolf, 18-19, Shadowfang Keep (Dungeon))
Spiteflayer (Carrion Bird, 52, Blasted Lands)
Starving Mountain Lion (Cat, 23-24, Hillsbrad Foothills)
Swamp Jaguar (Cat, 36-37, Swamp of Sorrows)
The Rake (Cat, 10, Mulgore)

1 Like

Is that because he got hit with Warchief’s Blessing? I noticed a lot of super fast pet speeds, and it’s because pets pick up that buff and its haste.

Nope. Been like that since I tamed him at level 10

But is Brokentooth only 1-5% better? If so then I wouldn’t care if nothing is done. If it is like 10-20% better than that is a clear best pet that means choosing anything else is a handicap.

Not possible at level 10, please put up a picture of you and the pet unbuffed that shows attack speed. Put the pick up on site and the URL here, just put a space so you don’t have the post rejected due the forums stupid trust level crap.

Respect for that mindset, honestly! It’s great that some players stick to what they love regardless of the numbers.

The reality, though, is that you only have to walk around Orgrimmar or Stormwind for two minutes to see the exact same meta pet repeated everywhere. Most players feel pressured to optimize (especially for PvP or pug groups), and the whole game ends up looking less diverse because of it.

Giving us trainable attack speeds or Pet Transmog solves that completely, so both casual and minmax players get to bring their favorite beasts out of the stables!

2 Likes

I am level 23 now. I don’t really care if you don’t believe it or not. I have no incentive to lie about it. Just trying to he helpful with info. Test it yourself to verify or dispute.

Which tiger? And where tamed?

Durotar tiger. Says 1.3 speed on petopia i think. The islands SE of senjin village in durotar. I was shocked when i saw the attack speed. Even hunted down the attack speed macro to confirm what character sheet displayed.

1 Like

I have a 1.2 attack speed pet and I’m fine with it.

I tamed broken tooth in 2019 classic and in SoM, he is not a game changer tbh.

I’m more concerned about only having 3 stable slots and not a dedicated quiver slot either.

6 Likes

I use mystmane. I love my owlbear.

1 Like

Honestly, thank you for posting that Petopia list because it actually proves the exact point of this thread. Out of all the offensive, pure-DPS beasts in the game, that list has 11 specific mobs, and 7 of them are generic cats. Even within pure-DPS families, you can’t use iconic models like Humar the Pridelord, Echeyakee, Winterspring Frostsabers, raptors, owls, or wind serpents without dropping down to 1.5 or 2.0+ attack speed.