Please Reconsider the Raid Structure for WoW Forever

Hello Blizzard Team,

I am writing to express my concerns about the planned raid structure for WoW Forever. I believe requiring 40-player raids for endgame progression is the wrong direction for a game that needs to maintain a healthy and active player base over the long term.

The problem with 40-man raiding is not the number of players participating in an encounter. The problem is making that number a requirement for accessing progression content.

A group of 10 or 20 dedicated players should be able to experience the same raids without being forced to recruit additional members, merge with another guild, or depend on random players to fill the remaining positions. A guild should not have to double or quadruple its roster simply to participate in endgame content.

My recommendation is to provide 10- and 20-player versions of all standard raids, with identical weekly lockouts. Larger 40-player encounters should remain limited to special one- or two-boss raids, such as Onyxia.

This approach preserves large-scale raiding without making it an obligation for the entire community. The shared lockout is particularly important. Players should have the freedom to choose their preferred raid size without being pressured into completing multiple versions of the same content for additional rewards.

There is also a fundamental difference between encouraging cooperation and requiring excessive organization. World of Warcraft is a social game regardless of whether a raid contains 10, 20, or 40 players. Smaller groups still require communication, teamwork, coordination, and commitment. Nothing about reducing the required roster size removes those elements.

The social identity of Classic WoW is not defined by a 40-player raid requirement. Wrath of the Lich King demonstrated that smaller raid formats work within World of Warcraft. There is no reason Forever cannot build upon that successful design while retaining the identity and atmosphere that players appreciate about Classic.

The long-term consequences of this decision deserve serious attention. As additional raid tiers become available, maintaining large rosters and organizing multiple raid groups will place increasing pressure on guilds. Players will become exhausted with the demands, and guilds will lose members.

This directly affects the game’s ability to maintain an active subscription base. I want a version of World of Warcraft that remains enjoyable and accessible throughout its entire lifespan, not one where participation becomes increasingly difficult as more content releases.

I have no intention of supporting a raid structure that creates unnecessary barriers to content that should be accessible to smaller, dedicated groups. The developers have an opportunity to make Forever a lasting success by prioritizing player flexibility and sustainable progression.

Please make 10- and 20-player raids the standard, implement shared weekly lockouts, and reserve 40-player raids for special encounters.

Thank you for considering this feedback.

This is not a Classic vs. Retail debate. Please respect others and their opinions, even when you disagree. Any comments that violate the community guidelines will be reported directly. If you cannot engage in a civil and respectful discussion, simply move on.

Have a great weekend, everyone! Happy Halloween!

6 Likes

40 man raids in 2026 is madness

it’s a big waste of time and effort to organize and the fight gets so stupid, that even if half of the raid dies, you still finish it.

6 Likes

I tend to agree. I enjoy raiding, whether it’s 10 or 20 or 40-man content. However, I’m really not looking forward to the massive raiding grind the current system is likely to create. I genuinely believe every raid should have a 10 and 20-man version, with 40-man raids reserved for occasional one or two-boss encounters like you pointed out. I loved the flexibility Wrath introduced with different raid sizes. It made raiding much more accessible and less stressful, especially when it came to organizing guilds. Raiding should be something we look forward to, not another job.

2 Likes

Good thing you’re too late because massively disagree. 40 man raids are goated and truthfully I’d love to see 100 man raids too especially with technology being so much better now.

But I’m sure they still can and likely will introduce more skill based 10-25 man raids.

2 Likes

Why do you assume they will be tuned like classic and not vanilla? Why do you assume that raids that were never balanced to be against patch 1.12 because patch power was literally the catchup mechanics will transfer to new raids that are being designed for completely different classes? Especially when they said they would be tuning 40 mans for the power creep in forever…

Like this is such a wild take I don’t understand at all. Will the be mythic hard absolutely not but they won’t be LFR easier either most likely.

And 40 man raids are the pinnacle of social raiding. Having to actually work with a large group of people to a common purpose. A 10 man raid might as well be a dungeon group.

Everyone treated UBRS as a dungeon just because it didn’t have a lock out timer. That’s all a 10 man “Raid” is a dungeon with a lockout timer.

Not everything needs to be hold your hand accessible for the retail crowd that just wants gear and to never talk to another human being outside their tiny little discord micro group.

So if your 20 man guild has to team up with another 20 man guild to go kill a world changing level threat, is great for your character not being the OP champion of the story.

It literally makes you feel like an adventurer rather then the chosen one.

10 mans feel like your the chosen one if your killing entities that armies are scared to take on. No 10 people should have ever killed kelthuzad or the Arthas. That’s literally just being the chosen one with a support crew.

Having to assemble a near army of 40 plus adventurers is peak, you aren’t the chosen one while still being manageable. 100 man raids could be cool but managing loot across that many people would hurt too much. That’s why large pvp is cool you don’t need to manage loot and stuff across it but it feels epic.

Pve deserves to feel epic.

Tiny raids do not feel epic they feel like your basically the chosen on and are fated to never lose.

2 Likes

Blizzard’s developers have repeatedly described Forever’s raid philosophy as “beer and pretzels” raiding. Lead Encounter Designer Michael Nuthals specifically emphasized approachable encounters built around preparation, coordination, and manageable mechanical complexity.

I’d recommend watching the recent developer podcast on raiding, where they explain this philosophy directly.

You’re also overlooking the evolution of WoW raiding beyond 2019 Classic. Blizzard has used multiple raid sizes and encounter designs for nearly two decades. The history of WoW raiding doesn’t begin and end with the 2019 rerelease of Vanilla.

And before anyone says it, Forever is it’s own thing. Completely seperate from Retail or Vanilla. It is based on Warcraft III story, with loose Vanilla elements. Also, confirmed on the main website, and in recent developer podcasts. The players aren’t heros, or the main character, the characters they write about are, and the player just happens to be helping them. This is straight from Lead Encounter Designer Michael Nuthals.

1 Like

My counter argument is that the current variety of 10, 20 and 40 player raids gives a little something for everyone.

IMO fighting Onyxia without attunement in a 10 to 20 raider group isn’t going to hit the same. We will also have more than enough players on realms to easily fill many 40-man rosters every night.

For players that want to fight her without attunement, there needs to be more timewalking raids in Retail.

1 Like

Yes, that means things like Naxx not like jailor. That’s exactly what im talking about the difference is tuning isn’t = to mechanics.

A fight like Geddon has 1 mechanic. It doesn’t mean that mechanic has to be trivial. They literally talked about how adds going to the second half of MC, could 1 shot players if they stood in front of the fire elementals. That’s not a complicated mechanic but it is punishing if you don’t do it.

They aren’t going to tune a 40 man raid to be killable by 20 people from 80%. Or a fight like onyxia to be 4 mannable on tier. That’s not how raid get balanced. It never has been. Just because classic specifically didn’t tune raids. Didn’t mean SoD/SoM didn’t have better tuning when they did actually tune them. All new raids are going to be tuned.

They also said the old ones would be tuned as well.

Their lead raid designer and aggrend himself also said they want to keep the vanilla/classic style of raid design too.

Which means bosses with immunities when it calls for it. Fire/frost/poison immune enemies. Bleed immune ones. None of the stuff retail has.

Please read my post. I’ve specifically advocated keeping Onyxia as a 40-man, single-boss encounter. Nobody is asking to remove her attunement, either. Blizzard has already confirmed that Onyxia will remain a 40-player raid requiring the Drakefire Amulet. So I’m not sure why you’re arguing against something I never proposed.

The problem with your argument about variety is that having three different raid sizes doesn’t automatically mean players have meaningful choices. If specific content is exclusively available to 20 or 40 players, smaller guilds are still required to expand their rosters or recruit outside players to experience it.

As for realm populations, having enough players online does not automatically translate into maintaining reliable 40-player raid rosters. Those are two completely different things. Guilds have to account for attendance, scheduling conflicts, roster composition, and turnover every single week. High population doesn’t eliminate any of those responsibilities.

And this isn’t about launch week. It’s about what happens months later as additional raid tiers arrive and older content remains relevant.

My proposal preserves special 40-man encounters while giving standard raids 10- and 20-player versions with shared weekly lockouts. That provides actual flexibility without forcing guilds to organize around the largest required raid size.

Finally, telling people to play Retail completely avoids the discussion. Forever is its own version of WoW, and discussing its raid design doesn’t make this a Classic versus Retail argument.

The goal is sustainable raiding, not eliminating challenging content or social interaction. More players in an instance doesn’t automatically mean better gameplay, stronger communities, or a healthier endgame.

1 Like

I’m not going to debate you on this. It’s completely off topic to OPs suggestion. Watch the podcasts is all I can say.

10 mans and 20 mans suddenly don’t have to not worry about those as well. I know plenty of 10 and 20 man rosters that fall apart as a game goes on, because people just don’t want to commit the time anymore.

I’d even argue that losing a healer in a 10 man is more crippling then losing a single player in a 40 man. Because most 10 mans are very tight knit groups where half your raid might collapse if 3 people only play because they are playing together and one quits.

This is far less likely in a large guild to completely destroy a team and make people not want to raid at all.

Throwing up a survey for a 20 man raid for raid times is literally no different then doing it for a 40 man. Acting like this is some massive mountain to climb is disengenous. Never have I been in a raid team where they didnt just create a poll for raid availability. Whether that be 10/25/40/8 or 16.

You act like being a smaller guild is some how a hardship and that anything that inconveniences it is absolutely unacceptable. Being a large guild isn’t even easier. You just don’t want to put in social work for loot.

None of the raid sizes actually scale cleanly either. 40 mans a decent amount of the time take more tanks. So either you make a tank DPS to go to smaller raids or you make people switch classes. It’s never a perfectly clean division.

The new 10 and 20 man raid have over 20+ bosses combined. There is plenty of content if you don’t want to put in effort for 40 man.

I like long 40 man raids. They already said MC is coming back at 40 people. There is absolutely no way they don’t bring NAXX back as a 40 as well. It’s too important to the worlds story. The entire scourge story line is tied to it.

They never said 40’s would drop higher tier either. It might just be different stuff. You don’t need to be able to get everything the game with your select a group size.

Old version of the game were fine for health with 40 man raids. Hell in SoD some of the 20 mans took 40 people to make them trivial for no more loot. There is absolutely demand for 40 man raids. Just because you don’t prefer them or want to group with people doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be made at all.

You’re arguing against something I never claimed. Nobody said 10- or 20-man guilds are immune to attendance problems, roster turnover, or burnout. The argument is that requiring 40 players introduces a substantially larger organizational burden. Both things can be true.

Yes, losing a healer in a 10-man raid can have a greater immediate impact. That doesn’t eliminate the challenges of maintaining 40 reliable players, managing class compositions, coordinating schedules, replacing departures, and keeping everyone engaged. You’re confusing the consequences of losing an individual player with the overall responsibility of maintaining an entire roster.

And no, creating a scheduling poll for 20 people isn’t equivalent to coordinating 40. The process of collecting availability is identical. The number of people whose schedules must align is not. That’s a mathematical distinction, not a matter of opinion.

Your point about tank requirements actually supports my argument. Different raid sizes don’t divide neatly because their compositions and requirements differ. That’s another logistical complication guild leadership has to manage.

As for the 21 bosses across the new 10- and 20-man raids, nobody is disputing that content exists. The issue is that those are separate raids, not different versions of the same content. Having different raids locked to different group sizes is not the same as allowing players to choose how they experience the same raid. That’s the distinction you keep overlooking.

Blizzard has already committed to providing 10- and 20-player content every tier, with Lead Classic Designer Tim Jones explicitly describing 40-man raiding as an exception. That’s an important distinction when discussing the intended direction of Forever.

Your claim about Molten Core and Naxxramas also goes beyond what Blizzard has officially confirmed. Onyxia is confirmed as a 40-player raid. The final raid sizes for Molten Core and Naxxramas have not been established in the official announcements. Furthermore, a raid’s importance to Warcraft’s storyline has absolutely nothing to do with requiring 40 players to experience it. Naxxramas itself was available in 10- and 25-player formats during Wrath of the Lich King without losing its narrative importance.

You’re also correct that Blizzard hasn’t confirmed 40-man raids will offer higher-tier rewards. I never claimed otherwise. My concern is the organizational pressure created by exclusive content and additional progression opportunities, regardless of whether the rewards are statistically superior.

And your Season of Discovery example doesn’t establish that mandatory 40-man raiding is necessary or sustainable. Players choosing to bring larger groups to trivialize content is fundamentally different from requiring 40 players to participate in that content.

Finally, suggesting that people who prefer smaller raids simply don’t want to put in the “social work for loot” is an unnecessary personal assumption. I’ve organized 40-man raids before. My position comes from experience with those responsibilities, not an unwillingness to interact with other players.

I have never advocated removing 40-man raiding entirely. I’ve consistently supported keeping it for special one- or two-boss encounters while making 10- and 20-man versions with shared weekly lockouts the standard for other raids.

You enjoy long 40-man raids. That’s your preference, and you’re entitled to it. But your preference doesn’t invalidate the concerns of players and guild leaders who want a more manageable structure.

The goal is to make raid encounters challenging without making roster management the hardest boss in the game. Player choice and long-term sustainability are the entire point.

1 Like

10m pugable casual pseudo-dungeon content, 20m committed raid team content, and 40m ezmode faceroll content is a fine format imo.

I’m pretty fine with the 10, 20, 40 format as long as 40m raiding isnt flagship raiding, and 10m raids are more akin to UBRS than WoTLK+ 10m raids.

I do not want multiple difficulty modes or raid sizes for the same content.

3 Likes

Yes, but that doesn’t mean the same 10 people will also have times that align. This is not a dependent system where every 10 people will always align and every 40 people will never align.

This is an identical problem faced by all raid sizes. Just a matter of degree sometimes, but thats ok I won’t fit with every 10 man that raids at x time just like I wouldn’t fit with every 40 man that raids with at x time. You just have to find the people that work. Having a pre-established 10 man coming into the game doesn’t mean you should get special consideration. Some people have established 40 mans already, they don’t need special treatment either.

Except they AREN’T THE SAME RAIDS. They’ve been very clear on this. Each raid is unique and has one size. Lead Classic Designer Tim Jones also said “One raid. One Size” A raid is a raid. So using half their words to support you argument while ignoring the other words they used that made it clear that’s not what it means, isn’t helping you.

Getting to select the hp health and mechanics of a raid boss is not equivalent. Stop pretending like it is.

Onyxia doesn’t just get less health and damage because you walk into the dungeon with less people.

Garr doesn’t magically have less adds that need to be dealt with because you want 10 people in the raid instead of 40. They mechanically change to not be the same raid.

They said raids will be one size and unique the moment you get select a size raid, means its not an encounter anymore. Its a build a bear.

Yeah as long as 10/20 are the focus, I don’t mind 40-man raids existing. I’ll only be organizing 10/20 raids, but I hope to PUG a spot in someone else’s group for Ony.

1 Like

This honestly. I don’t want the game to become Build a boss for your difficulty and raid preference. It cheapens all encounters and makes them meaningless. If every enemy has 10 versions of itself it doesn’t have any permanence.

2 Likes

Thirded. There’s no 10-man version of BRD. No 20-man version of Ony. The group size of the content has meaning. No flex raids.

1 Like

That’s my hope for how things shake out as well.

2 Likes

Ya, ideally I want to play DPS for a 20m team, and tank for casual 10 and 40m gameplay on my own time. 20m is the sweet spot for organized or guild raiding to me.

2 Likes

The argument in favor of smaller raids usually comes from tight-knit groups of friends: “It’s too hard for us to gather 40 people; we’re comfortable playing as our own cozy 10-man micro-guild.” However, as soon as the developers give in to their demands (or, as seen in SoD, abruptly jump from a 10-man to a 20-man format), the entire ecosystem of the game shatters.

The Death of LFG Culture: In a 40-man raid, there was always a strong core of 15–20 top-tier players who could fill the remaining slots from LFG and carry them, even if someone had low DPS, played an unoptimized class, or was poorly geared. In a 10 or 20-man format, the cost of a single player’s mistake skyrockets. One low-DPS player means the boss hits enrage; one healer failing to move out of a void zone means a total wipe for the entire group.
Toxic Min-Maxing Instead of Casual Relaxation: In a smaller raid, there is no longer room for off-meta classes or casual players. LFG leaders are forced to strictly inspect logs and gear, carefully sculpting the class composition because they simply cannot afford to carry any “dead weight.”
A Divided Community: These established groups of friends live in their own exclusive club, shutting out outsiders. Meanwhile, solo players—who are completely willing to accept the rules of PUG raids, agree to performance-based loot penalties, or face getting kicked—are left out in the cold. Assembling a perfect raid “off the street” in a smaller format has become too difficult and stressful. Consequently, LFG groups will only invite players with stellar gear/logs or highly preferred meta classes.