My Bestiary is at 185/186 pages. How long until I finish it

This morning, on my first Monstrous Essence hand-in, I got the penultimate missing page of new the Bestiary entries…

This means that I now have 185/186 pages unlocked…

So, how many hand-ins / days will it take to get the missing page?

Well, it’s time for some maths…

  • Chance that a hand-in of Monstous Essence will give the missing page = 1/186
  • Chance that a hand-in of Monstous Essence will not give the missing page = 185/186
  • Chance that none of X hand-ins of Monstrous Essence will give the missing page = (185/186)^X

Now, remember that only the first three hand-ins per day can result in a missing page and, whilst the first hand-in apparently has a higher chance of giving a missing page, no-one other than Blizzard knows how much that increase is (as they’ve never publicly stated it) so I’m just going to ignore that for now.

Some example values for X, using 30 days = 1 month, for ease of calculations…

Chance that none of 21 hand-ins will give the missing page = (185/186)^21 = 0.89296

So, after a week, 89% of players wouldn’t have the page.

Chance that none of 90 hand-ins will give the missing page = (185/186)^90 = 0.61558

So, after a month, 61% of players wouldn’t have the page.

Chance that none of 270 hand-ins will give the missing page = (185/186)^270 = 0.23327

So, after three months, 23% of players wouldn’t have the page.

Chance that none of 540 hand-ins will give the missing page = (185/186)^540 = 0.05441

So, after six months, 5% of players wouldn’t have the page.

Chance that none of 1080 hand-ins will give the missing page = (185/186)^1080 = 0.00296

So, after a year, 0.2% of players wouldn’t have the page.

Let’s see where I end up on the Binomial Distribution curve of luckiness.

I’ll update when I get the last page.

3 Likes

im gonna bet that im one of those 0.2% unlucky people

I completed it on January 14.
I was lucky.

My post on a Korean community
https://cafe.naver.com/diabloimmortalkr/2857

1 Like

You “just” need to encounter the mob to “unlock” the page. Normally, there was an update that facilitate the proc of new pages but you need to encounter and probably kill it.

This was the case last time with the last helliquary boss. As soon as I killed it, the page was discovered in the next few bestiaries.

2 Likes

I think it boosts the chances but supposedly not required. I’m still missing 5 but I also don’t turn in 3 daily all the time.

I only do 1 a day and I’m on 183/186.

The previous time they added pages I got them all in two weeks.

You might get the last one tomorrow or you might have to wait a year. That’s RNG for you. Good luck!:hugs:

No you don’t. The pages you get have absolutely nothing to do with mobs you’ve encountered / killed. The pages you are awarded are completely random from the available pool.

1 Like

Got the last page on my third hand-in today…

So, that was 17 turn-ins after the one in the opening post.

Chance that none of 16 hand-ins will give the missing page = (185.186)^16 = 0.91736

So, roughly 91% of players wouldn’t get it that fast.

Looks like I was on the very lucky end of the Binomial Distribution curve.

4 Likes

Hahaha, called it!:joy: :wink:

By the way, I don’t think you can apply that theory effectively on this.

It’s the same as when you get the same dungeon 5 times in a row while queueing up for random. Randomness does not take into account past results, the chance is the same on every single try.

There might be a system that increases your chances over time, like with 5* leg gems, but with bestiary pages, I doubt it.

At no time did my calculations suggest that there was any causality between previous and ongoing results. Each event is discrete from the others.

Indeed, but I’m talking about the cumulative chance, not the individual event chance.

For example, if you flip a coin, the chances of not getting heads is 1/2.
But, if you flip a coin 10 times, the chances of not getting any heads is (1/2)^10 = 1/1024.

The last time I had just one page missing, it took me a couple of months, of three hand-ins per day, to get it, i.e. roughly 180 attempts, so I tend to doubt that too.

Ugh, wow. I just logged in to ask about 1 missing page to see if it was a bug, guess I’ve been missing my 186th for 6+ months now given these dates. With that boosted first turnin effect every time they add a batch of 5-10 new pages it normally only takes me like 2 weeks to complete, but this last one isn’t showing.

A 296 thousanth of a chance is almost a self creating facepalm :rofl:
You should buy a lottery ticket.

180/186 here..

3 turn-ins every day, think the last time I got one was back in.. uh.. January? February? I totally lost track.
This rng is ridiculous.

Yeah I’m surprised there was never an actual pity system added for this. But then there is nothing really ‘beneficial’ to completing so prob less reason to

Indeed, there’s really no detriment other than the sense of completion for not having all pages unlocked. Thus a pity system isn’t needed here. Would be nice though.

I’ve been at 185/186 pages for quite some time now. Doesn’t bother me, it’ll unlock eventually when the RNG hits just right.

1 Like

So, February to July and half of August with no new page.
Let’s say 6.5 * 30 days of 3 hand-ins per day, that’s 195 hand-ins.

  • Chance that none of X hand-ins of Monstrous Essence will give the missing page = (180/186)^X
  • Chance that none of 195 hand-ins of Monstrous Essence will give the missing page = (180/186)^195 = 0.00167153

Roughly 1 in 598 players would get that result.

Do all Elite and side quests if you haven’t. Also, every HQ boss.

Those that say there is no pity counter or you do not need to defeat a particular monster to reveal the page are sadly mistaken - search Reddit threads, it’s explained there in detail.

There is a big boost (unknown %, but noticeable) on the first turn-in of each day, which seems to always slip past the other poster’s calculations when he knows it exists. Not sure why…perhaps an ego boost to give him some validation that he achieved something almost as rare as winning the Powerball? Idk, but I can’t wait for the “Dev said it doesn’t matter if you kill a monster” replies with zero proof.

Happy hunting.

Blizzard have never said what the increase for the first hand-in of the day is.
So how do you expect anyone to be able to include the increase in their calculations?

I can’t wait for you to provide a link to a Blizzard source saying it is required.

1 Like

There’s zero proof that killing a specific monster is required or that it boosts unlocking a page.

“Just google it” is not proof of anything.

1 Like