Please remove auction LIFO queues and undercutting protection

The combination of LIFO queues and undercutting protection are causing severe price crashes due to how it accelerates the race to the bottom for auction prices.

I understand the reasoning behind the changes, but that logic used to implement them does not hold up to scrutiny of real world results.

For example, if I see a bunch of wool cloth posted at 10 silver, and I post mine at 10 silver, I am immediately at the front of the queue, but on the current forever mega servers, someone is guaranteed to post again in a few seconds, pushing me back in line. As more and more people get pushed in front of me, it guarantees that I’m now moving to the back of the line, getting farther and farther from a sale, until I lose my deposit because the auction expires without selling.

Because of this, a lot of people will choose to undercut, but because you can’t undercut by 1 copper, the price doesn’t just drop 1%, it drops 10%, and then by the time 2 people undercut it’s dropped 20%, crashing the market entirely and making it unprofitable to post on the AH at all.

Old system: 50 undercuts = 9s, 50c
New system: 5 undercuts = 5s

TLDR:

  1. LIFO queues incentivize undercutting because people realize that you can no longer patiently wait for your item to move through the queue like it would in FIFO.
  2. People will undercut no matter what, but forcing them to undercut by 10% of the price causes massive and near instant price crashes on anything where there are more than a few people posting.
1 Like

This is a good change.

No more gold buying through the AH.

Actual Blizzard W here

4 Likes

TBH the retail AH in forever is the one thing i hate the most about forever.

3 Likes

the thing about only ‘buying’ the cheapest in the AH… on a highly needed item when lots of people are buying it… buy the time i click ‘buy’ it’s already gone… happened several times in beta.. on common crafting mats… that had 100s at the lowest price

so.. you buy the 2nd or 3rd lowest price in that situation.

This economy is wild. Nothing has value. I’ve been selling light leather to the vendor because the AH prices are garbage and not worth the hassle.

I feel bad for someone seeking mats to work up their skills. But it’s not worth the huge deposit and time-locked money delivery.

3 Likes

Haha don’t even get me started on the fact that if I want to buy some linen cloth, every time I press buy I get “that item is no longer available”. It takes me an average of 7 attempts to purchase anything.

2 Likes

LIFO is a fine design imho. Some people don’t understand how it works and they undercut when it does them no good whatsoever. Normally, you could just post at the price you want to sell it for and wait for demand to outpace supply - which it will often do.

The real problem is the 1s minimum deposit. You can’t just post an item at a fair price and wait for demand to catch up because the risk is too great.

This was a change they made in wrath iirc, and it does not belong in Forever where many items sell for 1s or less. It was reported as a bug during beta.

2 Likes

This is the problem with merged AHs is that there is way more supply then there is demand to the point of Vendors being a better more profitable avenue then selling to people.

2 Likes

Thats the problem though, there is not enough demand to meet the supply, so its a race to the bottom, its why prices are in the gutter for everything.
You have an entire mega server of people selling things.

Great that means it’s working. :slight_smile:

1 Like

Me too. I was really surprised when a green enchanting recipe that dropped had no value at all. I accidentally made an extra pair of leather boots. When I went to sell the AH was absolutely flooded with them. Better to just mail to a friend even though I’m broke and could have used the silver.

1 Like

That’s just how supply and demand work.

The real problem is the 1s minimum deposit.

You can’t just post an item at a fair price and wait for demand to catch up because the risk is too great. If you could do that, demand would eventually catch up to the supply in many cases.

1 Like

Beauty is that if doesn’t sell in the auction house you have NPC’s that will always provide you with coin.

This isn’t supply and demand. They have artificial controls and systems on the AH to force all lower prices with the LIFO system.

That is meant to prevent undercutting. Without LIFO, the race to the bottom would be even faster. Lifo removes the incentive to undercut because your place is line will not change.

As long as I make a profit I will undercut all day long. If someone wants to buy it and put it back then good for them.

You are operating under the assumption that people will wait for their item to sell, people want to sell their items as fast as they can. As a result people will put it lower to sell it faster. This is because right now everyone else is doing the same thing, so the goal becomes sell it as quick as possible because we know the prices are going to tank.

Its the same thing that happened in retail, prices are strong at the start, but then drop like a rock. That problem is exacerbated in forever because its a mega server and its flooded with people right now.

What you are suggesting only works if you are assuming that people are willing to wait for thier thing to sell, which is not reality. People want their goods moved asap.

See the poster literally right above me as the living example.

LIFO removes the incentive to undercut. If you undercut, a bunch of people will just match the undercut price, and you are in the same spot as you were before - except you are on the top of a new Lifo list. Your place in line does not change. Your items sell no faster than it would have sold if you didn’t undercut.

If you FIFO it, then the incentive to undercut is real. If you undercut, your place in line changes. So, every new person will undercut, and that will drive the price through the floor even fast.

Not really sure why people have so much trouble understanding the mechanics of this.

Again: The real problem is the 1s deposit. You can’t afford to let items expire.

Someone wants to price gouge they deserve to be under cut, selling lvl 10 greens for 2-3 gold is pure greed.

Except it does because people list after you, meaning you get stuck at 100th out of 1000 and nobody ever buys your item.

2 Likes