1. Festering Strike combo skill is just awful | Ghoul stack is redundant
Festering Strike has always been one of the blandest skill in the game; reworking it into a 2 GCDs combo skill made it feel exponentially worse. Wasting ~20% of your rotation on this unimpactful combo skill – with both GCDs adding up to be ~0.8% of your overall damage – is the exact reason why players feel Unholy button presses are worthless.
The biggest design flaw is the constant need to waste 2 unimpactful GCDs on this clunky combo skill to upkeep two separate desynced buffs, while always overcapping one of the two. Then, to make it even worse, Soul Reaper now consumes majority of the Ghoul stacks, so the player is forced to push this 2 GCD abomination every few seconds. This is WORSE than having to FStrike when target-switching in 11.0.
Design-wise, the combo itself is nonsensical in that it goes from melee range (FStrike) to mid range (FScythe). Compared to DH’s Voidblade>Hungering Slash combo that leaps into melee-range into an area sweep – the DH combo just feels cool and impactful; meanwhile, the DK waddling to melee range to push FSrike>FScythe every few seconds for ~0.8% of total damage is just the most awful 2 GCDs to press in the game.
Fix: Festering Scythe needs to completely replace Festering Strike. Delete Festering Strike. Please. Festering Scythe is just a much more interesting skill. Festering Scythe applies Plagues and Plaguebringer. Scourge Strike summon Ghouls when Plaguebringer buff is up, instead of another redundant Ghoul stack buff (reduce Plaguebringer duration on ghoul summon, if needed, with Putrefy and Sudden Doom extending Plaguebringer duration). Same gameplay, less clunk.
Completely replacing Festering Strike with Festering Scythe immediately makes Unholy feel 10x better to play. That’s just how bland and horribly clunky the FS combo is.
2. Dread Plague encourages degenerate target selection
Dread Plague exploding for 184.5% damage and jumps to the lowest health enemy when its host dies means the player always want to target the lowest-health enemy. This devolves the gameplay into DPSing non-priority lowest-health enemy, kill it, scramble to click the nameplate that Dread Plague jumped to, kill this next lowest-health enemy asap, then frantically repeat, to maximize damage. This is completely counter-intuitive as Dread Plague is meant for priority target.
Fix: The death explosion should be moved to Virulent Plague. It would preserve the chain-reaction gameplay without forcing constant low-health target sniping.
3. Cycle of Death needs a cleaner solution | Outbreak is bland
All these new additions such as Cycle of Death, FS combo, Putrefy Charges, Soul Reaper, and Blightfall has created a messier and a more complex launch sequence than 11.0 Unholy. When DnD was brought back with Cycle of Death, players just got sick and tired of trying to get get it through to Blizzard that ground-target skills like DnD has no place in Unholy’s kit over and over again. That is when players start resenting the spec.
Fix: Simply merge the boring Outbreak and Death and Decay into one iconic ability that creates an AoE miasma that applies Plagues (centered on the targeted enemy), with the miasma being treated as DnD (Put some initial damage and a 15s CD on this new ability, and have Festering Scythe as a secondary way to apply Plagues instead of Putrefy). This would reduce unnecessary setup, reduce button bloat (again), remove ground-targeting friction, clean up all messy Putrefy interactions, and make the spec flow much better in moving encounters.
Then Blightfall can move back as a follow-up to Outbreak+D&D, instead of the nonsensical follow-up to Dark Transformation.
The ground-target D&D can be a choice node for PvP or for utility.
Bonus - Dread Plague proccing Putrefy does not provide player agency. The random proc causes an unwanted Putrefy that triggers Necrotic Wounds at the wrong time. Either fix how Necrotic Wounds stack, move Putrefy to trigger on Sudden Doom, or Dread Plague procs a free empowered Festering Scythe.