Please update shaman specs in 12.1.7

Issues/requests for each spec below, most are taken from the shaman discord, the forums here, speaking with other shamans in game and hearing from shaman content creators like Zorthas.

Enhancement Shaman issues and requests:

  1. REMOVE RNG DOOM WINDS AND BRING BACK DOOM WINDS AS ITS OWN BUTTON.
  • Doom Winds RNG is horrible for the spec, most enhance shamans do not like it at all. It is way too feast or famine, its too strong of a proc which means bad procs feel terrible and the good procs do not make up for it (bad procs feel worse than great procs feel good). It can take a long time to get procs due to the deck being 600 msw, but lowering the amount won’t really feel any better.
  • It forces bad gameplay. Having to stop spending Maelstrom Weapon because a pack is dying or a boss is entering intermission to avoid getting a bad Doom Winds proc feels terrible and very anti-enhance. It also makes it so we don’t want to spend msw from ranged which really sucks because being able to do a bit of damage while moving out and back in is a cool aspect of enhance.
  • We have plenty of button space to get Doom Winds back as its own button. We lost Ice Strike, Frost Shock and Ele Blast as rotational buttons, we lost Feral Spirits as a CD and we lost Stone Bulwark Totem, Totemic Recall and Thunderstorm as utility/defensive buttons. We have room for Doom Winds to be a separate button. This really needs to happen, Enhancement Shaman gameplay as Stormbringer is nearly perfect outside of RNG Doom Winds.
  1. Totemic could use a rework.
  • Its damage profile is way too similar to Stormbringer as they are both high burst damage specs. It would be so much better to have Totemic do what it did in TWW as a high consistent damage spec with much lower burst peaks but its damage never falls off.
  • Having Doom Winds as a 1 min, Sundering and Prim Storm as 30s CDs and Hot Hands procs being short duration all makes for a consistent damage profile as long as Surging Totem is a 30s duration 30s CD.
  • In order to avoid button bloat especially if Doom Winds returns as a separate button it would be a good idea to dissuade picking up Ascendance as Totemic since Ascendance is more burst focused. This would just require changing Oversurge to something different entirely or maybe make it based on Doom Winds.

Restoration Shaman issues/requests:

  1. Mastery needs a rework.
  • Resto Shaman mastery is heavily outdated at this point. It is unreliable, prone to being sniped by other healers and is just inconsistent value wise. Pres Evoker got a modernized version of our mastery which was really upsetting to many Rshams, it would be nice to see our mastery updated.
  1. Mana economy is terrible. Rsham in mythic progression -requires- an innervate to not run out of mana on longer fights like Coiled Altar and Ula’tek.
  • This is largely due to only having Chain Heal and Healing Rain as cleave/group healing spells which are our two most expensive spells.
  1. Overpruned. Need an ability back that allows us to conserve some mana while group/cleave healing.
  • Getting Wellspring back that does something like “Heals all targets hit for x amount, applies riptide to all targets hit and makes your next Healing Wave instant and heals all targets with Riptide” would be really nice. Another way of doing this would be modernizing/updating Downpour which has been dead this entire expansion so far.

I can’t say much for Ele because its the spec I play the least in mythic raiding content, but what I can say is Ele has horrid 2 target and spread cleave damage. Those are Eles weaknesses which is fine, but Ele might be a bit too bad at those and maybe improving at least one of them just a bit would be nice.

9 Likes

I think there are a lot of good ideas here but I don’t want to have to wait until 12.1.7. Something should be done now, but they are too busy with all the resources seemingly committed to their Wow Forever money grab.

6 Likes

They stopped doing mid season reworks as it made the fotm rerollers squeal.

Unfortunate since all they have now in these patches are recycled invasions/events and 30 minutes of quests.

2 Likes

Haven’t really touched this expansion since they gutted my main spec (Fire) - dabbled in Enhance and oh god is it so near perfect…but Doom Winds is SO annoying. There absolutely has to be agency around such a major CD. It’d be like if Combust went back to a 2m CD, but would randomly proc based on hot streaks spent - absolutely terrible. Even SKB let you at least hold it for ~30s (15s was pretty bad) so you weren’t necessarily screwed if it popped towards the end of a pack.

I’m all for minor pruning so specs don’t wind up back with 25-step openers and a million rotational buttons and procs to juggle, but anything that makes a dps spec actively NOT want to do damage in certain scenarios is god awful design. DW as its own button is completely manageable - there has to be a better way of incentivizing Totemic/non-Ascendance builds that isn’t this monstrosity.

While we’re at it though, can we please just give up on Reincarn and replace it with burrow? Reincarn can’t really be called a defensive, and it’s more often than not a die-twice vs. a real cheat death.

1 Like

Yeah its what bothers a lot of us the most as shaman/enhance mains. They actually got the spec to a near perfect place rotationally/gameplay wise but then RNG Doom Winds just ruins it pretty hard. They could do absolutely nothing and only remove rng doom winds+add it back as a button and i’d be happy. Though I would like to see a Totemic rework so it is different from Stormbringer since as of right now they both kinda do the same thing, but again would be happy enough with rng doom winds gone.

The worst part is, they’ve done this before in the past. I’m sure its new devs or whatever but having a major CD be RNG in any way is almost always bad, even more so if its tied to spending your resource. It feels terrible and I really hope they change at least this.

Yeah I noticed this. I thought it was because of other things though, like this expac was the whole addon prune which was a lot of resources for them so they definitely pulled people from other teams, Forever on top of that has some retail devs working on it, but usually the .5 patches we don’t see that much which was true even in TWW. The .7 patches are the ones that have medium sized reworks (according to tww and midnight 12.0.7). The thing is, enhance doesn’t need a rework at all it just needs RNG Doom Winds removed and added back as a button, thats quite literally it. Totemic rework can come at a later time, I’m happy enough with just Stormbringer for now since the gameplay is solid and I think many enhance mains agree with that. Resto might be a 12.2 thing but idk they could do it in the .7 patch too as it doesn’t really need a foundational rework.

1 Like

Yeah i gotta be honest the next update is going to make or break this game for me. I’m tired of this. I agree with everything your saying, I just…they have to be aware, and their silence and willingness to just leave entire groups of players frustrated for no reason is getting to me.

8 Likes

Totemic buffs inc!!! Give lava lash another 35% buff and we’re cooking lmao.

But yah agreed it would be nice to not be so dam bursty. Idk how they do it at this stage though. I think for totemic, it would make hot hadns proc a little more frequent, and some damage taken out of totem into hot hands. I don’t htink they will go back to 30 second

1 Like

It would be nice to receive some pvp buffs on spells/talents we actually use. Just finished pushing glad yesterday and we only ran into one other resto shaman. (2500-2700 mmr)

Pres/MW/Rdruid are dominating.

Please give us another defensive, bring back thunderstorm/prep totem, and give lasso baseline.

2 Likes

I also want to add that I think Enhance and Resto each need something unique given to their spec (baseline) utility/cc wise. Ele having Thunderstorm gives it unique utility over the other two, it would be nice if Enh/Resto got something unique utility or cc wise as well. That or add Thunderstorm back to Resto/Enh.

Enhance does have instant Healing Surge that is unique but it keeps getting nerfed so it isn’t that great anymore especially on targets without Earth Shield.

Also, it’s getting a bit ridiculous to have Enhance be so bad in Raid at the beginning of every season and even after 9 weeks it’s still a mid spec in raid. it’s single target is meh, it’s aoe is great, it’s 2t cleave is decent, it’s spread cleave is non existent.

Yeah moving Lasso to honor talents was awful. Made the class with the worst cc in the game even worse since enh/ele can’t take lasso at all. Enh/resto losing thunderstorm but not getting anything useable in cc/stuns to protect themselves was also very bad.

2 Likes

it would be nice to have a spec specific utility but tbh our utility is already super high and imo rewarding. We’ve got purge, mass sprint that’s also a mass snare dispel (helpful in Altar), poison cleanse, fear cleanse, curse cleanse, aoe stun, ranged low-cd kick. i can understand wanting a bit more defensives, and for pvp an extra stun or disable, but utility wise we are pretty strong.

1 Like

I mained a shaman back from 2006 to 2009, elemental shaman in fact and it was extremely versatile back then and had teeth but after quiting and taking a 17 year haitus and coming back 2 months ago and since then nearly leveled every class/spec to 90 I can say beyond any shadow of doubt that what Blizzard has done to Elemental shamans is nothing short of a disgrace.

It’s fully reliant on procs, which have a low… far too low proc chance, its mobility is bad and changes to farseer helped but the proc rate is again, far too low. In solo content especially delves it suffers because of the lack of mobility, totem rework has weakened the classes utility further and its burst window is just bad making it a laborous chore to play them, back in 2009 they were a true reinforced glass cannon and now, just a glass pea-shooter.

Tempest builds once again, slot machine RNG for it proccing’ same with ancestors popping so as the saying goes, its very much a feast and famine class but the famine happens far more often, when the RNG gods shine and your rotation is steady, it can dish out respectful DPS but right now, its so inconsistent in every sense of the word.

Honestly, Elemental Shamans would highly benefit from being able to cast whilst moving all the time like DH Devourer. I think this would be just one of the changes which would help.

Another is the proc rates all across the board need buffing, lightning needs to be buffed too, it went from your mainstay spell to just filler, maelstrom generation is also iffy and would benefit from a buff to allow more elemental blast casts, or reduce the maelstrom cost of EB.

You compare Elemental Shaman vs Enhancement and its a joke right now, the specs are not even in the same league- sure, OP makes great points that the class is far from perfect and absolutely valid criticisms for Blizzards poor handling of the class.

for resto, in a .7 patch. out of the issues listed. the only realistic thing to hope for is something effecting mana management

1 Like

+1 on Rsham mana economy.
Resto shaman mana feels awful. Often I am sitting there waiting for my riptide / healing stream totems to come off cooldown instead of casting anything because I simply don’t have the mana to spare elsewhere.

I am blessed to have a boomkin friend that throws me innervate for our mythic prog. I could not imagine playing the spec without it. Plus, we’re officially the lowest healing spec on raid logs now post hotfix that actually nerfed us.

Bring back lightning bolt = mana return!

1 Like

What do you mean exactly? Ele has thunderstorm, the other 2 specs do not. The other 2 specs should have thunderstorm or something unique between them that ele doesn’t. But realistically they should just have thunderstorm. Either way my biggest issue with enhance is rng doom winds, if that’s all they changed for now id be more than happy so not worried about the rest.

Yeah same. I’m mostly hoping they add another spell or at least update downpour so we can actually use it to group heal while conserving mana (aka use it instead of pressing a couple chain heals every time it’s available)

2 Likes

Its always been interesting that they add rolls like the mid range caster in evokers, and demonhunters, but they never seem to really change an existing roll.

it took them a fair few expansions to add the “Charge” feature to another class besides Evoker,

I feel like alongside some of the utility and unique spells that make our class identity some of the newers mechanics could be added , or just generally some thought put into the class.

If there was ever a class that should have the same role as augmentation, i would think Enhancement would be it

can we ask the guy who designed ret paladins to do all target damage, be it 1,2,3,5,20 that they can do insane amounts of dmg figure something out for enhance? it must be something dumb like proc similar to hit divine storm that does a passive hit also.

1 Like

Nah I would never want enhance to do that. I honestly love enhance the way it is outside of RNG doom winds. Right now with the tier set, we have a non stop rotation and we actually do damage (could be better but not garbage like prior to the recent buffs) so it feels worthwhile. Having Voltaic blaze as an actual rotation button that does a lot of damage feels amazing, having more presses of crash feels great especially since Unleashed looks awesome. I do worry a bit for when we lose this seasons tier set unless they maybe bake in the Voltaic Blaze/Fire Nova stuff to our spec tree.

I think Totemic needs some work, but Stormbringer with this current tier set is probably my favorite version of enhance in a while. The only thing that sucks about it at all is the fact Doom Winds rng controls how I play which is very annoying. If I play normally I just end up with poorly timed procs too often.

I’m not even sure I’d want another Aug like spec in the game. They still struggle to get Aug right I think. But I do understand your point, I just think they already have too much to deal with regarding classes/specs at least for a while. I do want to see new things coming for classes but mostly cosmetic stuff at least for now outside of reworks/updates to existing specs (not reworks that turn a spec into something entirely different).

I think if our class were to get anything new design wise it’ll be a tank shaman spec at some point. Haven’t had a tank spec added in over 10 years, Shaman tank is popularly requested and has been since Vanilla (and classic releases have only strengthened that), the theme is also very easy to deal with.

1 Like

Fair,

I find my self tanking often because of doomwinds and threat.

Yeah that happens to me too. I usually give my tanks a couple seconds to get aggro once everything is gathered, but with RNG doom winds existing sometimes I get a proc right as a mob dies and we’re moving to the next pack and I dont want to lose uptime on it so I blast instantly. Can be prevented by not using spenders as mobs are dying but I really hate that so much

Blizzard to enhance shamans

“Our solution for you to enjoy your game in situ and in the broader aspect is for you not to play until will decide to fix your spec at some un-named future date, but dont push buttons, in fact just don’t play enhance.”