Honestly, I think the root cause for Hog being in the state he is in rn is due to 5v5.
People say that no hero was ever designed for 5v5 or 6v6, they would just happen to have strengths and weaknesses that the other player in that role could capitalize or make up for. I would say that they are right, but some of the designs just make you ask that question. Wrecking Ball, a tank that perfectly encapsulates what an “off tank” should be, but ball is not in a very good state at all in OW2, due to the format switch.
Hog is sort of in the same boat. If I am being 100% honest, I lied about the rework not being bad, I DESPISE playing as or against Hog. He needed the rework though, in order to function as an actual sponge for the insane amount of damage that he can’t mitigate other than his damage reduction.
Having another tank, mainly a shield tank, could drastically change how Hog could be played. Hog could take more aggressive angles with a second tank. I hate how they did the heal though, since a tank like Rein, just CAN’T do damage unless you charge/shatter him in the middle of the breather, same thing for a tank like Winston or Ball.
They will be forced to rework the entire tank roster to fit into the 5v5 format, and all of the new tanks will have an ability like shout or nemesis form, where you get close to killing them, but then they press a button and don’t die. They really need something like season 9, which thankfully is in a day or two, since everything about the tank role currently (and maybe even in season 9 with the dps passive) is absolutely miserable. I have personally seen COUNTLESS players say that tank makes them upset/sad when they play it, the reason we went to 5v5 in the first place was most likely queue times, since nobody was playing tank in some elo ranges back in 6v6, but if the tank player base is getting to the point that is was at near the end of OW1, you know that it’s bad.
Sorry for the essay lol, kinda got carried away. I just think 6v6 was more balanced and enjoyable when I played it, and I have played OW2 almost daily since launch, minus a few week or so breaks, and the tank role was not as miserable as it is in this game, mostly because of counter picking, and Hog.