Hi Everyone, I hope that it’s going smooth for you guys.
Heads-up: this post is going to be pretty long, with no TL;DR.
The fantasy: I started WoW when I was 10, or - should I say - really started WoW when I was 13. I tried multiple classes. Back then what I cared about is fun and fantasy only - I didn’t care if “X is better than Y in raids or not”. I ended up being an Undead Warrior - and throughout many years of my journey I always remained one. I am 31 now and I am still dedicated. In the World of Warcraft, where everyone has ancient or forbidden or Holy powers, where everyone can call elements or shapeshift into animals or tame some, you’re just a regular fighter with nothing but dedication and discipline. I guess that correlates well with what I’m going through in life - regular guy fighting his way through things in life, just good at never giving up. The particular interest to me is Arms spec - big, slow, calculated hits, where you pay the price and see/feel the result. Boom - Mortal Strike - 30 rage - big chunk of damage. My vision would be - give up on ability to heal yourself or others, give up on ranged combat and your feeling of safety, give up on crazy CC-chains, give up on your quality of life - just straight combat, facetank the consequence, get rewarded if you do everything correct. See those big numbers. That what gave me pleasure through the Lich King and Cataclysm - two of my favorite expansions, the ones I had most fun in, good times…
Time to play the Warcraft: I’m 31, married, have a wonderful toddler. Family above all, so I only get to play around 4-5 times a week in the evening - mostly 1.5-2 hours at a time.
Forever hype: I was c-r-a-z-y hyped when Forever was announced. I LOVE warcraft - this is my favorite game of my life I guess. Unfortunately, I heavily disagree with the direction of Retail (I’m not here to say retail is bad or whatever - it has its’ pros for sure). So when Forever was announced - I was really happy that we’re getting this “Classic vibes with slight alterations to fix bad decisions from before”. I remember the spirit of the game, the slow progression, the “feels earned” instead of just granted for basically every single item you get. Man, I was shaking with happiness when I got my first blue two-hander. I’m 31 btw.
My overall experience: for PvP, I’d say I’m a pretty decent player, but nothing near r1 top of the top. Mostly rated PvP player. I’ve achieved my first glad title in early Cata. Then a glad every now and then. I’m no longer playing retail, the last exp for me to really play WoW was Dragonflight and I was top-500 warriors in soloshuffle in my Region. Overall I have 9 Glad Titles, although they don’t really matter novadays after transitioning to fixed rating instead of %-based.
I decided to try PvE once Mythic+ has been announced and has an absolute time of my life. I’ve cleared all * achievements multiple times. I quit in Dragonflight and my last season was 3 I believe. I was around 3100 rio and felt like I could go more if I had time.
My starting leveling experience: leveling a warrior has always been pain. I know it, you know it. But honestly, I was very enthusiastic about Forever. I heard there would be changes for QoL for classes, but I went in blind. I never checked for what’s coming, never knew who got what etc. etc. Except for my ret pala friend talking about his new talents all the time despite me asking for no spoilers. And this guy was also teasing me with “A new cool ability for warriors”. And honestly, I just logged in, created my Undead Warrior and started. Everything was smooth - even easier than I remember - until level 10. I dinked the level, was excited to see my new talents. Press N - Arms.
So let’s talk about Arms talents.
New talent - Spearing strike. A brutal attack that deals 75% weapon damage. Excuse me? A talent with a cooldown that basically does less than autoattack? Am I missing something? Well actually yes, because: Deals an additional 75% weapon damage against Giants, Dragonkin, and mounted targets. I’m level 35, so far I’ve fought 0 Giants or Dragons in the game for all the hours I’ve spent in it. The ability also dismounts - but why? Let’s say you see a mounted enemy running away - charge and hamstring baseline. Any player in the game would just instantly dismount themselves. What is the particular usage of this cool new ability? It’s very “Niche”, but what exactly does it reward you with? I’ve discovered that enhancement shamans had their Stormstrike at 150% just all the time. No additional requirement whatsoever. Press the button - get damage. It got nerfed to 100%, but it’s still better than mine? Who’s the master of Arms here? ![]()
But LET’S assume for the sake of the game that every enemy in the game is either a Dragon or a Giant - okay? An attack on 20 seconds cooldown with 15 rage requirement is literally a swing and a half. So if it lands, doesn’t get dodged, parried or missed, on my level that’s like 200 damage? Uhhh?
Well, okay, because the ability might be tweaked afterwards, this is a launch in the end of the day. By that time I’ve already seen that mages got Ice Lance, rogues got TWO saps (what the?) and some new attacks, every now and then everyone around me would be /yay’ing about how happy they are with all the things added to their class. What else did I get, let’s see.
Bloodthrill - this one is looking good. I expected it to be a gamechanger. And it’s kinda decent. It’s doesn’t proc as often as you would expect. I’m not sure if there’s some sort of inner cooldown or what, but it’s surely not 20% - not 1 in 5 hits. There are times where I kill a mob, charge into the 2nd one, get him down to half life and that’s my 1st proc. Anyways I didn’t actually measure the proc rate, so it’s kinda a meh argument. Just my own feeling. To me, this is the best thing happened to Arms in Forever.
Aaaaand that’s it. Basically that’s it. Okay, keep going.
So once I’ve arrived to Crossroads, things became waaaaaaay slower and harder. That was to be expected, not my first time leveling a warrior. Got some gear from AH, crafted some, went in couple dungeons. I was doing okay-ish.
Pulling 2 mobs or a caster mob would almost always mean either a death or me being like 10% hp after the fight. The worst part is that you can’t actually do anything, since you don’t have anything except for autoattack and an “Improved” autoattack (actually, not really, heroic strike is the worst ability in the whole game). So it’s basically “If I miss 5 attacks, I lose. If I don’t, I’ll win.” Rend does no damage at all. We’re talking 13 damage ticks when a mob is at 500 health.
By that time I already saw the absolute BONKERS that prot warrior had in their talents. Well, how about 60% more damage with your #1 damaging ability starting as soon as you hit 16? So yeah, I just specced prot and MY GOD this was day and night. Man, I can pull like 3 mobs with no risk at all. I’m talking retail level of confidence. I do way more damage than arms. Way more. And I get multiple times tankier. So basically I’m losing nothing - not even damage - by going prot. And then I get to charge in defensive? This basically eliminates the need to get out of D stance forever.
And I kept leveling as prot for like 15 levels. Because it’s just better, not because I like it.
But hitting level 30 I was like “Hey man, this is WoW Forever, where the game is about the journey, not the destination. Why am I playing something I don’t like?” - I went it, got the best rare 2H I could find and specced Arms again.
Worst mistake ever. I lost in damage. I lost in survivability. I lost in comfort. I lost in confidence. The spec feels like a Temu version of warrior. I was really upset. My time to kill a mob would not really increase to be honest with you. Even if it did, this would not justify me pulling 2 mobs max against prot warrior pulling half of the yard.
I went to a couple of battlegrounds and I saw Enh shamans oneshot (not an exaggeration - literall one shot - kill in 0.1 seconds) people. Ret palas would just obliterate people in HoJ. I don’t even want to talk mages. I could die to a rogue never leaving CC. Like Ever.
Maybe the things will change once I stop being an autoattack simulator and get to 40 to get a Mortal Strike. But for now I’m still basically in a position where I’m sitting autoattacking a mob praying that multiple consecutive hits will not be missed or parried, so that I have enough rage to press WW. There are scenarios - and I’m not being dramatic - where you would land 0 hits in 3 swings and would just sit there for your swing timer x 3 seconds. My weapon is 3.6 - that’s 3.6x3=10.8 seconds of no succesful autoattacks = no rage = afk tanking a mob for almost 11 seconds. Yes you get some rage when you’re taking hits - it’s enough for a rend. That’s just… boring?
Now be with me on this one: on the one hand, this is “Your” journey, who cares what others got, but on the other, it’s just weird when my best friend ret pala can do 1.5k damage in 2 globals. It’s like he can do everything I can, but better. He can heal, I can’t. He can stun, I can’t. Half of his damage doesn’t “Miss”. There are no scenarios where he’s like “dang, missed an autoattack, I guess I’ll just afk for 4 seconds”. You see where I’m coming from?
When everyone is better at everything, what is even the point of being there?
Name me any spec and I’ll tell you what they exceed in.
What is Arms best in? I’m supposed to be a slow melee machine with no ranged attacks, no immunities, no heals, no CC, but unmatched in melee combat. Yet a ret pala or enh would not run away from me. Why would they?
I understand things might be a little better at 40, but even now I can tell even from the tooltip that Mortal Strike literally does way less damage than Shield Slam. Read that again.
I’m really struggling right now and am this close to quitting. I’ve expressed my concerns to my pala buddy and all he says is
Just play prot
Just play someone else
It gets better at 60
Well I know it does, but why do I have to wait to 60 to play the game? Wasn’t Forever supposed to be about “Don’t rush to 60, take your time, enjoy the game, it’s about the journey” thing? Or is it enjoy the leveling, but not you brown two-handed guys? Why am I forced to play something else? How is rushing to 60 and getting raid gear in order to become relevant - enjoying the journey?
I know people will comment something like “Skill issue” or “Just play prot” or “It gets better at full raid gear” or “This class is not for you” or something else. Well, maybe. But I think it’s deeper than that. I think I misunderstood what Forever really is or supposed to be. Or was misleaded by whatever rhetorics. “Well, what would you expect, it was always like this in Vanilla?” - right, but is your leveling experience that same as in Vanilla? Half of the classes got their signature abilities from Retail, while Arms got almost nothing. And I don’t want to wait months autoattacking mobs prior to “well the game starts at 60”, because this is not what was advertised.
And, unfortunately, the game turned out to be just not for me probably. And that’s fine.
Thanks for reading this post for so long and I sincerely wish everyone good luck and to have a good time in Forever. Because the atmosphere and the setting have been incredible. I personally have no desire to “Just roll or spec into someone else”, because this is a part of the problem that made Retail Retail. And I was in Forever for Forever, not “Old Retail”.
Have a nice one,
/bye