Hey everyone,
I’ve been playing Diablo Immortal since launch, and like a lot of players, I’ve always managed to maintain a consistent win rate (historically never dipping below 60%). But this season has felt completely broken. I just watched my win rate slide from 46% down to 44% entirely off a relentless, uninterrupted losing streak right as I hit the Gold II threshold and got dragged back down into Gold I. Matches feel like an absolute lottery that the algorithm has already decided before it even starts. I have an average 4k resonance with average secondaries and play the current warlock meta build but it hasn’t helped.
A few issues are making the current system feel unplayable:
1. The Secondary Stat Wall: I am constantly running into hyper-optimized low-resonance smurfs/ who have maxed-out secondary stats . These people have 4k resonance but 11k secondaries. This is non stop all the time.
2. The Death of “Corrective” Matching: It used to feel like if you hit a brutal losing streak, the matchmaker would at least attempt to balance the scales or throw you a lifeline lobby. Now? It just feeds you right back into completely lopsided, unwinnable matches time after time.
3. Zero Point Mitigation: Taking a full-point penalty (like -12) when a lobby is skewed against you from the second it forms—especially during an unavoidable slide across rank boundaries—makes the grind intensely discouraging. You get no compensation because the players are smurfing so the system clearly does not take secondaries into account like they have been saying. its a lie.
Is anyone else who has a long history with the game suddenly seeing their win rates tank into the 40s? It feels like the matchmaking parameters shifted away from actual lobby balance in favor of raw queue speed, leaving mid-tier and veteran players high and dry. You can see pictures on my reddit post since I can’t post them here. https://www.reddit.com/r/DiabloImmortal/comments/1ww4yma/i_just_hit_a_44_win_rate_wall_what_happened_to/
Would love to hear if others are noticing this wall, or if community managers have any visibility on how secondary scaling and rank algorithms are currently being calculated.
2 Likes
Nope.
I’ve played since the day the servers went live.
I’m currently halfway through Gold III, with a 64% win rate.
Around 3.6K resonance, secondaries 5-5.5K
1 Like
Thats awesome for you. Now check my pictures and tell me why mine is 44%? And why I am constantly getting whale smurfers with absolutely no balance whatsoever? 7 matches in a row, 10 matches in a row. Is it a bug? A glitch? Thats what I want to find out because this has never ever happened before. To reiterate, I have reached legend easily every season and never had a win rate below 60% so something is obviously wrong.
2 Likes
I have no idea why. You asked if others were seeing the same thing, so I responded that I wasn’t. In your Reddit thread there was also a respondent with 1.6K resonance at Legend with a 70% win rate.
1 Like
I appreciate your response and yes, I saw that claim and that isn’t helping answer my question. can you consult with someone who actually might have an answer? dont you think 44% win rate would be an anomaly? A bug? Especially if it has never happened before?
1 Like
Just for demonstration, let’s assume that you’re just as likely to be put in a winning team as a losing one, i.e. over a large number of matches, your win-rate would be 50%.
With that assumption, would a 44% win-rate be unusual?
Let’s take a look at it with…
Binomial Distribution Calculator
…and do the calculations for 100 matches.
On the unluckier end of the distribution curve (44% win-rate)…
- Number of events = 100
- Probability of success per event = 50%
- What is the probability of getting 44% or more successes = 90.33%
- Mean number of successes = 50
- Standard deviation = 5
On the directly but opposite end of the distribution curve (56% win-rate)…
- Number of events = 100
- Probability of success per event = 50%
- What is the probability of getting 56% or more successes = 13.563%
- Mean number of successes = 50
- Standard deviation = 5
But what about your historical rate (60% win-rate)…
- Number of events = 100
- Probability of success per event = 50%
- What is the probability of getting 60% or more successes = 2.844%
- Mean number of successes = 50
- Standard deviation = 5
Now what about my current rate (64% win-rate)…
- Number of events = 100
- Probability of success per event = 50%
- What is the probability of getting 64% or more successes = 0.33186%
- Mean number of successes = 50
- Standard deviation = 5
What about the guy from the Reddit thread (70% win-rate)…
- Number of events = 100
- Probability of success per event = 50%
- What is the probability of getting 70% or more successes = 0.003925%
- Mean number of successes = 50
- Standard deviation = 5
If the base rate is 50%, your historical win-rate of 60% is more unusual than your current 44% rate is.
1 Like
I am at my usual 68% winrate but only gold 3 atm, the season feels harder then any other mostly because everbody seems to play warlock and the pets are really a pain for my sader, there are multiple very broken builds at other classes too, especially demon hunters with higher reso deletes me sometimes in 1 hit before i even can see what is going on and the wizzard has like always a very strong build that can kill you in 1-2 bad hits too if you are unlucky.
As you already play one of the strongest classes at game there is maybe something you should try:
1. Never ever play the new battleground (convoy) the possibility that whales team up there and you get a bad group which cant hold up to that is too high, always play classic battleground.
2. If you loose one game after another try to skip the next battleground and wait a little longer, it is possible that you always fight the same enemies you wasnt able to deal before with and i would avoid to play at weekends and later hours because i have seen the biggest whales mostly at this times.
3. Maybe a class change or some replacements of gems can bring you into other lobbys, the reason why mostly low resos sit at the top of the leaderboards is that they get easier groups or dont be expected to make the game, as a 4k you are on the edge from low to mid reso which brings you at harder games anyway.
4 Likes
My winrate for Gold 1: 
https://i.postimg.cc/yd545fK8/c2.png
So I can’t say I am detecting any severe anomaly in the BG Matchmaking.
Still encountering a lot of uneven tanks for both teams, though.
Also, I am no longer play BG Convoy as well. It was a better mode than BG Assault but because of the duo queue, it really can make you lose for the whole night if you are unlucky, so I am avoiding it now.
And yes, just as Thorba said, if you lose the match, please wait like 2-3 minutes (my thumb rule) before queuing. From my experience, if you instant queue, you most likely will end up facing the same enemies that just trashed you or end up with the same teammate that is a liability.
P.S. Maybe I will play Convoy if it doesn’t share the win rate as BG Assault. 
1 Like
Hmm, your screenshot shows a 77% win-rate…
- Number of events = 100
- Probability of success per event = 50%
- What is the probability of getting 77% or more successes = 0.000002757%
- Mean number of successes = 50
- Standard deviation = 5
Look carefully at that percentage. 
Appreciate the binomial breakdown, but that math only works if Battleground matchmaking is a completely random, blind 50/50 coin flip. It isn’t.
An active matchmaking algorithm is supposed to dynamically balance teams, adjust for hidden ratings, and account for massive power gaps. Treating a player with a consistent, long-term 60%+ historical win rate like they’re just experiencing standard deviation when they suddenly hit a brick wall at 44% ignores how the matchmaking engine actually behaves.
When the system consistently pairs you into lobbies weighed down by massive secondary stat walls and optimized low-resonance setups without any corrective balancing, it stops being ‘random luck’ and starts being a matchmaking parameter issue. If the baseline assumption is that everyone naturally trends toward 50% regardless of skill or matchmaking design, why even have hidden MMR or rankings at all?
A binomial distribution is an absurd model for battleground matchmaking. I made legend at 78% win rate this season. Last season I got 5500 score with 69% win rate.
Matchmaking only takes into account reso/stats. It doesn’t, for example, take into account my better than average familiars, duo queue, etc.
I’m facing 14k secondaries daily and still winning 78% of the time. If you have 44% win rate, it’s a you problem.
2 Likes
Okay, so you’re rejecting the idea that it’s roughly as likely to be on a winning side as a losing side, i.e. a baseline of 50% win-rate. Cool, so what’s your explanation for your 44% win-rate when you have me with 64%, the guy from Reddit with 70%, Kilometer with 77%, and Denzel with 78%? If it’s a broken match-making algorithm, why aren’t we also being affected?
2 Likes
They’re smurfing and I dont? And it’s a coin toss or there’s weighted matchmaking. Can’t be both.
1 Like
lol, so everyone with a better win-rate than you has to be cheating?
I have 3.3k reso. How much lower can I smurf further down? I am not a whale spender; there is a limit to how high my secondary can be, either.
Here is my in-game character sheet: 
https://i.postimg.cc/HkrsGjP5/c2.png
You’re playing a warlock. You just have to press one button.
If I were playing WL, I would have at least 5,000 points right now.