I watched your vid. I review these differently than other people, it’s not fair to tell you what you should have done based on what a GM player would have done, I’m going to tell you what I would expect a Gold1/Plat4 player to do.
The first point you hadn’t even picked your hero when the round started and your Rein probably thought the game was going to be cancelled so he charged into the enemy and dies. He was dead before you even got to the point. If you had been there I actually think he would have survived with you and mercy healing him. He didn’t which snowballed into them taking the point. I’m going to at least partially blame you for this, partially on Rein for assuming match was cancelled. A gold 1 player should know to have their hero picked and ready to support when the match begins. The other team will have more ult charge than your team so the repercussions of this mistake are going to be felt for awhile.
The second stand off at the gate was debatable if it was your fault or not. You were holding the choke until bastion ulted you. I would argue that if you had better movement when you heard the bastion ult begin that you could have survived but I’m not sure most gold 4’s would have survived so I’ll just say it was a great play by their bastion… The choke was lost because of your death but it’s not really your fault.
Next standoff: Your team was holding just fine, the genji dies because he made a mistake so if you lose this hold it’s his fault, but your Orisa was smart enough to know to equal the playing field by using an ult and getting a kill, and you were smart enough to nano boost her which helped get the kill and even the playing field, great work, you’re holding the choke again. But then instead of healing your orisa you shoot at the enemy team and your Orisa dies. You could have shot your Orisa and healed her and you had a heal nade! 100% she dies because of you. You throw the nade after the orisa was dead. So now your mercy corrects your mistake by using her resurrection on Orisa, she leaves the Ashe for two seconds and Ashe dies because you didn’t heal her. If you hadn’t of wasted your nade a moment ago the ashe would have lived, or if you had simply hit your shots on her right in front of you then she would have lived. Think about how the mercy feels, she leaves for two seconds to rez your mistake and you let the person she was just healing die, right in front of you! Despite the Ashe dying you possibly had a chance of holding it but then Orisa stepped into a trap and you missed all your shots on her despite being zoomed in and she dies because of you. You were given about three chances to hold that choke and it was lost all three times because of mistakes you made.
The fourth standoff was lost because of you. You were getting engaged by the other teams Orisa, you were at half health and instead of healing yourself with your nade and surviving you threw it at her and she killed you. There is no way you should have died there. From there it snowballs and your team never recovers from that mistake and they get to the next checkpoint.
Next standoff is lost because of your Ashe and mercy. Not on you.
From there you hold the choke and the enemy doesn’t get the third checkpoint.
NEXT ROUND:
You guys take first point.
Pushing fine until genji dies, its his mistake. You probably could have saved it and kept pushing but I wouldn’t expect that from Gold1 / Plat 4 so I don’t hold you accountable. Not your fault.
Your team regroups and you start pushing, your ashe dies, it was her fault, you definitely could have saved her but again nobody should expect higher level play from you so not your fault. A diamond would have known to assist your ashe in taking high ground and could have grabbed her to safety or started healing her, but again, not your fault. Your DVA goes in a little too far and she gets out of Mek, you definitely could have saved her by peaking through and healing but you just didn’t. You didn’t really have a decent chance of dying so no reason not to. If you had lost this push it would have been your fault but somehow you guys recover and take the checkpoint. No harm no foul.
Everyone does a decent job until the cart gets close to the winning checkpoint. There was a moment where your DVA got out of mek but didn’t have to (you could have grabbed her out), she wasted her DVA bomb, you had poor placement with tree of life. The last point not getting taken wasn’t necessarily your fault, I’d put that more on the DPS. HOWEVER, I’m not sure the other team would have ever made it that far had you not made the mistakes in the first half. I wouldn’t put the loss on you but I’d say if you have put a different Gold4 / Plat 1 healer in there there’s a very good chance your team would have won.
The matchmaker is definitely broken, but I can’t give this one to you. You made too many basic mistakes eve at this tier. You didn’t even have anything diving you. You were free to just stand there and heal and still made mistakes, I think your team would have won if you had just healed at those key moments.
I would say based on what I observe that you’re probably playing at around a Gold 3/4 level of play. The game should have never let you get into plat (assuming you solo queued, if you grouped then that’s a different story) which shows the matchmaker is broken.
The matchmaker is broken but this was probably a fair match.