I am pretty sure one I have now is better, but this 1 just dropped. I’d imagine if it rolled 10cc vs 8cc, i’d be much closer if not better, but i figured i’d check to be sure.
https://i.imgur.com/LWNvxnh.png
I am pretty sure one I have now is better, but this 1 just dropped. I’d imagine if it rolled 10cc vs 8cc, i’d be much closer if not better, but i figured i’d check to be sure.
https://i.imgur.com/LWNvxnh.png
The non ancient with AD is better by a lot.
I disagree.
Ancient has more +720 dex, +2% crit, and +17% legendary bonus. That AD isn’t going to make up for all of those, let alone surpass them.
It depends if you’re pushing, the 20% area damage is very strong for solo push due to the cubic scaling of Devouring Arrow with density and area damage.
That said, the Ancient is better otherwise due to more toughness and a bit more raw damage.
Affix is worth about 2.5% more dps, higher dex + CHC a little under 5% it looks like from the tooltip. So around 7-8% total dps. If it was just the dps difference and not a toughness difference, you could make an argument for area damage vs. the 7-8% flat dps, depending on how much area damage you already have. That’s basically the same damage tradeoff as ancient damage range on a ring vs. area damage. And you can justify that, depending on what you’re pushing and what else you have on your gear.
The difference maker here is the toughness in my opinion. 7-8% dps AND 6-7% toughness vs. 20% AD is a much less enticing trade. The toughness pushes it over the edge for me.
So I agree with Iria here.
Looks like he’s running Valla’s/Dawn now, so maybe the question is no longer meaningful.
I think AD is overvalued in most cases. If you’re a top player and you’re playing high GRs and you can group up mobs effectively, then it’s great. Otherwise, it’s okay or possibly worthless.
But ignoring my opinion, and looking at the quivers again, what about the HA damage vs AD? He could re-roll the HA on the ancient to AD. Then it would be a question of HA on non-ancient vs Dex+Crit+Leg on the ancient.
I am running both. I am runnin this one doing 112 speeds. But, for push, I feel like quiver + ballista is better for crowd control