I’m sure to most players it won’t destroy the ‘feeling’ of the game. However the more time you spend on learning and understanding D2’s mechanics, the more of an impact the charms have on the whole game. So if someone ever gets beyond casual, they will probably just drop the game because this mechanic limits any encouragement to go deeper.
Noone is arguing, changes to expand build viability isn’t wanted. Its this execution specifically that is so awful and game breaking, and against the spirit of the game.