It’s not that they’re not strict. It’s just that they’re more complicated than what most people understand about them.
I haven’t attacked your character in this discussion. I’d appreciate it if you paid me the same respect.
Complicated =/= not binary or spectrum
Computers are complicated but are entirely binary in operation.
No, always.
If a male has XX chromosomes, there’s something different about their XX chromosomes than ones typically found in females. Specifically, they have a male determinate gene locus in their X chromosome that’s usually found in Y. That’s where the binary actually lies.
It’s still binary. It’s just more complex than boiling it down to chromosomes. You’re getting lost in the complexity, and simply saying “it’s not binary” is your way of trying to make sense of that complexity.
It’s defined by something in the chromosomes, which I’ve said over three times by now.
That’s incorrect. It’s still binary, because it’s still determined by a specific genetic locus. Your confusion lies with the fact that a genetic locus that’s usually in a Y chromosome can occasionally be found in an X chromosome. That doesn’t make the determinant non-binary. It just makes the determinant more complicated.
It doesn’t need a cause to be binary.
If someone is asking a question, they can set the premise of the question however they like. The answer to the question may or may not be determined by variables outside of our control. But the premise of the question is not out of our control. To change the variables in the question is to change the question itself. But since I was the one asking the question, you changing my question isn’t a valid response.
For example, if you asked an Overwatch pro “how do I climb to Top 500” and their response is “You’re actually asking my how to climb in Valorant”, they are changing the premise of the question, which is not a valid response to your question.
1 + 1 is the question that was set forth as an example, and there’s a corresponding answer. For you to then retort with “The 1 is actually an X, and the other the Y”, you change the premise of the question being asked.