No. Ana is far too good. Bio grenade is probably the best ability in the entire game and she gives up very little in other categories for having it. If it hits an enemy, it is death for them. If it hits allies, it synergizes with the other support’s healing. She also has the highest ult shutdown potential of all supports with grenade countering most healer ults and sleep dart countering a lot of others.
Brig has good healing numbers but is basically an E bot. She’s a melee character that can rarely melee. Shield bash is good for canceling ultimates and that’s about it.
Lucio is pretty strong on the right maps, but he’s not a primary healer. He compliments Ana/Moira/Bap well. Zen works well if you can land his shots.
Basically we’re in this weird place right now where you MUST have an Ana/Bap/Moira and then you can pick from one of the other healers. It’s kind of stupid. If I queue as support and the other person is a Lucio/Mercy/Zen/Brig, pretty much gotta go Ana/Bap/Moira. The support (and tank roles, to an extent) do not have as much freedom as the DPS role to play your favorites.