Please read my post. I’ve specifically advocated keeping Onyxia as a 40-man, single-boss encounter. Nobody is asking to remove her attunement, either. Blizzard has already confirmed that Onyxia will remain a 40-player raid requiring the Drakefire Amulet. So I’m not sure why you’re arguing against something I never proposed.
The problem with your argument about variety is that having three different raid sizes doesn’t automatically mean players have meaningful choices. If specific content is exclusively available to 20 or 40 players, smaller guilds are still required to expand their rosters or recruit outside players to experience it.
As for realm populations, having enough players online does not automatically translate into maintaining reliable 40-player raid rosters. Those are two completely different things. Guilds have to account for attendance, scheduling conflicts, roster composition, and turnover every single week. High population doesn’t eliminate any of those responsibilities.
And this isn’t about launch week. It’s about what happens months later as additional raid tiers arrive and older content remains relevant.
My proposal preserves special 40-man encounters while giving standard raids 10- and 20-player versions with shared weekly lockouts. That provides actual flexibility without forcing guilds to organize around the largest required raid size.
Finally, telling people to play Retail completely avoids the discussion. Forever is its own version of WoW, and discussing its raid design doesn’t make this a Classic versus Retail argument.
The goal is sustainable raiding, not eliminating challenging content or social interaction. More players in an instance doesn’t automatically mean better gameplay, stronger communities, or a healthier endgame.