yes you are right Stryker while maybe the first version was good, after so many patches - they ruined the original idea.
give a cheap upgrade to work on large units. throw a grenade, bounce a walker
I think the reapers use them in campaign and some coop commanders.
Actually I do not remember them also in campaign or Co-Op.
As I told Reapers were meant just for a Demo of new Terrain (high + low ground) stuff.
Or I think one mission where you mine than Lava came, so all the army should reach high ground . But even there you can do it with Marines.
You asked me to leave you alone yes? So why reply to me? You say you have me on ignore, please just use it and donât talk to me Cat. ![]()
Just give them a late upgrade to AOE Stun Grenade Launcher.
Hard cc can easily become problematic. I donât think allowing players to spam Reaper grenades to lock units down is a good way to make them viable.
Protoss already have stronger lock downs. Cast by units stronger than a marine for the cost.
Youâre not wrong, youâre just Protoss, who can physically block chokes with spells and float units.
If you are referring to Stasis, it also renders units invulnerable for its duration; and it works like a trap where units have to march into it. This is not a spell that you can easily spam on armies to lock them down and kill them without retaliation.
I main Terran. Anyone who has actually paid attention to my posting history would know that. The people who assume that anyone who disagrees with them must belong to âfaction xâ are infantile.
Making them invulernable is arguably irrelevant. You other have units that will die they donât retreat, assuming the enemy gives chase. Admittedly avoidable.
But no, I was referring to the spell blocking passageways and to making units float.
No, it is very relevant. If Stasis didnât make units invulnerable, then everything affected by it would be an easy kill. That invulnerability is one of the most important balancing factors for stasis.
Forcefield is not hard-cc. Units arenât stunned, they are just displaced or blocked from moving in aspecific area. There are also several ways to destroy it or bypass it.
Graviton Beam is hard-cc, but it has targeting restrictions and it effectively disables the caster. It isnât common for a player to be able to spam this spell to a problematic effect, like you would be able to do with AOE stun grenades.
Terran units are already an easy kill.
That depends on the unit in question. Bio units are easy to kill, because they are generally balanced around high DPS, mobility, medivac healing, and moderate range. They are balanced out by being squishy and vulnerable to splash.
Factory and Starport units vary a lot more:
- Hellbats are relatively tough units (for 2 supply). They are still a bit vulnerable to splash, but usually not as much as Bio.
- Hellions, Cyclones, and Widow Mines are squishy.
- Vikings are relatively squishy compared to most other air units, although they are moderate compared to ground targets. This is balanced out by the Vikingâs other stats, particularly range.
- Thors and Battlecruisers are relatively durable, with Battlecruisers being one of the toughest units in the game as an individual unit.
- Siege Tanks and Liberators arguably fall somewhere near the middle of the pack in terms of durability.
Technically? Yeah, but they arenât really supposed to be a âfront lineâ except as a deterrent and for poking. In actual direct engagements you still want âtechnically squishierâ or similarly-squishy units in front of them - Bio, Widow Mines, Hellions, Hellbats.
But really the claim âTerran units are an easy killâ is rather deceptive just going based on how much HP they have. The correct statement is badly-controlled Terran units are an easy kill when the opponent makes the proper counters. Bio units are not an easy kill if the user takes advantage of Bioâs mobility to engage on the userâs terms and dodge and split. Bioâs DPS density and Medivac healing and upgrade scaling also often mean that the opponent must use splash damage to fight Bio, otherwise stim-and-a-move will still often beat the opponent.
Technically speaking, Siege Tanks, Vikings, and Liberators are artillery, and you want walls, terrain, or meat-shield units in front of them whenever possible, and that is pretty much how mech uses them.
Bio often retreats behind Siege Tanks and Liberators in late-game fights, leaving the artillery to die in order to save themselves. It is one of the many reasons why Bio-Tank starts to fall off in both non-mirror match-ups. âŚThatâs the result of playing Bio correctly, it is not a mistake.
I mean, it is in the context of your combined arms composition. Itâs a lot easier for the terran player to replace a bunch of marines than a bunch of siege tanks. Itâs one thing when you canât save the tanks no matter what, but you should never be making a conscious decision to sacrifice them to protect the cheaper and easier to produce units.
It may be easier to replace individual Marines than Tanks, but without the micro they die in huge numbers to many sources of splash and other threats. When you actually micro your Marines (and they do usually require micro to be effective), you quickly run out of space for them to continue fighting in front of or near the Tanks. This is why the Tanks become isolated.
Tanks also deal a certain amount of unavoidable splash damage when units like Chargelots, Ultralisks, Brood Lords, etc hit the field. Basically, anything that can reliably close into the Bio will force friendly-fire, and Bio has more trouble with that splash damage than most enemy compositions do.
Bio also often depends heavily on its mobility to avoid combat until the enemy is weakened (splash damage units and other threats disabled or cut in number), and Siege Tanks simply donât have the ability to keep up and be effective in combat.
Factors like this put Bio-Tank on a timer in both non-mirror match-ups. Meanwhile in TvT, Terran simply lacks units that can cause and exploit these weaknesses, so it doesnât happen as often there. Bio doesnât fit into the artillery + meat-shield paradigm that most of mech uses; whereas most mech units canât keep up with Bioâs mobility.
Sure, but thatâs what the tanks are for. You donât just let a bunch of colossi or high templars blast your marines while the tanks shoot the enemy zealots (and also your marines). The whole point behind adding tanks is to proactively shut down that threat rather than just run away from it. Adding tanks changes the entire paradigm of your army.
Now, granted, thats not the same thing as saying its the best use of your resources, but trying to play bio-tank like bio is just a failure to correctly use your units, so of course it wont work when you do that.
You are getting the dynamics wrong here.
Siege Tanks donât remove Bioâs micro requirements. They may reduce those micro requirements specifically against Banelings (which is one of the reasons why they are used early on in TvZ), but you must still kite and split your Bio to avoid getting your army slaughtered by some combination of splash and/or melee units. That micro requirement is what leads to Tanks getting isolated in most situations. This is not a failure of player control, but the best way to limit losses. Losing your Bio to splash damage from both sides, and then losing your Tanks because they canât escape, would be a lot worse than just losing the Tanks.
Siege Tanks are not able to consistently prevent High Templar, Colossus, or other splash units from getting their splash off, regardless of how well you focus fire. They donât have the damage for it (it would be insane if they did), they always use their first shot on the first target to enter their range, and they have fairly large gaps between individual attacks for units to close in and attack after each volley. They arenât going to consistently kill all of the enemyâs Banelings either, so it comes down to the Bio control in the end.
The friendly-fire has to be stressed here. Bio is one of the most vulnerable compositions to splash damage. It is often even more vulnerable to splash damage than Zergling/Baneling, due to the relative density of the units and the breakpoints for splash damage on each side of the match-up. You also cannot focus-fire every single shot of your Tanks because of the way that they kill things, so friendly-fire becomes unavoidable whenever the opponent has units that can reliably close distance. This is one reason why Bio-Tank is on a timer in both non-mirrors. The opponent gets splash damage and units that can reliably close the distance, and suddenly the friendly-fire and relative squishiness of the Bio (when you try to keep it near the Tanks) both become issues that make the mixture perform worse than mech without Bio or Bio without Tanks (which switches to more mobile units and avoids major engagements until the main threats are weakened or killed with Mines, Vikings, Ghosts, opportunistic harassment, etc).
Weâve seen professional players, the best of the best, consistently lose their Tanks in Bio+Tank compositions since WOL was released. The dynamics of that particular mix, with the possible exception of the Tankivac era, have been the same since the game was released, despite every patch. This is a composition that is well and truly figured out.
Escaping with Bio while losing Siege Tanks is consistent theme of Bio-Tank compositions. In both of the cases where it is unlikely to happen (early contains and early base defense), the opponent simply doesnât have the units and ability to exploit the friction that exists between those units.
I strongly disagree. Youâre wanting to treat siege tanks as fat immobile marauders. Thatâs going to fail every time. The siege tank is the heart of the bio-mech composition, and every decision you make needs to be anchored around it.
Again, this is not me saying the composition is good. This is me saying that you are thinking about it completely wrong.
Case in point, your goal is not to protect the bio units, it is to protect the siege tanks. The tanks are the damage of this composition, the bio is the sacrifice. Itâs ok if your bio dies, you just need to make sure it dies slowly enough that the tanks dont also die. Everything you do with your bio should be done with the idea that it is expendable. Maybe this isnât always possible. Sure. It would be an expensive comp, maybe prohibitively expensive. But youâre trying and failing to adapt bio principles to a unit that just cannot even come close to working that way.