Raid Encounter Design in Season 3

Last week we made several adjustments to The Venomous Abyss with the intent of reducing the number of damage events that could kill you or your entire raid with a single individual mistake. We believe this type of severe mechanical penalty was used too often in The Venomous Abyss, causing the associated mechanics to become frustrating as the season wore on. Our goal with these changes was to ensure that damage events feel more proportional to player mistakes and to reduce the number of instances where individual mistakes could easily trigger group wipes. A couple examples from that list of changes:

  • Malice damage was reduced by 45% on Mythic and 63% on Normal/Heroic, which should now help a failed interrupt feel like a punishing but recoverable group mistake.
  • Reductions to Noxious Splash’s initial damage (33%) and damage-over-time component (84%) should help ensure that a single individual’s mistake no longer feels like a death sentence.

We feel that our design has shifted over time at the expense of the average Mythic player’s experience. Going forward into Season 3, we’d like to intentionally pull back on some of these severe mechanical penalties, even at the start of the season. Once Season 3 launches on the Public Test Realm, we’d like to invite you to test each difficulty of the new raid and see for yourselves.

What is a “mechanical penalty”?
Generally, when an encounter designer creates a mechanic, they also design a corresponding penalty to reinforce the gameplay that the mechanic is intended to incentivize.

Sometimes this can be very simple. If an add spawns in the encounter and the tank doesn’t establish threat on it quickly, it can melee and endanger other players. The tank needs to pick that add up quickly, which is hopefully fun gameplay for the tank. That’s pretty straightforward.

Other times, these penalties can be complex. Let’s use Heroic Ula’tek as an example. If enough individual players don’t contribute to soaking Stone Venom, a player will be affected by Calcified Corpse and very likely wipe the raid. Players need to split into roughly equal groups, react quickly, and ensure that they’re staying with their assigned player until the Stone Venom aura has expired. Calcified Corpse exists only to reinforce gameplay that we want players to enjoy in that phase.

“The Punishment Must Fit the Crime”
When we design mechanics and their corresponding penalties, it’s important for them to be proportional to each other. For example, a small missile landing on a character should generally not kill an appropriately geared character from 100% HP. However, if every player in the raid collectively ignores Malacrass’ cast of Eternal Nightfall, he will eventually complete his cast and destroy the raid.

When mechanics and their penalties are out of proportion, a sense of frustration usually sets in. This threshold (what feels “unfair”) can be very different from player to player, and we spend a lot of time internally discussing what will feel right for each raid difficulty.

We’ve heard a lot of player feedback about this element of raid difficulty. Going forward, we want to be more lenient in places where we’ve previously killed players in a single damage event or quickly wiped the raid as a result of a single point of failure. Our hope is to retain the challenge and sense of achievement you feel from completing encounters - but allow for more satisfying progression along the way. Fewer wipes that feel like “instant death” and more wipes that feel like a slow unraveling as the group makes mistakes and productively learns from them.

Again, we invite you to join us on the Season 3 PTR once it begins. Please join us for raid testing and let us know your thoughts.

14 Likes

Looking forward to the 12.2 last boss with twice as many seed + bullet hell mechanics. Gonna be insane in the membrane (goated achievement btw). Thanks for the update!

5 Likes

Ya, seed carrying is such a lazy unfun mechanic, it’s been way to prevelant recently and needs to die.

18 Likes

Lol. You guys only care about making the raid hard for the RWF. Nobody likes raiding Mythic. It hasn’t been enjoyable for many years. The ones still doing it are lying if they say it’s fun.

You won’t dupe me into playing 12.2 I already quit Midnight, and I am done until The Last Titan. Not interested in your cantrip items. They are cool except they come from an unpuggable nightmare of a boss that I’d rather quit the game than waste 2-3 hours wiping to that boss just to try to use ONE bonus roll.

Nah fam. I am done with Retail for now. I am also not playing Forever, I played in 2004 originally, don’t need to go back on some nostalgia trip.

3 Likes

Perhaps more importantly, moving in to the next season, I think it’s crucial for encounter designers to consider designing fights in such a way that a single players absence from raid that evening should not immediately make the rest of the team feel like they are going to be wasting the next 2-4 hours of their time.

Mechanics such as L’ura Crystals and Ula’tek Eggs require certain players to take on a disproportionate amount of responsibility for the raid team’s success which can create frustrating situations as is, but when one of those players is not available to play, the amount of time it takes for a different player to learn that role is often quite high, this means that 1-2 raid nights might be spent reprogessing the encounter simply because someone has a different job.

This also disproportionately impacts lower end guilds more, because their seasons last much longer, which means that personal life events will almost certainly come up.

These kinds of mechanics need to be limited, or eliminated entirely from the raid design.

33 Likes

I mean you guys write this same PR letter after every single raid tier since the middle of Dragonflight and you have literally never followed through on it.

Here’s some player feedback for you: WE are tired of YOUR constant talking instead of doing. WE are tired of YOUR constant words instead of actions.

Quit writing these nightmare PR letters that are exhausting to read (we are gamers and humans not bots) and please lord start doing actions.

18 Likes

Based profile image

Yall have been saying this same song and dance since Sepulcher of the First Ones and you haven’t actually changed your design philosophy.

Stop telling us. Just actually do it.

17 Likes

I’ll believe this when I see it, but good of Blizzard to say at least something and not just let S3 arrive in silence.

That being said, can we also permanently ban eggs/seeds/etc. from final bosses? It’s not fun to have players navigating high intensity SPOF OR borderline sleep-inducing fights based on whether or not theyre assigned to carry a bomb for 10 minutes that explodes if the wind blows too hard.

4 Likes

not just final bosses, all bosses

halonrus sucked

1 Like

This type of mechanic has no business being present in any raid at all. The only guaranteed raid wipe mechanic should be the engage timer. Every time you include a mechanic where the inadvertent actions of a single player can potentially cause a wipe you’re virtually guaranteeing that the level of toxicity and rancor surrounding the encounter will be off the charts. No one needs to sweat that much, let alone in an ancient MMO like WoW.

You keep harping on about how much you lament the death of the social aspect of MMOs but then you actively design encounters that promote antisocial behavior like exclusion and ostracism. Ever since your war on addons and the subsequent massive increase in the difficulty of raid encounters you’ve been quite literally pouring gasoline on the fire and wondering why it won’t go out.

7 Likes

All I care about is you guys don’t wait until like week 19 to actually balance your content for smaller groups. We always raid with 10-15 at most and we can always tell when we hit mechanics you clearly balanced around 20-30 people.

9 Likes

this raid tier was absolutely atrocious. You guys need a serious re-evaluation on encounter design, which yeah you admit to doing but man… you literally changed calcified corpse to kill the raid in a hotfix. a lot of these bosses are just not fun to do. The only failure that turned into a success, was Vashniks horrible design. No one does the fight like you intended, and they cheese it with the one area tech. massive design failure that actually benefited the players.

And as a tank, no… getting aggro on an add is NOT fun gameplay… this already tells me you dont know what tanks want. Make it so the add gets aggroed and gives the tank a dmg boost or something… that makes tanking interesting. Not oh i get to let a mob hit me for nothing…

oh and STOP USING THE STUPID EGG MECHANIC

4 Likes

They seemingly want to dps and not tank, to which I think, they should just go play dps.

Heroic raid was fine, as for mythic, only two fights with teeth. One with a mechanic I dislike, and the final boss’s mechanic was resolved in an unintended way.

Vashnik is horrible. You can just go lfr for target dummies.

So how much perfection should players expect for mechanics? Ula’tek waves is probably a good starting point between both lethal and non-lethal depending on the scenario.

1 Like

Just going to leave this here because well, we’ve been here before. So unfortunately, I will not believe it until I see it.

Lessons Learned: Sepulcher was an Arms Race that Won’t be Repeated in Dragonflight - Wowhead News

15 Likes

It’s not just instant wipe mechanics though, and that’s not even the biggest problem, the biggest problem is that fundamentally, almost every single encounter this expansion except for Sszorak across every single raid so far has had waves of adds that typically die within 5-10 secs, disproportionately making specialisations that cannot deal adequate single target or multi-target damage without changing their talent builds up substantially, feel like they are completely useless within raid encounters, period.

We’ve coined these kind of encounters “add slop fights”, every single encounter that has had adds in it except for Entombed Sentinels, L’ura and Vorasius has had every single one of those adds die almost instantly (and this would have happened for Vorasius adds as well if it didn’t cause your raid group to explode on the spot), many of them have also featured spawn points designed purely to necessitate the existence of Death Grip, majorly shrinking the comp diversity for melee players if Blood Death Knights haven’t been desirable tanks as raid groups now need to bring at least 1 or 2 DPS Death Knights just to group up adds. Melee isn’t exactly a role where you can bring more than 5 in the first place to most encounters (Coiled Altar is the most egregious example of not being able to bring almost any melee at all just to be able to do the encounter on mythic).

Having raided as Feral Druid this expansion has been an eye opening experience for me, nearly every single fight with adds in it it has not been worth even bothering to target them as by the time any of my DoTs would have been able to do meaningful damage the adds have been long dead, or I simply cannot hit them because they spawn on opposite ends of the encounter room.

This is misery, the value of being a boss damage spec this expansion simply has not existed outside of 3 fights because boss damage as a metric DOES NOT MATTER anymore. Please stop making encounters where adds die in 5-10 secs. PLEASE!

I want single target fights to matter again. I want Death Grip to stop being designed in to so many encounters that aren’t enriched by its existence. I want adds to stop dying the moment they spawn. I want my spec not to be the worst raid spec in the game every single season.

10 Likes

Do Not Besmirch the King in that way. Side note: I literally loved every single thing about that fight on all diffs but can see the friction it caused.

You always know the right things to say.

If only you ever actually followed through.

2 Likes

Based on Blizzard history of correction you will go overboard in the opposite direction and the next raid is going to be to be severely easy on normal and heroic difficulties.

Can we add to this list trash that isn’t a nightmare? Kithix is the worst offender with bolt spam, unclear purple mechanics, toxic pools, and tornadoes that are too close together?

1 Like