To those who want evidence, but can’t be bothered to Google:
Mythic VA (last two weeks):
Go to: warcraftlogs /zone/statistics/latest
Heroic VA (last two weeks):
Go to: warcraftlogs /zone/statistics/latest?difficulty=4
Heroic VA – last ONE week:
Go to: warcraftlogs /zone/statistics/latest?difficulty=4&sample=7
Mythic+:
Go to: mythicstats /dps
Other evidence:
Go to: wowhead /guide/classes/tier-lists/dps-rankings-mythic-plus#s-tier-specs
Having grouped with them in Heroic raids, Mythic+, looking at rankings, it’s quite obvious. The successive buffs have clearly gone too far.
Subtlety is overperforming by like 20-30%, depending on the fight. This is gear for gear, compared to other top performing players. Even lesser geared players now do more than other classes with better gear…what?
Ula’tek fight is trivialized by having sub rogues. M+ runs are trivialized. Being geared doesn’t compare. I would go so far as to say gearing for the rest of us feels unrewarding when grouping with them.
Please fix this, I am seeing far faster clears and kills in raids with 2 or more good Sub Rogues. The difference is stark.
Raids, Cleave, “Mythic±style-of-raiding”
Across the board, M+ style of play or extreme cleave raid fights takes away from a lot of the enjoyment of raiding, turning it into a button-mashing-extreme that makes WoW feel more like a quasi-action RPG.
Mythic+ has its place. It’s called Mythic Plus. And while, yes, trash clears, and certain adds can make cleave useful, cleave itself isn’t an interesting mechanic. Nor should cleave-centric specs be favored for so many boss fights.
Various fights have strongly emphasized critical adds with high health, or multiple adds with high health AND an interrupt requirement…Hard switches to break a shield or stop an enemy that cannot otherwise be cleaved down…Or positioning and add fighting, not just smashing them away.
I think you underestimate your audience, that they want the weak thrills of action RPG “power fantasy”. It’s nice under some circumstances, but enough fights benefit from egregious cleave that thoughtful gameplay seems to be deemphasized. After enough cleave, I feel like I’m playing low keys Mythic+. And low keys cannot feel rewarding because they are a cheap and cheerful cleavefest.
I feel that Mythic raids have tended to stay truer to “consider before acting” and “be mentally fluid, ready to adapt”. The good fights have been refreshing, even if they were difficult. Completion required performance in totality…that’s what feels rewarding.