Caster Shaman is UNPLAYABLE now: here's why (and how id make changes)

Hello,

Here’s a quick bit about myself. I have played shaman in every expansion since Vanilla TBC (Minus Original Classic where i went alliance hunter, a throwback to what I played in vanilla). I recently mained shaman at 60 on anniversary, playing both ele and enhance, and then mainly just ele at 70 on TBC. I have more of an inclination towards pvp, but I love to raid as ele as well. These last minute changes feel like a complete F U to both resto and ele shaman. Both in pvp and pve. Here is some of my reasoning.

Some very simple things to start, that I still can’t believe were never addressed when class redesign started in the first place:

Why is shaman still the ONLY class in the game with 0 baseline hard cc’s (especially now that druid can also root indoors)

Why is resto Shaman the ONLY healer in the game with 0 defensive mitigation buttons. (Rdruid barkskin and bear + frenzy rejuv / Pally BoP and Divine Shield / Priest PW:shield and Pain Suppression) Stoneskin totem and windwall totem are garbage and can also be 1 shot by rank 1 moonfire or wands so I dont even consider them defensive tools.

Why is enhance a 2handed spec but still has maelstrom weapon, a proc on hit ability, when there is no dual wield??? why is spirit weapons a talent in the game but still enhance can’t tank?

Why do totems have 1 health, and why can they be targeted and destroyed at all?

Now to the awful changes that happened most recently, which is sad, because the recent iteration of elemental, where flame shock was 35 yards, i could project totems into the fight, and I still had lava burst to cast a second school, while also getting some combat mana regen and still having access to instant ghost wolf, well that had me really excited to play. Even without a hard cc, a lot of the glaring weaknesses had been shored up. But then they listened to the pve andy’s, gutted everything, and now we have a spec that is arguably worse than what it was in Vanilla.

The most egregious is the ghost wolf change. Moving it down two rows seems completely arbitrary, absolutely shafting ele and resto, who arguably actually need the mobility more because of 0 long range instant cast spells. Why does gw have a cast time at all? why do you need to burn talent points to reduce it? does travel form, blink, sprint, (which are available to all specs) have a 3 sec cast time? Its a massive pve nerf for any fight with mobility. And in terms of a pvp nerf, it only stops me now from either getting mana sustain as ele or better dmg casting as resto, but you can still grab it with either spec, just with the trade off of severely gimping your normal gameplay. So it just feels absolutely arbitrary.

Removing lava burst is a GIANT PVP LOSS. Now when kicked on nature spells you’re literally stuck there doing nothing for the duration of the silence. Having a second castable school for dmg is imperative for pvp. In vanilla you used to be able to at least drop a fire nova totem which actually hurt and hit a frost shock which equally hurt. Now if you want to fire nova you need to burn a global dropping a fire totem (which can still be one shot by rank 1 moonfires) just to hit your fire nova, which also hits like a wet noodle now. Also, when nature locked, you can only cast fire totems, which makes 0 sense thematically. My air and water and earth totems are all nature spells? Where are the other “elements” for elemental shaman, we are now just lightning casters, so why are we even called shamans when were just storm callers?

Our rotation is literally the same as vanilla now, LB until you get a proc then Chain Lightning, but now ALL of those spells are objectively worse and do less dmg and have less scaling, and we don’t have the benefit anymore of being the caster that does double crit dmg (boomkin and destro both get the 100% crit buff dmg now) AS WELL AS not having the old elemental mastery so we cant even batch a CL into earth shock for big burst dopamine hits.

Totemic Projection change makes 0 sense. Why do elemental shamans get access to improved fire nova, when i cant even send my totems in from range? i have to stop casting, run into melee, burn a global to drop a totem, then hit fire nova, only to have run into the pack again to bring my totems to me when the tank pulls a new grp or repositions the current one? why is a caster expected to be running into a melee group every time they want to actually aoe, oh and btw I cant instant gw anymore to make the run in quicker. Totemic Projection needs to be the same as retail, ten second cd, point and click sends all my totems, 0 mana cost.

Totems STILL only have 1 hp and can be one shot by rank 1 spells. Totems not having any protection against getting auto destroyed in pvp, and even still being targetable is crazy work. Baffling to me that not a single version of wow really ever addressed totem’s glaring weakness. Make them have a larger health pool, or even better just make them un-targetable.

Shock range being 20 yards makes 0 sense for casters. Frost shock and Flame shock should at least be the same as lightning bolt’s range, if you want to keep earth shock lower due to it being an interrupt i wouldn’t agree with it but at least I’d understand, but not being able to use my dot until i run into 20 yards feels so bad.

Reiterating this: SHAMAN IS THE ONLY CLASS WITHOUT A BASELINE CC. STILL. Let that sink in. Enh gets no stun, ele has to talent into a melee root, once again making you more a melee player than a range caster.

Riptide is a useless spell now. A 12 sec cd hot that heals for less than the amount of absorb than PW: shield makes now sense. druids can spam rejuv, priests renew, why would you take away the up front healing and then DOUBLE the cd? the biggest weakness of resto was they have no instant cast healing, pallys get holy shock and bubbles, priests renews and shields, druids rejuvs and swiftmends. Why would anyone even consider taking riptide now in pvp? Its a literal button to buff chain heal now and has 0 value on its own. It is now the worst capstone talent in the game IMO.

Resto Shaman will easily be the worst pvp healer in the game, getting trained by all melee and locked out of all their hard cast healing spells with no counterplay. Even pally’s, the other hard casting healer, has holy shock, bubbles, and silence reduction in the talent tree

Again, shamans get 0 defensive protection spells for themselves. No shields or dmg reduction buttons, with 0 instant cast heals, the pvp meta is now back to sit on every resto shaman you see, and always just train blue. Cant even gw to try to kite away now.

SOME VERY BAD DISPARITY WITH OTHER HYBRID’S QOL CHANGES:
If you want spell pushback mitigation as shaman, you need to spec into it twice, once in ele for dmg spells, once in resto for healing spells, both of which are at least 3 rows into the tree. Meanwhile druids get pushback resistance on both healing an dmg spells, one talent, first row of resto, no investment needed at all.

The two talents on the first row of the ele tree are absolute GARBAGE. Want dmg increase? 5% for 5 pts. Balance gets 10% for 5 pts. Want mana reduction on dmg? 10% for 5 pts. meanwhile, balance and resto druids can get 25% reduction in mana for dmg spells for 3 pts.

Some Glaring Design Flaws:

The call of the ancestors spells. Three second cast time? are you kidding me? I’d rather hit 4 separate keybinds with the reduced 1 sec gcd, for a total of 4 secs of time but i can be completely mobile for the duration. Really it should be: you drop 2 totems? instant cast. Drop 3? 1 sec cast time, can cast while moving. Drop 4? 1.5 sec cast time, can cast while moving.

Enhancement:

Having Maelstrom weapon completely pigeonholes elemental’s design, especially now there isn’t a spell that is exclusive to elemental. How do you buff lightning bolt without indirectly buffing enhancement? Maelstrom Weapon effectively makes elemental impossible to balance without effecting enhancement… Just bad design

Having so much ap and sp scaling in the enhancement tree from int that enhance shamans now want caster mail, will use flametongue weapon over wf weapon, and will have more total spell power than elementals.

Not having a stun. Not having a defensive on use ability. Not having a gap closer like charge or leap / not having a true sprint or a movement steroid like rets 15% move speed.

If you want to invest only 31 talents in the enhancement tree, being forced to either miss out on a point of flurry and imp gw entirely, or miss out on 3 pts of flurry be able to take all the talents in row 5 (which feel mandatory). Just another reason the gw change was SOOOOO bad.

Resto:

Having a capstone that not only feels weak, but narrows your rotation to a point that you don’t want to cast chain heal on someone without riptide if its up on someone else.

Having a pseudo HoT in the form of healing stream totem, that not only does very very little healing, but competes with your mana regen totems and can also be destroyed by rank1 spells and wands in pvp.

Not being able to get dmg AND healing pushback resistance in one talent, thus making solo play as resto feel clunky and slow.

Being a one button chain heal rotation with a second button press every 12 secs to just “buff that chain heal”

Having no button that is “press this button to surive”, in disparity with ALL other healers.

Elemental:

Being a 1 spell school caster, all totems excepting fire tired to nature school.

Water shield having a proc on crit. Having to press a global every 10-15 secs just to put my mana regen up just so I can then cast my spells feels bad. needs to be mp5 or never lose charges.

Not being able to shock outside of 20 yards, not being able to drop totems and then fire nova outside of melee.

Not having early access to dmg pushback talents or effective mana reduction talents

Weapon imbue choices having little to no meaningful interactions for elemental. No caster buffs associated with any of them.

Having 0 caster buff representation in totems, no spell power, spell hit, or spell crit totems. Spell haste totem would just be bad design.

Having a talent for mana reduction on dmg spells be only 10%, and only be a small subset of all dmg spells cast.

If you want to invest only 31 talents into Elemental, being forced to miss out on either one pt of Elemental Reach or one of Elemental Fury, which both feel mandatory.

Having two 5 pt talent sinks on the first row of the tree that aren’t engaging and / or weak.

Lightning Overload proc chance on Chain Lightning in single target being 10% not 30%, thus reinforcing never wanting to hit Chain lightning in single target, coupled with the fact that the changes in base spell casting speed have weakened Lighting Bolt’s Scaling, and made Chain lightning a now sluggish 2 secs.

Having what feels like 0 elemental representation for the “elemental” spec outside of lightning and nature. Fantasy should feel like this: Resto: water and nature, Enh: wind and earth, Ele: All the other elements, Lightning and Fire and Ice.

Changes I Would Make (beyond what was suggested already) :

Remove all totems from spell school lock outs, they should be physical spells.

Resto:

Get rid of Healing Focus, combine it with ele’s pushback resistance talent, 1st row of ele tree 5/5 pts, both dmg and healing spells, just like druid.

Move Riptide down to an 11pt talent, remove cd, remove chain heal buff, make healing on par with renew and rejuv (resto now has a reliable HoT they can spread).

Remove charge count on watershield, or remove crit proc and add mp5

Remove Healing stream totem entirely, or change functionality by making the totem un-targetable and having it be a delayed explosion after casting into a solid aoe heal for party members, 15-30 sec cd.

Add new capstone: Earth Shield variant, acts similar to Pain suppression, short duration %dmg reduction that has a moderate cd, maybe can grant interrupt immunity (resto now has a much needed I live button).

Enhancement:

Storm Strike reverts to 8 sec cd. Get rid of maelstrom weapon. Shocks are 30 yard baseline

New talent where maelstrom weapon was: separates the cds of earth shock and flame/frost shock. Adds 4 seconds to earth shock cd (now 10sec) Enhance becomes a melee and shock build.

Bring over reverberation from the elemental tree to the enhance tree, replacing imp lightning shield. make it 3 pt talent that reduces shock cd’s by .66/1.2/2 secs (earth shock is now 8 sec, flame and frost shock both share a 4 sec cd)

Lightning shield either has 0 charges , or reverberation removes the mana cost and it stays a 3 charges.

New capstone Talent: either 30-45 sec cd, 4 sec stun that can be used at range, or 20-30 sec gap close similar to charge. Enhance now has a some kite protection or a lock down cc.

Guardian Totems talent Removed, Stoneclaw totem reworked: when dropped grants the shaman a shield that absorbs a % of total health incoming dmg. Earth’s Grasp talent now reduces the cd by 15 secs or it can buff the shield amount and reduce cd by 10 secs. All Shamans now have a reliable defensive in the form of a shield on a low to moderate cd. This can also be made to help bring shaman tank to reality.

Spirit Weapons slight rework: When rockbiter is active turns earth shock into a taunt. Removed the threat component from earth shock baseline.

Rework Rockbiter weapon: When active increases chance to block by a % and increases armor of worn items by a % or just flat %dmg reduction. Shaman tanks are now a reality, have actual mitigation, good threat, a taunt, and a defensive on use.

Toughness is baked into Anticipation: 3 pts. 6% stam increase total.

Elemental Weapons slightly buffs their imbue totem counterparts. Enh now has a slightly stronger wf or flametongue totem now over resto and ele and a specific raid identity

Elemental:

Fire Nova Now moved to be tied to your most recent flame shock, not fire totems.

Remove Grace of Air Totem, Add wrath of air totem talent, 3rd row next to elemental focus, which increases spell power by a moderate amount (there is now a reason to bring ele to raid, resto can choose to grab it as well if an enh has wf covered already.

First Row of talents are deleted. 5 pt pushback resistance talent that covers both dmg and healing spells added to first row.

Call of Flame and Elemental Devastation brought down to row 1, Elemental devastation reduced to 2pts, changed to be melee crits increase spell crit chance by 2.5/5%

New mana reduction talent row 2: 3 pt talent, reduces mana cost of ALL dmg spells by 25%, on par with balance druid. Coupled with reverberation, makes enhancement’s shocks incredibly cheap.

Elemental Warding either gets removed or moved down to row 2

Elemental Alacrity gets reverted to be .33/.66/1 sec off cast times, Lightning bolt put back to 3 secs, Chain lightning back to 2.5 secs baseline (this fixes the scaling issues while making it still attractive for resto to take as well)

Improved Fire Nova gets moved down to row 3

Eye of the storm deleted and baked into first row talent above.

Elemental Reach moved down to row 4, increases range of all spells not just lightning chain lightning and fire nova

Call of Thunder removed: New talent, Elements Unleashed: having an active weapon imbue increases ALL spell critical strike chance by 5%. Perhaps increases spell power by a small amount as well. Elemental now has a reason to imbue.

New Capstone Talent: Some riff on elemental blast: 2 sec cast spell that changes based on what active imbue you’re using. Frostbrand imbued: Frost Spellschool nuke that also applies frostbrand weapon effect on cast at increased dmg and strength (now theres a reason to use frostbrand both in pvp and in conjuction with elemental blast as an opener, ele blast → auto slow → flameshock and lightning bolt cast on open world mobs). Flametongue imbued: Fire Spellschool nuke that erupts an active flame shock on the target, this effect can either explode for some aoe cleave, or possibly spread the flameshock to multiple targets in aoe. Windfury imbued: Nature spellschool nuke that increases either your speed for a short duration or perhaps makes your next lighning bolt or chain lightning castable while moving, or even the windfury version of the spell itslef is castable while moving (elemental now has multiple spell school by choice, imbue interaction, and tools for raid aoe, raid mobility, and mob/pvp slow in world content).

Final Thoughts:

Does any dev actually even play elemental? you buffed enhance when it wasn’t needed, and gutted ele when it was already struggling? And decided resto just doesn’t deserve a real capstone? More and more I get the feeling there is 0 elemental representation within the dev community, and the ones who do play shaman play alts and only as enhancement. 0 shaman love for a class that is in a partially broken state similar to how it is in both vanilla and tbc. Sadly shamans didn’t really receive the tools they needed to be a complete class until wotlk, and it looks like they will not be receiving any of those tools in Forever either. Here’s to hoping we get a massive shaman overhaul top to bottom.

4 Likes

Crit by wall of text

17 Likes

What Elemental really needs now is a third button, ideally Fulmination, and some help with mana. Other than that, I think Elemental is in a great place and Blizzard is finally taking it in the right direction.

We played through both Vanilla and TBC using Nature damage, and we were never weak or useless. Quite the opposite, we had a blast playing it. Being Nature-focused has always been part of Elemental’s identity.

1 Like

You claim being Nature-only makes us weak, yet you’re asking for Elemental Blast, a spell with a cast time that, if interrupted, could lock you out of Nature, Frost, and Fire all at once. Please, go back to Retail.

4 Likes

It…just kept scrolling. It never ended.

11 Likes

You’re on every post telling people to go back to retail. The changes OP mention are things that are no newer than Cata, a 16 year difference. How about you go back to Era, and let this game actually succeed long term. Shaman is a pile a trash where it stands, and needs something to make it better and actually feel decent to play.

4 Likes

You need to come to terms with it. We’re level 60, in the Vanilla world, and Vanilla is the foundation of this game. Every class has its strengths and weaknesses. If you want Retail, Cata, or Wrath, those versions already exist.

Forever starts from Vanilla, and that means accepting that every class has pros and cons. You can’t have everything. Deal with it.

And the fact that you complain about being locked out of a single school, Nature, while asking for Elemental Blast, which could get you locked out of Nature, Frost, and Fire all at once, tells me everything I need to know about how little thought you’ve put into this.

I would like to see an interaction between flame shock and frost shock. Kind of like a conflagerate idea.

Fire nova should also trigger off of a flame shock target. Espeically after totemic projection changes.

Move imp ghost wolf back up to row two.

The capstone talent is also very dull, but eh. Otherwise ele is fine, if they get a third rotation button.

1 Like

I was thinking about it too, in case FS would let you do firenova for ele, it wouldn’t be bad.. and frS maybe increase the nature damage

2 Likes

Vanilla being the foundation doesn’t mean every aspect of Vanilla has to remain untouched. That’s the entire point of a Wow forever. If the goal were simply to preserve Vanilla exactly as it was, there would be no reason to introduce new abilities, talent changes, or class reworks in the first place.

Also, this game is going to change whether you like it or not lol. Classic Andys like you are outnumbered greatly, and blizzard is gonna listen to the majority on class design and gameplay issues.

The developers themselves have made it pretty clear that Vanilla is the FOUNDATION, BUT not a rulebook that every original class limitation has to follow.

They’ve explicitly stated that one of their goals is to flesh out specializations that weren’t fully realized in Vanilla, ensure no spec feels useless, and give simpler classes more engaging depth without losing Classic’s pacing or identity.

2 Likes

My friend, you should read the latest development notes, where Blizzard explicitly says they want to move even further away from borrowing things from TBC and Wrath.

If they take new directions while respecting Vanilla’s identity, I’m all for it. In fact, that’s exactly what I’m here for. But getting a Retail version of Shaman? No thanks.

You call me an Andy, so can I call you a Retail Andy too?

Let’s make a bet: if this game becomes more and more like Retail, how long do you think it’ll take before it shuts down?

I believe we’ve all collectively agreed on Retail Randy :grin:


On topic… Sorry OP, that was a bit much to go through. It might help to structure your post a bit more and highlight the key points. This is actually where AI can help a lot. Asking it to summarize your thoughts and distil it down to the most relevant points can be a helpful way to organize and frame what you’re trying to convey. I’m not one to say that we should fully cater to the tiktok generation and keep things suuuuuuper brief, but you do have to respect your audience’s time at least a little bit.

If Elemental Shaman still needs some work, providing pointed and digestible feedback to the devs will help them understand the issues you’re having.

Cata was 16 years ago. If classes having more than 2 damage rotation buttons is too “retail” for you, then I guess we will just have to agree to disagree. Enjoy your new joke of a class lol

I can’t believe people still make giant posts like this. I undertand that you could be super low effort and use AI but either way absolutely no one is going to read it so it’s a waste of time regardless.

1 Like

Quoting that entire wall of text for one of the first replies is diabolical. Lol

1 Like

Debuff would be an interesting idea. I was leaning more like frost shock does 1.5x or 2x dmg.

Along debuff idea. You could do a combo system. Earth Shock + Flame Shock = Something with fire nova or searing totoem cleave. Frost shock + Flame shock = nature debuff or we get a mild lightning rod effect.

Something like that.

if you read all my posts I’ve always said that I like the direction and I’m happy to have just one element but a third button is missing

Let’s just play what they gave us for a few weeks and then see what happens.

1 Like

If you seriously logged into forever and said yup this classic you are actually delusional

Hello fellow shaman(s)

Day 1 Shaman here, vanilla and for classic re-release in 2019. I’ve been maining blue for 2 decades now and love this class more than anything.

Skimming through this post, I see many things I agree with. One of the main things: Shamans have always been on the back burner, and more focused as a support class rather than a chart topping powerhouse. (This is coming from one of the select few resto shaman PVP mains in MoP, to which we are arguably the worst healer in the game besides disc)

These nerfs for ele suck, the talents suck, and from what research I have been doing I don’t see us being viable in anything but enhance, and even then, we won’t be godlike either.

The reason I am still going to play shaman though, is because of the fantasy aspect. I think its so freaking cool to wield a massive 2h axe as an orc and absolutely global a gnome mage with a WF proc. I currently have my shaman at level 12 and leveling at enhance is looking pretty promising so far.

I think you could still play ele and have a blast (pun intended). Sure we don’t have a hard CC, but what other class truly has the ability to 2 shot people in less than half a second? The crits will crit and we will still get to have our fun. As the next few months roll out im sure more buffs will be added once they see how it is performing. For now, lets dig in and get the lightning rolling.

FTH!!!