What about #nerfreinhardt

Play is sloppier on the ladder. You have people not in voice and overextending without the reassurance of a near-given mobile barrier.

Where everyone has a plan, knows how to execute it, and knows what needs to be where for it to happen, that limitation becomes a lot less of an issue.

Iā€™ve never been able to come up with a clear position on this one. I simply canā€™t answer this questionā€¦

ā€œIs Rein that good because heā€™s that good, or is he that good just because of what he is?ā€

I mean, you probably can in Gold/Plat, but thatā€™s because very little matters in solo queue.

But Orisa will never be a substitute to Rein where play optimization is a thing.

1 Like

And buffing Rein against her wonā€™t change that, because shield Bash isnā€™t what made her good against dive, specifically Winston, itā€™s what it does against the rest of a dive comp which goes unchanged.

this is some funny irony brig the anti dive tank support in a dive comp.

Yes please. Just delete them. OW devs missed the point of the heavy and added some WoW PVP abomination to an FPS.

To be honest, I donā€™t think that last Mercy nerf was needed either. There are other stats besides pick rate. Reinhardt just isnā€™t that statistically crazy outside of his pick rate. Heā€™s fine.

And I say that as someone who mainly plays D.Va, Hammond, Orisa, and Zarya. I do play Rein too, but I never feel like I have to. I play Orisa all the time. Tanks right now are a class that is pretty balanced.

As a hardstuck plat/gold (LUL xd) people prefer Reinhardt because he is leagues better than Orisa. Her skill floor is higher than Reinā€™s and juggling CDā€™s and shield dancing is something you dont see that much in low tier.

Instead, in a very simplified way too-- you just have to put up your shield as Rein and youā€™re already effective. You only get Orisas on hybrid 1st point defense or at best, when thereā€™s bastion/torb/symmetra on the team.

You could try to make Orisa work anywhere, but thats gonna be next level chaos even for plats :grin: I dont really think she is a Reinhardt substitute tbhā€¦ but sometimes reinhardt feels like an Orisa substitute, specially when you have turret heroes.

Think of it in reverse, the less Brigitte can compete, the closer she is to being taken into a niche side meta pick to deter dive heroes (the key aspect she was made for) then that is closer to releasing the other tanks from their sad desolate prisons brig locked them in >.<

and this addresses the issue of a lack of counterplay in a Reinhardt avoiding being stunned by a Brig with no option other than to take it, which Iā€™m all for as it helps solve a problem which leads to chain cc, and that is FRUSTRATING BEYOND BELIEF, canā€™t block the first, so you get hit by all the ones you COULD block previously to brigs unavoidable stun.

Iā€™d say itā€™s two steps in the right direction for making the games roster more diverse, releasing a hero that just blocks a portion of the roster out and creates another extreme must-use meta obviously just created a new problem, so it needs to be balanced through solving the individual issues each hero kit has to achieve actual hero pool diversity and increasing the amount of available strategies which as Iā€™m sure near enough everyone would agree is where we want overwatch to be.

1 Like

Itā€™s funny you should mention this. MagyTheMage did a survey on balance about 9 days ago. 77% of people felt Reinhardt was balanced. And 15% of people felt he was underpowered. So, survey says heā€™s balanced.

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdrsUyqxw_M3ruvnww2Ch_wvaz1LGWqccsQq018_ZJKpW4Blg/viewanalytics

5 Likes

Thanks for linking that, and Magy for doing it. Pretty interesting results.

1 Like

No, he had not. Winston only had higher pickrate in GM, about same in Masters and lower in Diamond. Winston also had lower winrate in every single bracket.

Source: Omnicmeta

http://www.omnicmeta.com/2018/03/overwatch-hero-meta-report-pc-mar-22-18.html

It is a very popular myth than Rein was not used during dive meta. The only short time frame when he was not #1 most played main tank across the ladder was mid-late of Season 5. From S6 and till now he surpassed Winston in almost every single bracket, since S10 literally everywhere.

2 Likes

She still locks out the dive heroes though through existing. Youā€™re going to a point where sheā€™s effectively deleted to Z tier where no one is going to pick her anyway.

That might help things at higher ranks; but this is a hero whoā€™s fifth picked Support overall - sheā€™s not picked at lower ranks and not having the same impact players are pretending is happening - this is why we call her ā€œForum Brigitteā€.

Making life easier for Reinhardt when he is picked doesnā€™t help dive heroes in this instance; it just reinforces ā€œSomeone is trying dive, letā€™s go Brigā€, so we end up with reinforcement of Rein deathballs because thereā€™s still no point even trying dive.

Reinhardt needs a spinning tornado attack

That is by design, though. Sheā€™s a stop gap needed to let deathball compete at the highest level.

Brigitte is a bit of a mess balance wise even though she is not what the thread is about. She does not have the heal throughput to even be an offhealer, so sheā€™s not that great in 2/2/2 and running Brig as an off healer means you pretty much need your main healer to pocket Rein all game or he will just get bursted down. Sheā€™s very good in triple support, though, as her brawling potential (whether intended or not) allows her to replace a DPS without much loss in team TTK and your team still has two actual healers to keep the blob alive. Plus, you know, everything else she brings. Itā€™s why I call her Swedish Zarya.

But the same goes for Brigitte, just like a potential Brigitte swap polices dive, A potential Rein swap Polices brigitte, that is the art of the hero swap mechanic, and I donā€™t think they are looking to get rid of it any time soonā€¦ but if it is seen as a problem over time, itā€™d be brig that gets nerfed to the point of being very niche and a liability like quite a few heroes are, but Iā€™m hoping more along the lines that her power level overall gets checked down to the point shes usable, but not dictating a meta.

Or, you can go back a bit further and see Winston being picked more than Reinhardt. Itā€™s all about WHEN you look because Reinhardt has not always been on top. Here an Omnic Meta source that shoes what I am talking about.

http://www.omnicmeta.com/2017/07/overwatch-hero-meta-report-pc-s5-w7.html

I can drive a Reinhardt crazy as Doomfist.

Actually, is this a troll post?

2 Likes

Not fun =/=weak

Iā€™m not saying heā€™s OP ,but he is absolutely not weak and balance wise doesnā€™t need buffs.

1 Like