Never played Grim Dawn and witcher was so long ago i dont remember but if those systems worked then yes i suppose.
Anything is better than the nothing i feel we have now.
I want to feel like im involved and making impactful choices that will either make or break my next NMD. Not just have 1 potion that gives me 15% poison protection.
In the same NMD ive had poisonous spiders, Ghosts, Goatmen, Skjeletons and died to fire from mini bosses. Been stunned then pummeled to death while i coulldnt move.
The current system lets me partially prevent 1 thing ata time. It just feels VERY disconnected and almost meaningless.